Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    51
  • comments
    156
  • views
    17,007

Analysis of the Individual in MLP


LZRD WZRD

956 views

I've previously discussed individualism in relation to the season 5 trailer as well as in relation to cutie marks. However there's so much more to say about other episodes and aspects of the show. I suppose the best place to start is right at the beginning with Friendship Is Magic.

 

It starts out with Twilight saying she doesn't need friends. Of course by the end of the episode she's made five new friends and now realizes the importance of having them. What's important to note is that these friends are not simply ponies like Twilight. They all have distinct personalities and talents. Each of them contributes to the group in unique ways. There is no correct way to be, as shown by the way in which they all provide useful services.

 

To go further, every one of them has a special trait that powers the magic of friendship. What's important is that no element is more powerful than the other and all of them are necessary. As we see in The Return of Harmony, all of them play an imperative role in channeling the magic of friendship. Not only is everyone important, but nobody is replaceable. When Twilight substitutes Spike in for Rainbow Dash, their magic fails.

 

All of these support that the FIM universe sees everyone as having value. But more than just that, it also encourages openness to other ideas.

 

To illustrate exactly what I mean, I'll use a character who seems at times to be unappreciated by the other characters in the show: Pinkie Pie. From the first episode it's shown that others don't always approve of her antics. The others roll their eyes when Pinkie begins singing. But as they soon find out, this is actually just what they needed.

 

Just because something seems counterintuitive, doesn't mean it's wrong. No episode demonstrates this better than Feeling Pinkie Keen. It's often criticized for promoting blind faith and promoting close-mindedness, but it actually does the exact opposite. Twilight plays the role of a dismissive intellectual, who despite being presented with indisputable evidence in favor of pinkie sense, still denies it because she can't wrap her mind around it.

 

There are plenty of scientific facts that are hard to understand and explain, but it doesn't mean that they aren't true. That's the message that episode was trying to get across and unfortunately many interpreted differently. But the fact remains that it's promoting the inquiry of all ideas. People's questions and observations are all valid to discuss. Even if it's wrong, this principle is still important.

 

An instance where this occurs in the show is in Putting Your Hoof Down. Iron Will promotes a new philosophy for Fluttershy to follow. Of course in the end she finds that adhering to this overly assertive philosophy is a bad thing. But despite being wrong about adopting this, Fluttershy still grows from the experience. Even in failure there are positive things to be found.

 

Furthermore, it doesn't end with them telling Iron Will he's no longer allowed to preach his ideas. He has a right to do so and it's up to the individual to decide if it's right for them. In a different sort of show, you might have him get in trouble for spreading this harmful philosophy. One of the key tenets of individualism is freedom for the individual to make their own choices, free of restrictions of state control.

 

This is why fillies and foals can print gossip columns in their school paper. It's why it's legal to sell magic comics that can whisk you away to their dangerous worlds. It's why your allowed to journey out into the dangerous Everfree Forest if you want to. What's fascinating is that even with all powerful rulers in place with no checks and balances, Equestria is not an authoritarian or paternalistic state.

 

Not only are you allowed to make your own choices, but expressing your individuality is encouraged. Take the CMC. Throughout the series they've explored numerous activities in search of their true passion. Nobody is telling them that they should do a certain thing or to do something because others in their family have done it.

 

Look at Applejack. Despite being the legacy of apple farmers, she's free to explore other possibilities by living with relatives in Manehatten. It's through revelation and her own free will that she decides to return home to her roots. Just as there's nothing wrong with freely choosing to be different, there's nothing wrong with choosing to be the same.

 

On the other hand, you have Rarity who is nothing like her parents. She's adopted a different way of speaking and behaving that way makes her happy. There's no resentment on the part of her parents for being so different. They love her all the same.

