• entries
    319
  • comments
    1017
  • views
    250468

FIM's most impressive feat: consistency of good quality

Dark Qiviut

233 views

With season 9 being its last, I could give my thoughts on it ending, but I did so already. Instead, I want to reflect on what the show has done. Over the years, FIM has had moments where many, myself including, declare whether the show jumped the shark or not. For those who don't know, "jumping the shark" is the moment that indicates its peak has passed and won't return to form again. Examples are located here and here.

Of course, when something jumps the shark is subjective. What might be a "jump the shark" moment for one may not be for another. There's no right way to determine it. That said, there have been many "jump the shark" moments, only for FIM to bounce back.

  1. Faust leaving during Season 2's production? Season 2 was really solid and has aged better than the former.
  2. Derpygate? Derpy was around during S2, was on hiatus in S3 til MMC, returned again in Rainbow Falls, and has remained a background mainstay since.
  3. Twilicorn debuting in MMC, a possible change in character? In S4, she showed remnants of Twi of old, and in S5, many of her quirks return.
  4. The castle replacing the tree? No on talks about it now, and I argue that Castle Sweet Castle helped relieve the worries. In fact, her castle's been in the show longer than the Golden Oak Library (104 eps to 91 to date, minus the shorts and Best Gift Ever).
  5. Princess Spike's ending implicating permanent status as a buttmonkey? Two weeks later, Amending Fences — one of the best of the show — aired, and Spike's direction has improved tremendously since. S5 remains my favorite of the show.
  6. Newbie Dash screwing up Dash's achievement? In consecutive weeks, Tail and TSRR air. Afterwards, the Wonderbolts become much more likeable, and Dash feels like a part of the team.
  7. Starlight joins the cast? She gradually improves in S6, and in S7 and 8, she makes her mark as one of the Mane Eight.
  8. The School of Friendship is born? Becomes one of the show's best settings and the home of the Young Six, some of the best characters of the show.

You get the picture. Every time the show proverbially jumps the shark, the show always bounces back. It never stays down for so long. Whenever the show looks to be in the downturn in quality, DHX publishes good to great episodes, reminding us why FIM has the well-earned reputation of being one of the best Western cartoons of the decade.

Consider this. Many cartoon shows don't last so long. After two or three seasons, it starts wrapping up or gets canceled. Gravity Falls only lasted two seasons. If they stick around, it runs the risk of rotting. FOX renewed The Simpsons for both a 31st and 32nd season, but many argue that it began its turn to mediocrity after Season 9. The Powerpuff Girls were good for about four years, but S5 and 6 (both w/o McCracken) sucked. Nickelodeon finally canceled Fairly Odd Parents after already drilling into the sewer. Sometimes they bounce back, such as Spongebob post Out of Water and Thomas & Friends following S16.

Is it impressive that FIM lasted so long? Indeed. I still remember wondering if FIM will even have a S3 or 4. But think about it. FIM's been good for not just the first three to four seasons, but so far its entire run. A large chunk of the show's best episodes started in S5. If Friendship Is Magic ended after MMC or Twilight's Kingdom, we wouldn't have all-time greats like Flight to the Finish, The Cutie Map, Slice of Life, Lost Mark, The Times They Are A Changeling, The Perfect Pear, Shadow Play, Mean 6, The Washouts, or Sounds of Silence. DHX maintained consistently good quality from the very beginning to today, which is very hard to do. As I wrote here, Faust planted the seeds early, and her apple tree currently blooms. Prior to FIM, Hasbro's longest TV series was G1 Transformers (99 episodes, 6 seasons). When this show concludes, it'll be more than double the length (221 episodes, 9 seasons); not bad for a show that's been this good for so long, huh? ;)

Whether it'll hold up or not remains to be seen. But no one can deny that Friendship Is Magic built a legacy, and with S9 coming up in perhaps five to eight weeks, I can't wait to see what's in store. :D

  • Brohoof 10


7 Comments


Recommended Comments

Quote
  1. Faust leaving during Season 2's production? Season 2 was really solid and has aged better than the former.

