draph91

ok, again why am I being reminded of Mare Do Well?

but I am raising a good point, aren't I?, also while I highly doubt that would be the case with the guards, heck he could have asked Twilight to help him

apology accepted also EquestrianScholar, I have a rebuttal, Celestia had no idea about the invaders, so she had no idea whether or not they could have been capable of breaking through the shield and.... now that I think of it why only shining armor to keep up the shield?, there are other unicorns in the guards, he could have asked them to help him, I'm pretty sure he could have taught them the shield spell

I have to agree, also why am I now thinking of the Mysterious Mare Do well

even so, I have a feeling that Bronies and Pegasisters will be debating this episode for quite a while over who was right and who was wrong, I still stand firm that the wedding should have been postponed until the threat passed, because if again they had no information about the enemy (someone correct me if I'm wrong), but I do agree Twilight should have found proof about her accusations (also is anyone here aware that someone could take Twilight being jealous the wrong way, right?)

I do agree with that actually

I know that but to me, it's like they didn't take the threat seriously, also apology accepted, but even though I still hate that episode. I have to agree with some bronies, Twilight could have been wrong about the imposter however I still remain firm that her friends should have taken her concerns seriously

uh no offense, but that reason for postponing the wedding is just stupid, they had no idea what they were facing, Celestia put her subjects at risk and I have to ask another question about Celestia, how many? also found another fanfiction http://www.fimfiction.net/story/176572/the-wedding-is-off-rewrite

I think my biggest problem with the two parter was the wedding itself, i mean holding a wedding when you've received a potential threat of an invasion, really?, like I posted before, the wedding should have been postponed until the threat had passed also one of the biggest debates from the two parter is this: Was Shining Armor being himself during his outburst towards Twilight at the end of Part 1 or was it a result of Queen Chrysalis' brainwashing?

but they abandoned their friend for a stranger someone who they had just met

i'm sorry but they did not, they were too busy with the wedding to listen to her, they forgot about Lesson Zero

the answer is simple: they DID not listen to her

Also what Luna said to Celestia, I agree with her also I have to ask this, what good is she? to those who are wondering this is it Not only did you, Shining Armor and Twilight's friends hurt her, you alienated her and drove her away! I do hope you know what it is to be ashamed, sister, because you deserve it. Nopony in their right mind should ever hurt anypony like that! You had a duty to protect and serve her as Princess of the Sun and as her mentor, but instead, you left her to whatever fate may have befallen her other than imprisonment! And by abandoning Twilight, you abandoned your kingdom, your subjects, and everything else in between! If Twilight had been murdered, then Equestria would have fallen months earlier!"

yeah in fact Mega-Diancie put it best in the comments of the last chapter of What Have You Done? and cloudedguardian put it best in the comments of the sequel Even As... -Back when Discord tested the Mane 6, Rainbow chose Cloudsdale over her friends. Loyalty didn't have an issue with this. She had to pick one or the other, and she had loyalties to both that were precious. She chose Cloudsdale. That was fine. But then Rainbow Dash rejected Loyalty. He didn't understand the why, but rather that she felt like she was no longer worthy. It took Twilight reminding Rainbow of her worth before he was accepted back as her Element. Then the wedding comes. Rainbow Dash chooses Cadence over Twilight. A Princess she has no loyalty with over her best friend. It may very well be that Loyalty still doesn't understand the why, but he knows one thing- Choosing someone else over friends equals lack of worth. Rainbow herself made that quite clear. But this time, there aren't any other precious loyalties, no wiggle room for forgiveness. And so Loyalty rejects her -Rarity was looking for praise for her dresses, her chance to be a bridesmaid, and a chance to suck up to Canterlot higher-ups. Something that is normally greedy for most of us as we would normally feel it if we were in her shoes, but she abandoned Twilight and chose the wedding over her, thus her greed over-shined her generosity. and so Generosity rejects her -Applejack promised to take Twilight more seriously whenever she was worried and to listen. But all she simply thought Twilight was being silly and refused to listen to her at ALL, which helped drive Twilight to making that confrontation in the hall as no pony would listen. And like that, a promise became a dirty lie. and so Honesty rejects her -Pinkie Pie was so concerned with her views of making sure the wedding was a happy time and seeing the good in the world while ignoring the bad, she failed to realize that Twilight was in dire need of comfort and hope, even thinking of her as a 'party-pooper'. Laughter means cheering up everyone who needs it, not just deluding yourself into focusing on the happy stuff and ignoring the bad. So by the time Pinkamena made her realize, it was already too late and so Laughter rejects her -As for Fluttershy...ignoring other's concerns, failing to realize someone is being cruel towards somepony and towards her birds due to the wedding or flat out ignoring it, and flat out abandoning a broken pony, choosing the wedding over her...That's even more cruel then she was than she was in 'assertive mode' and so Kindness rejects her As for Magic's words: Its understandable. Twilight's friends threw her away, sending her into despair. Now Magic is in despair because Twilight has turned her back on it due to her depression. also Trixie was right in Turnabout Storm about Friendship and I'm sadly agree with her “There’s no MAGIC in it—it’s just a word, nothing more, and it’s completely unnecessary."

hey has anyone here read the fanfiction What Have You Done? http://www.fimfiction.net/story/149998/what-have-you-done