• entries
    131
  • comments
    212
  • views
    104793

Are The Friendship is Magic Comics Canon?

Sunny Fox

8081 views

The comics are great. I like the art style, I like the darker stories, I like the funny little references they throw in. (Well, some of the artist OC cameos get a bit annoying, but eh) Some are better than others, of course, but overall, they're a hoot.

blogentry-2257-0-54323900-1407487422_thumb.jpg
And Applejack agrees.

The question is, are they canon? Or should they be considered an alternative continuity? Can we use the comics as evidence for headcanon theories in the same way as the show itself? Join me as I examine this question.

The first 4 issues deal with Queen Chrysalis, which puts it chronologically after the Season 2 Finale.

blogentry-2257-0-76559900-1407489069_thumb.jpg

blogentry-2257-0-13295700-1407490666_thumb.jpg

The second arc is the... sigh... "Nightmare Rarity Arc" (reasons for the sigh to be addressed when I've saved up enough anti-nausea medication to consider reviewing it... it might be a while...)

And here is where things get interesting. You see, Luna is shown in this arc, but as she was at the end of the pilot, her "depowered" form.

blogentry-2257-0-38084300-1407490106_thumb.jpg
Yeah, you go to your room and think about what you've done!

During the events of the comic, she gets powered up by the POWER OF LOVE!

blogentry-2257-0-67146000-1407489070_thumb.jpg

This restores her to her default Season 2 appearance... wait a minute... Season 2?

blogentry-2257-0-49705500-1407489776_thumb.jpg
Woah... that is badflank... but don't try to distract me!

This is where we apply our brains (or whatever reasonable facsimile thereof I can muster...) You see, Season 2 has Luna in her new form by the 2nd (I have a different counting scheme... just go with it) episode, while the comic has her in her old form as late as following the Season 2 premiere. So we have a contradiction... oh, wait... no.

You see, I was assuming that the comic arcs are presented in chronological order, but actually, there's no reason to make that assumption. The "Nightmare Rarity" arc could in fact be placed chronologically before the Queen Chrysalis arc, which wouldn't contradict the show. Thus proving conclusively that the comics do in fact follow the same continuity as the show...

Well, unfortunately, there's more to the story. You see, during the "NightRarity" arc, we get this panel.

blogentry-2257-0-67120100-1407489071_thumb.jpg

There is not much else that this could be referring to, except the CMC being kidnapped in the events of the "Queen Chrysalis" arc.

blogentry-2257-0-71514000-1407491119_thumb.jpg

We still have the comic contradicting the show's timeline, so I have to conclude that the comics cannot be canonically linked with the show itself. I would consider it an alternative timeline of sorts, personally.

Since generalizing from only one example could be misleading, I do have another example of a mismatch between the show and the comics. For this example, we turn to the comic featuring Princess Cadance and Shining Armor in High School, “Neigh Anything”. At the party during the climax, we have a scene where the past!Mayor Mare (one hopes that’s her title and not her real name, because otherwise her parents are clairvoyant) is talking with the past!Cheerilee about what their aptitude test results were.

blogentry-2257-0-67425400-1408350267_thumb.jpg

Cheerilee states that hers says she should be a teacher, and she disparages the notion (for those not fluent in Eighties Dudespeak, “grody” means gross, so she definitely is poo-pooing the idea of being a teacher here.) According to the show, Cheerilee’s cutie mark only appeared after she had decided to become a teacher and bring joy and learning to fillies and colts. Hence we have another contradiction of the show. Huzzah!

Well, Sunny Fox, one might say, you can’t see her cutie mark with Mayor Mare in the way, so you can’t be sure she has one yet. Fair enough point, but luckily, I have an answer for it. From a previous scene with Cheerilee, we can clearly see that she already has her cutie mark.

blogentry-2257-0-21207500-1408350268_thumb.jpg

Thank you, comic writers! :proud:

At any rate, I'll be reviewing the comic themselves in this section too, to give my own impression about each of the major arcs, along with ranking, a list of pros and cons, and of course a list of the references I got in each one. I hope you'll join me in my endeavour.

Until then, stay sunny side up! :D 

  • Brohoof 2


11 Comments


Recommended Comments

Why do they necessarily have to be referring to that one incident? I'm sure there's plenty of times they've needed help in the past that didn't involve being kidnapped. Plus, the mane six have saved equestria multiple times, they might be referring one of those events.

 

 Also, you're basing it all off of a single line of dialogue? It could just be a small continuity error. Plenty of shows and games and other things have had small continuity hiccups but that never stopped them from being part of the canon.

 

 I haven't read the comics yet, so I don't know how I think about them. But you haven't given me enough evidence to convince me either way.

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Why do they necessarily have to be referring to that one incident? I'm sure there's plenty of times they've needed help in the past that didn't involve being kidnapped. Plus, the mane six have saved equestria multiple times, they might be referring one of those events.

 

 Also, you're basing it all off of a single line of dialogue? It could just be a small continuity error. Plenty of shows and games and other things have had small continuity hiccups but that never stopped them from being part of the canon.

 

 I haven't read the comics yet, so I don't know how I think about them. But you haven't given me enough evidence to convince me either way.

Read them and decide for yourself. I don't know everything, or most things, so I just call 'em as I see 'em. If you have a reason to disagree, all to the good! :D

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Read them and decide for yourself. I don't know everything, or most things, so I just call 'em as I see 'em. If you have a reason to disagree, all to the good! :D

I'm planning on it. I'm going to start picking them up in graphic novel form the second I get some extra money to spend. Looking forward to it since I've been craving more ponies ever since season 4 ended.

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

I'm planning on it. I'm going to start picking them up in graphic novel form the second I get some extra money to spend. Looking forward to it since I've been craving more ponies ever since season 4 ended.

I do like the comics, so I think you're in for a treat.

 

Having one's own income is pretty awesome...

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

I think one of the show writers tweeted once that the comics are canon if you want them to be and you can disregard them if you prefer. I can confirm that, though.

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

I always viewed it as an "unofficial canon" type deal, to where if you wanted to believe it tied in with the show than it's fine, but it isn't official and doesn't have to be considered true canon - which is why I usually just shoot it down when people try to use something from the comics as if it were actual canon from the show.

 

I loved the Return of Chrysalis arc and I'd consider that canon, but I would've burned the Nightmare Rarity arc after reading it, had I possessed it in a form that was other than digital (so I just deleted it from my Comixology library. Huge waste of money) and I won't ever believe that to be something to have happened in a show setting until the day I die, and hell, I'd take that to my grave :please: 

So I guess it's kind of just pick and choose to me, but it'll never be 100% canon.

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

I've never read any comic. Don't know where to find them :(

Anyway, I enjoy reading your blog! :)

I always thought that they weren't canon, I thought that the comics are something like EG: something that doesn't influence the show.
 

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

i'd say its best to view them as canon (they have to be run by hasbro first) unless it contradicts the canon of the show.

 

(aka Chrsyallis is alive until the show says she died)

Share this comment


Link to comment

I've never read any comic. Don't know where to find them :(

Anyway, I enjoy reading your blog! :)

I always thought that they weren't canon, I thought that the comics are something like EG: something that doesn't influence the show.

 

You can get them legally through iTunes, although you need an iPhone or iPad to view them.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.