 

Agreed.

In my opinion, Lauren Faust is good at creating characters & worlds,

but the episodes she wrote showed me she isn't very good when it comes to writing stories that bring said ideas to life. 

 

Mhk8.gif I deserved that. :scoots:

 

Quote
  1. The castle replacing the tree? No on talks about it now,
  2. and I argue that Castle Sweet Castle helped relive the worries. In fact, her castle's been in the show longer than the Golden Oak Library (104 eps to 91 to date, minus the shorts and Best Gift Ever).

 

  1. I do! :-D/:sunny:
  2. The castle is a nice idea but, I feel like Twilight's personality was better represented in the Golden Oak Library due to the feeling it gave off.

I hope that made sense. 

 

Edited by Sparklefan1234
  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

I agree completely! :D Especially looking at season 8 and that amazing, possibly unmatched five-episode streak near the end (which you've also mentioned before). :)

@Sparklefan1234 Faust's contributions to the show as a writer are something I'd like to have seen more, even though I think the show retained its high quality after she left. I wouldn't consider the three episodes she wrote near the best, but it's hard to say what she would have done if she had written more... The episodes she wrote for Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends were largely regarded as some of the best in the series – I don't think we saw her writing at its best in MLP, though it's hard to say if she would have done as well with the MLP universe or not...

Edited by Tacodidra
  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

One of the best essays on the show you've ever written. More need to realize that while Faust did a great job planting the seeds of MLP: FiM's legacy, it was in fact the hard-working people at DHX who have never rested on their laurels in nurturing what has come from those seeds that has maintained the show's legacy. I especially liked how you pointed out that every time doom and gloom was spelled for the show, that doom and gloom only went on to be dispelled. :nom:

Edited by CloudMistDragon
  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment
31 minutes ago, CloudMistDragon said:

I especially liked how you pointed out that every time doom and gloom was spelled for the show, that doom and gloom only went on to be dispelled. :nom:

:laugh: A lesson I had to learn at times. Suffice it to say that each crow roasted quite well in the oven. ;)

38 minutes ago, CloudMistDragon said:

More need to realize that while Faust did a great job planting the seeds of MLP: FiM's legacy, it was in fact the hard-working people at DHX who has never rested on their laurels in nurturing what has come from those seeds that has maintained the show's legacy.

Indeed. With Faust's resignation, it was up to the rest at DHX to maintain its success. In some cases, they had a lot going against it, such as loose continuity and annual turnover of editors and writers (some more so than others; S8 was the first not to have anyone before S4 on the writing staff). Yet, they deliver. Shadow Play and Amending Fences will be proof of how they can take its on-the-fly storyline and weave it into something that looks pre-planned.

34 minutes ago, CloudMistDragon said:

One of the best essays on the show you've ever written.

That line gave a gigantic grin on my face. :D

  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

I actually agree heavily with the title. Even the "worst" moments of MLP are still not that bad! It's a great show, and I think it'll be remembered for its quality.

Hasbro, PLEASE release the show on bluray. Some of us would gladly like to support a physical release.

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

I am collecting the show on DVD in full-season releases (so have the first four) - but would buy them again if they released blueray in the same form factor (single case ,multidisk with a full season in each case)

I am sure I can find a niece or nephew that can take my existing dvds off my hands :D

  • Brohoof 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
On 2/18/2019 at 9:37 PM, Sparklefan1234 said:
  1. I do! :-D/:sunny:
  2. The castle is a nice idea but, I feel like Twilight's personality was better represented in the Golden Oak Library due to the feeling it gave off.

I hope that made sense. 

 

I think the Golden Oak was ideal for Student Twilight. Gaining her wings was a major change in her life though, and her self-appointment to the role of "princess of friendship" made it appropriate for her to have a change. Besides, we know from various scenes that the Castle has at LEAST a large a library as the Golden Oak ever did :)

  • Brohoof 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now