Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    9
  • comments
    42
  • views
    6,611

PSA: Qwerty keyboards are the worst keyboards you will ever use. EVER!


Ganaram Inukshuk

3,836 views

Keyboards.  

19 users have voted

  1. 1. Which keyboard do you use?

    • Qwerty
      17
    • Dvorak
      1
    • Colemak
      0
    • Other
      0
    • I thought we were talking about music... I'm outta here, man...
      1

As I presume that 90% of you guys are typing on a keyboard that looks like this:

 

799px-Qwerty_cz.svg.png

 

Whereas instead, I type on a keyboard that looks like this:

 

Colemak_layout_2.png

 

Ever since January, I have been on a crusade to change the way I type, and safe to say, I have succeeded with my ventures.

 

I can now type as fast as I used to using the former when I still was using the latter keyboard.

 

But what, you may ask, is this supposed blog to be? A public service announcement on the scourge of computing that is commonly known as the Qwerty Keyboard.

 

"But that's what I type on all the time, so it's gotta be good. Why you gotta hate on keyboards?"

 

That's the thing. The Qwerty keyboard was originally designed for typewriters so that jamming of the typewriter keys cannot happen. When the dawn of computers came about, it just stuck.

 

In other words, Qwerty was designed to make you type slow, making typing inefficient.

 

Historically, a person by the name of August Dvorak (No, we're not talking about the musician) created the most well-known alternative to the Qwerty: The Dvorak Keyboard.

 

I'll direct you to a site that has more info on this, but this is where I'll be referencing some of my info. http://mkweb.bcgsc.ca/carpalx/?dvorak

 

dvorak.png

 

On the Dvorak keyboard, 70% of all typing is focused on the home row, which on a Qwerty, is the row of keys that reads ASDFGHJKL. How many words can you make with those letters? Only a few hundred. Whereas with Dvorak, which is AOEUIDHTNS, that number is in the thousands.

 

What does that mean? Your fingers don't even need to travel that far to reach what's effectively the most commonly used letters in the entire English Language.

 

There was a book that was written without using one particular letter: The letter E. Did you know that there are 12 E tiles in Scrabble? Wanna know why? Because that's the most used letter. Wanna know where the E is on the Qwerty? Next to the W and the R, right at the hard-to-reach top row. Where does that translate to the Dvorak? Right under your middle finger of your left hand.

 

Dr. Dvorak designed his keyboard so that, as I stated, 70% of all typing is done on the home row, with 22% of the typing on the top row, and 8% on the bottom row, where all of the least-used letters in the English Alphabet are used at. Compared to the Qwerty, those numbers are in the neighbourhood of 32% on the home row, 52% on the top row, and 16% on the bottom row.

 

There are some interesting notes about this as well, including the fact that Dvorak is so efficient, bad stuff like Carpal Tunnel and Repetitive Stress Injury can not only be mitigated, but eliminated and prevented. http://en.wikipedia...._Dvorak_layouts

 

Oh, and the world's fastest typist used a Dvorak. That same person failed her typing class, because they used Qwerty.

 

A more recent alternative, and this is my cup of joe, is the Colemak Keyboard. It's marginally better than Dvorak, but because I had such a hard time switching to Dvorak, I said to myself, "Screw it, I'm going to Colemak". And within several months, I can officially diagnose myself with ASDF Deficiency: I cannot type on a Qwerty anymore.

 

There is a wiki devoted to the Colemak, as well as a download to switch from Qwerty to Colemak. There's also an interesting online app that compares which keyboard layout is best using only what you type into it. For example, I'll use this entire document in the end to see which layout is best.

 

So what does that mean? ANY keyboard is better than Qwerty, but personally, I prefer Colemak. I'll explain why:

 

I grew up, as with most of you, with using the Qwerty keyboard. As I progressed with my computer classes in high school (as with struggled how to type), I eventually learned how to type on what I now see as the worst keyboard ever. I've only heard small slivers of information about the Dvorak, but when I started my college courses in computer science, I heard the full dirt on Qwerty and Dvorak.

 

That was January 2012, so you could say that doing away with Qwerty was my New Year's Resolution. It wasn't easy, but it took less time than putting up with Qwerty.

 

The moment I heard the truth behind Qwerty, I immediately switched the layout of my keyboard to Dvorak, but after about a few months, I had to switch back. Through my research on Dvorak, I stumbled on a keyboard called the Colemak, made by a person with the uneventful name of Shai Coleman.

 

There were a lot of ups and downs in my life between March and now, and those who know me well will know what I mean, but one of the biggest factors behind that was that I literally couldn't type. And the best part of all this: For my Microsoft Office class, I chose this to be my exact topic I wanted to talk about for my PowerPoint project, all because of one trivial fact about Qwerty.

 

Someone once asked my why I would ever switch keyboards. I responded with the goal of efficiency. Some of you guys may know what I'm actually gawking about, and some of you guys are just boggled out of your heads and some of you guys -- HEY, COME BACK HERE!!! -- don't even wanna read this giant blurb of words.

 

I'm gonna post a poll up top about this.

 

So suppose you wanted to switch keyboards. What would I recommend? Colemak. Why? Because the position of half of the keys on a Colemak are unchanged between it and the Qwerty. No keys ever switch hands, except for P and E. It means if you wanna write "Pee", instead of using your left hand for E and your right hand for P, it's the other way around. All of the other keys on a Colemak don't even switch hands.

