I was about a week late to the party this time around: I didn't get to watch the MLP:FiM Season 4 finale, Twilight's Kingdom, until just this evening, six days after it aired. By that time, more than 300 people had voted for it, with close to 90% of them saying they loved it. Easily the highest-rated episode of the season, and I'd bet one of the most highly-rated of the whole series.
I think that's awesome. Yet, I was not among that 90%. In fact, after a couple of hours of conflicted thought and agonizing, I ended up voting only "Meh, it was okay."
Why, after such an epic finale?
T