ghostfacekiller39

Snips and Snails are very OOC in EQG. Their pony counterparts are stupid, but innocent-minded and don't want to hurt anyone (Twilight activated the "mustache" spell in Boast Busters to cheer them up). In EQG, they're stupid villains; they're evil and want to do whatever they can to humiliate and hurt TS. S&S may be dumb, but they have morals.

...Makes sense, brah.

But still, I fail to see any flatness in Rarity in particular out of the 4 you mentioned, let alone in AJ, and, to an extent RD; Pinkie seemed to be outstandingly flat in EQG, along with Fluttershy, but not the other 4.

Rarity, AJ, FS, and RD are flat in a way where their dialogue becomes predictable. Their lines are expected, but not out of character (most of the time). Dash suffers the worst of it with a very repetitive vocabulary (i.e., saying "awesome" one too many times); in character, but flat.

Pinkie was actually at her best in some time. She has that offbeat humor with a purpose (actions with awareness and intelligence in mind), and her dialogue (along with Spike) is arguably the m...