 

To be clear though, the show promotes sincerity in following your true path. It's fine if you're like Rarity and want to be different because that's who you are. It's also great if you're like AJ and truly want to do something that your friends or family are doing because you truly enjoy it. But you shouldn't act in these ways out of obligation or if what you're doing isn't truly you. Fluttershy in Green Isn't Your Color learned this. Even though she was good at modeling and she thought doing it would make others, namely Rarity, happy, she stayed true to herself and quit. You should be honest about yourself with others and not be fearful of disapproval.

 

Another notable pegasus who tries to live artificially is Scootaloo. Rainbow Dash is her hero and she wants to be like her so much, that maintaining that appearance becomes an unhealthy obligation. As a result, she's terrified to admit that she's scared during Sleepless In Ponyville. It's only when Scootaloo is honest about her true feelings that the burden is lifted.

 

Again in Flight to the Finish Scootaloo is worried that she's unable to fly like other pegasi. Similarly in the episode, Rainbow Dash is trying to temper her personality to adhere to the arbitrary standards of others. What they both realize by the end of the episode is that each of them are who they are and that they shouldn't concern themselves about not living up to others' expectations. Both of them are unique individuals, with no more or less intrinsic worth than anyone else.

 

Moving on to Rainbow Dash, she's someone who's learned to differentiate between herself and others, namely the Wonderbolts. In Wonderbolts Academy, she disapproves of the Wonderbolts' practices and rather than just going with it, she quits. You shouldn't change your own standards to match others' even if the people in question are your heroes.

 

Then in Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3 Dash realizes that her inability to learn in conventional ways does not mean she's stupid or that there's anything wrong with her. In the end she discovers a way of learning that works for her. The episode recognizes that we are all individuals and that the way one person is wired is not inherently better or more correct than another's.

 

Moving on to the end of season 4, the final thing I'll examine are the roles of the princesses in MLP. While it is established that inherited royalty exists, the alicorn rulers all have their roles because they bring a powerful and unique trait to the position. More than people who have positions of power, they are special and irreplaceable.

 

When Twilight's lamenting that she doesn't have a true role, the other princesses reassure her that she has a part to play and that she's a princess for a reason. Twilight's not there because she's super powerful or a popular figurehead. She's there because of her unparalleled ability to understand and spread the magic of friendship. She's no more or less important than the other princesses, just different.

 

In conclusion, MLP celebrates individuality and the freedom of people to choose their own path in life. I think it makes perfect sense that the show has attracted such a diverse fan base, since one of its fundamental missions is to promote such a society. We're all different and that's ok. Great friends and people come in so many different ways and at the end of the day, the fact that their great friends and people is what's most important.

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Hey guys I hope you enjoyed this! I'm planning on making this into a video for my YouTube channel, which you can find right here http://www.youtube.com/user/TheLZRDWZRD

 

I'm posting it as a blog here first because I'd very much like to get your feedback, so feel free to leave a comment below! And if you like this, go check out my other two blog entries and my latest MLP analysis videos, which are directly linked in my profile!

  • Brohoof 1

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

What a wonderful and insightful post! I apreciate topics that take a deep, hard look at the show to try to understand what messages are trying to get through to make people stop and reflect.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

What a wonderful and insightful post! I apreciate topics that take a deep, hard look at the show to try to understand what messages are trying to get through to make people stop and reflect.

Thanks a lot :D

 

Be sure to stay tuned for the video version, which will be at least 20% cooler B)

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

Very nice reflection on some of the values they've been able to get across with these characters. I especially liked the bit on Feeling Pinkie Keen, since I've been waiting for the chance to say as much myself. I think what people don't realize is that as important as it is to be realistic, people too often mistake "close-minded" for realistic, which has hindered progress all throughout history. 

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Very nice reflection on some of the values they've been able to get across with these characters. I especially liked the bit on Feeling Pinkie Keen, since I've been waiting for the chance to say as much myself. I think what people don't realize is that as important as it is to be realistic, people too often mistake "close-minded" for realistic, which has hindered progress all throughout history.

 

I actually made a very in-depth review of that episode on my channel all the way back in the summer. The audio was atrocious though and overall wasn't very fun to watch so I've since deleted it, but I might remake it one of these days.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...