 

Compared to Dvorak, only the A and M keys are unchanged. Then again, that's just my preference, and what I learnt with. If you're on a Dvorak and are OK with it, just stick with it. Once again, there are online resources on all three keyboards, and if I've actually persuaded you about what's what, then I've done my job right.

 

 

 

 

The optimal keyboard layout for your input text is:

 

Simplified Dvorak

Below you can see a table which ranks the input layouts and given them a score between 0 and 100.

 

Layout Score Simplified Dvorak 64.66 Programmer Dvorak 64.61 Colemak 64.16 Capewell 61.25 Personalized 54.90 QWERTY 50.20

The optimal layout score is based on a weighed calculation that factors in the distance your fingers moved (33%), how often you use particular fingers (33%), and how often you switch fingers and hands while typing (34%).

  • Brohoof 4

21 Comments


Recommended Comments

I've tried to learn colmark and Dvorak, I couldn't because I have to use QWERTY on the school computers and I cannot seem to learn more than one keyboard layout. But one day...Especially seeing as my mechanical keyboard is coming this week I should try to learn something else because I really do hate QWERTY.

Link to comment

I've tried to learn colmark and Dvorak, I couldn't because I have to use QWERTY on the school computers and I cannot seem to learn more than one keyboard layout.

 

I forgot to mention: All computers have the option to switch to Dvorak. Just don't forget to reset to Qwerty so you don't ruin it for the others, and don't forget to request special authorisation to do so.

Link to comment

I have no problem with the "E" key on my QWERTY keyboard. And I've been using a QWERTY since I was an insolent little imp (a kid), so there's no way I could change now.

Link to comment

I type smoothly on my QWERTY and I wont be changing... Ever. I dont see why some men just wanna watch the world switch... QWERTY rules I wub it and nothing else matters. Also I prefer fluency with a tiny bit of speed loss to total speed and a crapload of errors you have to go back and fix. QWERTY FOR LIFE!!!

Link to comment

I type plenty fast on a QWERTY. I type with maybe 4-5 fingers and my thumb, and move my hands around the keyboard a lot. Also, I type one handed frequently, where speed is really only dependent on knowing where the keys are. And while the vast majority of words I type are in muscle memory, I look at the keyboard while typing to position my hands (since I move my hands so much while typing, my hands are often in the "wrong place" for all you typists who actually use methods and whatnot.) so learning a new layout would be problematic unless all the keys were actually in the places they were, and I'd rather not dismantle my laptop keyboard :P

 

 

I've never seen the point of typing in the "correct" way and using more efficient keyboards. I mean, typing at like 150+ WPM is cool and all, but unless you're a writer of some kind, it's not like you ever need that kind of speed.

Comes down to whatever you're used to.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

Although I as a gamer will unlikely switch, all, if not most games are preset to be easy to use with.

 

I come from a much worse layout, and you may say, how can you have worse? It is called AZERTY, and AZERTY was developed by the French and adopted as a standard in my country. The big problem with it is that a lot of the useful keys are extremely difficult to get to (i.e. use of the ALt Gr key) which is inconveniently located next to spacebar. I have to do a lot of programming myself and it annoys me greatly when very frequent keys including >\[]{} are all hidden in very inconvenient location.

 

Secondly as a gamer I was forced to change the keys on every single games before I started playing just to play the game properly.

 

QWERTY is definitely not the worst. Although I not in a position to say it is the best. I'm doing perfectly fine with it and I am glad I switched over from AZERTY. Which in my opinion is much more of an evil then QWERTY ever was.

Link to comment

Ya see, if I wasnt't lazy, I'd totes try this out once I figured out how to switch it. But I think that I'm good with my QWERTY for now.

Link to comment

The inherent problem with this is: QWERTY is the default everywhere, from phones to computers.

People fear changing the defaults, that's precisely the reason that QWERTY is now popular, you can even see it in other areas as well, for example:

Did you know that Bing (in the US) currently holds almost a third of the search engine market share? You can see why this is when you remember that bing is the default search on all Windows machines, some people are just too afraid to ever change anything in their life because they think that it'll ruin everything, I myself know that, I once tried switching from Windows to Linux, lets just say I ran back to Windows in like 2 hours.

Edited by Ace Muffins
Link to comment
1 hour ago, Ace Muffins said:

The inherent problem with this is: QWERTY is the default everywhere, from phones to computers.

People fear changing the defaults, that's precisely the reason that QWERTY is now popular, you can even see it in other areas as well, for example:

Did you know that Bing (in the US) currently holds almost a third of the search engine market share? You can see why this is when you remember that bing is the default search on all Windows machines, some people are just too afraid to ever change anything in their life because they think that it'll ruin everything, I myself know that, I once tried switching from Windows to Linux, lets just say I ran back to Windows in like 2 hours.

Uhh, when did my six year old blog post become relevant again...?

Link to comment
Just now, Ganaram Inukshuk said:

Uhh, when did my six year old blog post become relevant again...?

idk, i mean, i respect your keyboard preference, and by all means i support it, its just that only now i saw you had a few blog entries, and decided to chek them out :mlp_please:

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Ace Muffins said:

idk, i mean, i respect your keyboard preference, and by all means i support it, its just that only now i saw you had a few blog entries, and decided to chek them out :mlp_please:

Please dont let my past blog posts influence how I'm perceived to you; the me that made those posts no longer exists and decided that there would be no point to sharing what he had to say.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...