Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    363
  • comments
    1,100
  • views
    266,578

DQ's letter grades for Thomas & Friends (Series 17-Present)


Dark Qiviut

1,061 views

If you reviewed this page to see my grades for various FIM media along with the three-parter analyzing the ten worst and best FIM episodes (Part 1; Part 2; Part 3), the standards I put on them apply here. Each grade you see listed beside each episode and aforementioned movie specials will determine the episode's overall quality (at least through my own observations). No explanations given, but if you want, I'll be glad to do it.

 

Also, this blog will cover the TtTE episodes from Series 17 and beyond. I have a lot of fondness over the classic series, and I don't know if I'll grade them fairly, so they won't be graded. Because Series 17 marks the revolution of Thomas back in the classic days and I believe I can judge them more fairly, I'll focus on them only.

 

Series 18 of Thomas & Friends has just begun airing in the UK, and Tale of the Brave should be available in the UK and US very soon. Some episode titles have been released, and not all the episodes have aired in Australia or America, so there will be some spoilers.

 

Be warned, these grades are subject to change, and some will have two instead of one because I can't gauge its quality at this point. They may be better or worse over time. So let's get started!

 



Series 17:
  • King of the Railway: B

  1. Kevin's Cranky Friend: B
  2. Scruff's Makeover: B-
  3. Wayward Winston: B+
  4. Gordon Runs Dry: D
  5. Calm Down Caitlin: B+
  6. Steamie Stafford: C-
  7. Henry's Hero: B
  8. Luke's New Friend: B+
  9. The Switch: A-
  10. Not Now, Charlie!: F
  11. The Lost Puff: A-
  12. The Thomas Way: B+
  13. The Phantom Express: C+
  14. Percy's Lucky Day: B
  15. Bill or Ben?: A
  16. Too Many Fire Engines: B
  17. No Snow for Thomas: C
  18. Santa's Little Engine: B-
  19. The Missing Christmas Decorations: B-
  20. The Frozen Turntable: A-
  21. Away from the Sea: B
  22. Gone Fishing: A
  23. The Afternoon Tea Express: D+
  24. The Smelly Kipper: B+
  25. No More Mr. Nice Engine: A-
  26. Thomas' Shortcut: B


———

 


Series 18:

  • Tale of the Brave: A-

  1. Old Reliable Edward: B-
  2. Not So Slow Coaches: B-
  3. Flatbeds of Fear: C
  4. Disappearing Diesels: B
  5. Signals Crossed: D-
  6. Toad's Adventure: C+
  7. Duck in the Water: B+
  8. Duck and the Slip Coaches: A
  9. Thomas the Quarry Engine: A-
  10. Thomas and the Emergency Cable: B-
  11. Duncan and the Grumpy Passenger: B
  12. Marion and the Pipe: D+
  13. Missing Gator: B
  14. No Steam Without Coal: B+
  15. Spencer's VIP: C+
  16. Toad's Bright Idea: A-
  17. Last Train for Christmas: A
  18. Long Lost Friend: C+
  19. Duncan the Humbug: A
  20. The Perfect Gift: B-
  21. Marion & the Dinosaur: C+
  22. Millie & the Volcano: B-
  23. Samson at Your Service: C
  24. Timothy and the Rainbow Truck: B
  25. Emily Saves the World: F
  26. Samson Sent for Scrap: B+


———

  • The Adventure Begins: B-

  1. Toad and the Whale: A
  2. The Truth about Toby: B-


———

  • Brohoof 1

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...