Rinkitty

I love TF2's art style. Shooters would be much more interesting if they were more artsy like the TF series.

I typically like cel-shaded or stylized art styles, like in Borderlands, The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker and Team Fortress 2. Graphics or art style shouldn't make a game, though.

The story, gameplay and presentation, imo, are the most important parts of any game.

I definitely prefer a more animated art style. Makes it much easier to get into a game.

But yes, above all else, gameplay/gamefeel and general experience are what a game is about.