Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    363
  • comments
    1,100
  • views
    266,602

The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone's false pretense


Dark Qiviut

1,238 views

When I wrote down the best and worst episodes of FIM (which should be updated), I called out One Bad Apple's wretched moral. Part of the problem was how it was treated as the solution to the whole child bullying problems in not just Ponyville, but also our own world. It's a dangerous false pretense because bullying is much more complicated than that, and there's no one right way to curb it.

 

The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone's moral may not be as screwed up as OBA's, but it's still screwed up. How? By being a one-size false pretense.

 

In this episode, Pinkie and Dash "realize" that Griffonstone is in complete disarray is because they're not helping each other and need to actually be friends to build their town back to former glory.

 

Nononononononononono!

 

Time-out!

 

Griffonstone is a wasteland. There's nothing exciting or endearing about this place. The houses are rundown. There's no food or water. Chances are they don't get much rain by how dry the ground and sky look. Present-day griffons have every reason to be grumpy: While others such as Ponyville and Canterlot thrive, Griffonstone looks war-torn, reminding me personally of how Germany looked following World War I. Very few sources are available because their economy is beyond terrible. It's literally nonexistent.

 

There's an implication of how greed led to very deep, rooted problems in Griffonstone. One way to heal itself for the future was through friendship and teamwork rather than societal seclusion. The problem is there's a deep disconnect between what the moral is trying to say and what it's saying. There's no reason to believe griffons here are greedy. Observe their terrible houses, stores, and food supplies; they're fighting for survival. They don't ask for money at any given turn for the fun of it. As comedic as many of the scenes are, the griffons are in very deep trouble. If they don't ask for money, they starve and will die.

 

The episode treats the moral as a one-size-fit-all solution to Griffonstone's problems (and by association, others in real life). That doesn't work. In fact, that solution is inappropriate for an episode like this. Why? Because it's dangerous. Even if society is welcoming and friends with each other, that still won't solve Griffonstone's economic and agricultural turmoil. It's so rooted that it'll take beyond merely friendship to restore Griffonstone. Friendship can only build so much, and it's a false pretense to believe otherwise. Sure, it's a start to maybe build Griffonstone back up, but the griffons are in a life-or-death predicament. Unfortunately, they don't completely treat it as such by making Griffonstone a cornerstone for "humor."

  • Brohoof 3

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

There's a bit of a disconnect, though. Wouldn't someone be considered greedy if they would potentially leave someone to die just because that person doesn't have the money to pay to be saved? 

  • Brohoof 3
Link to comment

There's a bit of a disconnect, though. Wouldn't someone be considered greedy if they would potentially leave someone to die just because that person doesn't have the money to pay to be saved? 

For a scene like that, that is greed, because he's more focused on his income than Dash's life. The problem is how the episode paints a very broad brush that they're all as greedy as him. Griffonstone is still in disarray, and the griffon population still have to get any income so they can survive through the next day.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

You know, when I watch the show, one of the last things that come to mind is resource scarcity so the interpretation went very differently. The availability of resources always seems like a given in the show.

 

Although thinking about it, the idea that Griffonstone is in a state of economic decadence does make sense. On the other hand... If we were to interpret things like IRL, some signs point to the griffons being fine when it comes to resources. For one, at least the younger ones don't show signs of being in ill health. Nobody seems to be sick and most aren't even wounded. 

 

Another thing: where's all the fighting? They just come off as cold and not particularly interested in duking it out at the first sign of hostility. The atmosphere itself comes across as nonchalant as opposed to dangerous. Had the griffons been watching the ponies like hawks, that could have been taken as a sign. What's more, they made no attempt at all to try and force them out of their bits. If the griffons were that desperate, I'm pretty sure that's what they would have done as opposed to passively waiting ask for bits, not even caring whether or the chance arose. That's very much the opposite of what I would expect from a community that faces serious deprivation problems.

 

However, your point still stands. The least the writers could have done is definitively and unambiguously show that Grifonstone is fine when it comes to resources and wealth, boiling it all down to lack of will and only a lack of will. Shoving even basic economic considerations to the side oversimplifies the episode's morals very arguably to the point of invalidation. 

Link to comment

 

 

While others such as Ponyville and Canterlot thrive, Griffonstone looks war-torn, reminding me personally of how Germany looked following World War I.

Walp, we all know what their solution was.

Link to comment

While an interesting take, I'll admit that I got a bit of a different moral from this episode than you did. If you'll be so kind as to listen for a moment...

 

To me, Rainbow and Pinkie represented the wrong way and the right way to help Griffinstone, respectively. Rainbow just wanted to get the idol and go, thinking she could just slap a band-aid on the problem more or less. Pinkie, however, did much more than spread friendship. She taught Gilda how to make Griffin scones, a skill that she could use to make money and improve her community. There was even a bit of a joke about this, if you remember these lines (well, something along these lines).

 

Pinkie - "Your scones are missing an important ingredient!"

Gilda - "What? Friendship?"

Pinkie - "Umm, no. Baking soda."

 

Maybe it's just me wanting to see the good in an episode, but the way I saw the moral, or at least a more subtle part of it, is that you can't just throw money or stuff at a community in crisis and expect everything to be fine and dandy from there. You have to help them help themselves, economically (the scones) and socially (the friendship).

 

That's my two cents at least ;)

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...