Do you think the Mane 6 are cuter humans than Ponies?

[Violet Hoof 1]

naw i think the ponies are much cuter then the human form there mmaking a EQG tv show im a little bit spectacle about hopeing its going to do as well as MLP

[Natasha 56]

The human versions were cute from the waist up. What I found un-nerving was how their legs were so darn long and their skirts were so short.

[Cerbyrus 63]

I prefer the pony versions. Mainly because, obviously, I've known them as ponies for a longer time, and I really don't like the human models. Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie looked pretty cute IMO, and Rarity looked good also, just her skin colour should've been a bit closer to the caucasian skin colour. I really didn't like the other models.

[Winona the Dog 1,981]

Being Attractive and being cute are two different things.

 

Ponies are cute but humans are attractive. There's not much I can really say besides that.

[Flutter's lover <3 8,204]

No. Even though I liked the movie...I just can't really compare them...I don't think I would've gotten into this fandomif the show had humans in it....I came here for the ponies.I find the ponies adorable, cute,attractive and sexy. The humanized versions,I don't see any of that...other then their eyes/face ,maybe.

[Dsanders 5,742]

The ponies are definitely cuter than the humans. I mean come on. Take my favorite pony, Pinkie Pie, for example.

 

Pinkie Pie's smile, her poofy mane and tail, her pink coat and abnormally huge eyes. I just have to go with as to being a lot cuter than the human Pinkie Pie!

 

 

^I mean come on!

 

The human version of Pinkie Pie is adorable and cute as well. But nothing beats the ponies!

 

Though as a human, she does seem quite attractive, if you know what I mean.

Edited October 12, 2013 by Dsanders

[BariSax 0]

I agree to a certain extend. Having watched Equestria Girls 15 times, I have seen the main six as humans a lot. Of the Main six, FlutterShy and Pinkie Pie are the cutest as humans or ponies. With the other main six, I have issues with them. 

[Cwanky 17,455]

Honestly if they better or differently designed I think the Mane 6 as humans could have been a lot better. Their original design as ponies was superior by far.

 

And yes if it wasn't said already, as humans they all had identical designs more/less that made them look like bratz and barbie dolls. Blechh.

[Discointhe90s 58]

I cant decide  on this they are both flipping adorable it would be impossible to choose its like picking a favorite pony they both are adorable in their own way

[Troblems 5,608]

I can't say the humans were cuter, however, some of the things they did reminded me of how much I do genuinely love the show, such as the recap of Twi and Flutters first encounter. Also, Flutter being able to tuck her hair behind her ear? Priceless!

[ponies4fun 9]

They were cute as ponies and as humans. But for humans there was other flavors since you know they wore clothes. Twilight in particular got a boost in cuteness for me as a human though.

[Shanks 10,811]

No, not at all there are some fanart of them in their human forms that can rival them but not the Equestria Girls versions. The only one that was just as cute was Fluttershy but then again it is almost impossible to not make her cute.

[Pikadash 7]

Twilight: No

Rainbow:

Applejack: Yes

Pinkie: No

Fluttershy: No

Rarity: No

 

Personally i don't find them attractive as ponies or humans, but i prefer the ponies in any case

[Ianpiersonjdavis 512]

No.

 

Based on my own preference;

 

Dashie is tied.

 

Pinkie is tied.

 

Twilight is cuter as a pony.

 

Rarity is cuter as a pony.

 

Fluttershy is cuter as a pony.

 

So, with roughly 2 out of 6, I'm afraid I'm going to have to say no.

 

Sorry...

[DaReaper 1,943]

while the human versions look great they just lack the cutness the ponies have, so yeah the ponies are definitly cuter to me at least. Side note is it me or did Scootaloo actualy look like she could be a human?

[Noazark 67]

Definitely not, I really don't like their design. I love the show because they are ponies, not because they're brightly colored barbies.

[KikiTwilight 90]

I must admit I really liked their human looks a lot, but nope, I can't say they are cuter. Their pony selves are still their pony selves. They are adorable both ways, though.

[Guest]

cute, to me, would obviously be the ponies. "dawh look a cutie wittle pony<3"

 

but attractive and pretty, would be the humans.

 

all looked good. i liked twi's, aj's, flutters, and pinkie's look the most in human form,

 

rarity's white skin and dashie's blue skin looked...odd. to me.

[*Rarity 123]

They are cute in a different way in EQG compared to the show. I don't really like the style on Pinkie Pie/Twilligt/Fluttershy as EQG's...

Rarity, Dashie, and Applejack however, look REALLY GREAT as Equestria Girls, oh, and so does Trixie!

Wouldn't say either one is "cuter", they're just different, and they look amaaazing in different ways.

[Cyan Blue 946]

In my opinion I find the pony version much more cute than the human version.

 

I'm not really attracted to MLP, as other people are. Looking at them while human just confuses me on so many levels.

[Pomfritter 165]

When I think of the word "cute" I think of stuff such as appearance. Their personalities were the same so that isn't worth mentioning, but their appearance did chance. As ponies, they are cuter in my opinion because of their rounded edges and the by the ways they act. Having ponies act in ways that humans do is cuter than humans doing human things. I suppose Twilight trying to act human was a cute behavior, but for the most part, I'd go with the ponies.

[Koelath 444]

They're pretty cute as "humans" but honestly, the very nature of ponies makes them cuter. Carrying stuff in their mouths, sniffing around like dogs and stuff...

 

Also, MLP toys are pretty shit anyway but the Equestria Girls line look like horrible aliens.

[Pomfritter 165]

They're pretty cute as "humans" but honestly, the very nature of ponies makes them cuter. Carrying stuff in their mouths, sniffing around like dogs and stuff...

 

Also, MLP toys are pretty shit anyway but the Equestria Girls line look like horrible aliens.

 

It's difficult to make something with as vibrant colors as MLP in the real world. And them being ponies definitely doesn't help.

[Koelath 444]

It's difficult to make something with as vibrant colors as MLP in the real world. And them being ponies definitely doesn't help.

 

...What does the color have to do with anything? They don't look like aliens because of the colors. They look like aliens because whoever makes the toys didn't put noses on them.

[Abbsterdash 3]

OH YES! Thats all I can say...

I'm not acctually a big fan on real ponies XD Yeah,they are definately cuter and happier than normal ponies