28 replies to this topic

[GameBeaver]

I was thinking of a Brony/Pegasister (Female Brony) (is)land. Just one land where all Bronies live in peace and happiness with at least one subject everyone likes: My Little Pony. Of course we need to protect ourselfs so we do need weapons. We are one country then. Whats your opinion?

[Crystal Sparkle]

To live, like...forever? I not so sure...

[Raiden]

As much as I love the idea, I feel that we would eventually not get along, which would lead to arguments/exile from group. Also, supplies would be a big problem, along with greediness.

[Lady Rarity Pony]

We can go to my island. Ireland. That's right, mine.

Edited by Lady Rarity Pony, 14 May 2012 - 10:00 AM.

[GameBeaver]

To live, like...forever? I not so sure...

of course you can get out of the country to visit someone but only bronies and pegasisters can get in

As much as I love the idea, I feel that we would eventually not get along, which would lead to arguments/exile from group. Also, supplies would be a big problem, along with greediness.

we can get our own supplies or import them

[Gizmo]

Civil war would break out very fast with everyone declaring "______ IS BEST PONY"
And thus is how Twilight Sparkle and Rarity battle to the death.

[PixelWin]

Or we can buy the nation called sealand nation. and make it MLP nation. Sealand nation was made by one person

[Kaborer]

No, I wouldn't like it. It would get boring to talk about ponies all the time, because it's basically the only thing you've got in common with all the other people. Resources would be a problem, since we live in a capitalist world. We need something to sell to be able to buy, and honestly, apart from bronies and girls, who else would buy stuff we produce? We would have to set up a whole new society and start a government, but who would lead that? How would we agree on how the country should be run?
I would get sick of being a brony if this was the case, I believe there needs to be more difference in a society and I don't think we have enough grown-up people (sure we have a good amount but nowhere near what we would need for a whole country).
I don't think we're enough people for this idea.
Another thing is: If we intend to keep our reputation about love and tolerance, it would be highly hypocritical bringing weapons.
I definitely don't think it would be very idyllic, we would all just have a life pretty much a harder-working life, assuming we don't all get into a fight.

TLDR: Bad idea

Also, where the buck would we get this (is)land from?

Edited by Kaborer, 14 May 2012 - 10:36 AM.

[Shankveld]

Because segregation is always a good thing /sarcasm
There are a lot of wonderful non-bronies
and a lot of nasty bronies.
~

[PixelWin]

No, I wouldn't like it. It would get boring to talk about ponies all the time, because it's basically the only thing you've got in common with all the other people. Resources would be a problem, since we live in a capitalist world. We need something to sell to be able to buy, and honestly, apart from bronies and girls, who else would buy stuff we produce? We would have to set up a whole new society and start a government, but who would lead that? How would we agree on how the country should be run?
I would get sick of being a brony if this was the case, I believe there needs to be more difference in a society and I don't think we have enough grown-up people (sure we have a good amount but nowhere near what we would need for a whole country).
I don't think we're enough people for this idea.
Another thing is: If we intend to keep our reputation about love and tolerance, it would be highly hypocritical bringing weapons.
I definitely don't think it would be very idyllic, we would all just have a life pretty much a harder-working life, assuming we don't all get into a fight.

TLDR: Bad idea

Also, where the buck would we get this (is)land from?

Sealand nation! Look it up! but I agree with you

[Fox]

We can protect ourselves with Twilight Sparkle on our side.

[Champion RD92]

I was thinking of a Brony/Pegasister (Female Brony) (is)land. Just one land where all Bronies live in peace and happiness with at least one subject everyone likes: My Little Pony. Of course we need to protect ourselfs so we do need weapons. We are one country then. Whats your opinion?

Now for a more serious answer...

I would rather just live in Equestria with the ponies >.>

I doubt that every single brony is gonna be able to live together in peace and happiness...that doesn't seem very plausible.

[Cloud-Kicker]

Maybe as a temporary thing for visiting and vacation.
A place run by bronies, for bronies, to visit whenever they please. I mean,If they really want to.
Just an MLP Theme Park would suffice. Not so sure about an entire island or nation

[NewCalamity]

Bad idea.

You remember Lord of the Flies, yes?

[Aureity]

If everyone sticks to the brony ideal of love and tolerance, I don't see why we couldn't function as a happy group.
Assuming we don't split into a "who is best pony" war and kill each other off.

Edited by Aureitas d'Aequitate, 14 May 2012 - 11:47 AM.

[Love4shadow~]

That'd be a good idea because we could show are love for mlp without worrying about being judged or whatever. But it'd be bad because me personally, I'd feel trapped and if I ever got out of being a pegasister, like just had enough of mlp, I'd have to leave the land and therefore leave all my friends I made there.

[~Chaotic Discord~]

Like what's been said before, it's far harder to cut a line between all the wonderful bronies and then everyone else, because like has been said, there are plenty of jerk bronies and a lot of great non-bronies. So, eh. Not really in favor.

[HylianTwilian]

Sounds...Great? I'll be in charge of weapons!

[Lady Rarity Pony]

We can protect ourselves with Twilight Sparkle on our side.

My dirty mind is making that image look like something it shouldn't be.

[Jokuc]

Haha, are you serious?
Anyways, sounds wonderful but there is no way that is going to work.