It's very disconcerting to see you call yourself an "Analyst" and make YT videos and then see you go around blaming Rarity and villainizing her for horribly trivial matters. I think you need to sit down and think about her character for a while, because you seem really intent on seeing the bad in her, which is a toxic mindset.
For the most part, Sunny said a lot of what I was going to say, but I'll just fill in a few things I was going to say and he didn't.
4. Don't forget that she had just done a whole bunch of things she didn't want to do in that race, which involved hiding in *mud* and running an entire race across that dirty old farm. As a matter of fact, that happened right before she said the spa line, but you don't seem to be taking any of that into account.
5. And what was that, might I ask? What exactly was she doing behind her friends back that was so evil?
Making new friends? Living out her dream?
All I saw her do wrong was the whole letter thing. It was said earlier in the episode that Rarity offered to make her the dress, and Twilight wasn't paying nor asking for it, so I don't see why you're going to be upset about that -especially considering she liked the final product. Other than that, you didn't list anything specific. If you were an analyst, you wouldn't be criticizing these characters and providing no evidence You're just assuming we all know what you're talking about and view Rarity as acting horribly evil in that episode...but really, all I saw her do *wrong* was lie to her friends in that letter
You're making it sound like she committed genocide, which is why I find it dangerous to have you around as an analyst after readomg this. Tptal objectivity may not be able to be achieved, but if you're going to market yourself on YouTube you should at least try not to be so bias. You seem to have no interest in that, unfortunately, which is scary. I'm no analyst, but I know enough about the show to know what you're saying is attempting to deconstruct a character rather than provide objective criticisms. Frightening, honestly
6. MA Larson, the writer of this episode, said it himself - that didn't even happen. It was Spike just Ogling over her. Here's what he said:
I'm no analyst, but you've got a lot of kinks to work out in your assessment of the series, kid. Especially since, in that same episode, she was kidnapped by a dragon who'd easily be able to kill her and she still wouldn't give him ththe ruby because "her dear friend Spike gave it to her"
I'm really thinking that you should go meditate on not only Rarity's character and motivations, but the meaning of the show itself. Being an analyst and being so quick to demonize one character while excusing two other characters who did the exact same thing, like you did when discussing Rarity in MMMystery, really makes me question your skill as an analyst but is also wanting me to tell people to stay away from your channel because you're trying to lead them astray from what REALLY happened.
You really need to pay attention to the show more and stop being so brutally bias against Rarity's character That'll only hurt you in the long run.
I have a feeling me and you are going to be seeing each other a lot.
Anyway, just because you never directly said anything about it doesn't mean it's not true. It's really hard to see it any other way, actually, with the criticisms you provided us of her character. As in, I don't believe you when you say what I just quoted hard to believe. If you didn't expect perfection, WHY are you criticizing her for these things you're criticizing her for? Most of them are very silly, trivial, minor, AND can be disproved with surrounding circumstances, and only a couple of them, if only one, serves as a valid criticism because it's not so...nitpicky. I don't really care when someone nitpicks the show, but you're just nitpicking a character to make her look bad
That's...kind of underhanded and uncool, to be honest.
Not really.
I actually had to sit and think to try and figure out what you were trying to say here...as in, what the criticism was.
I spent like, 10 minutes rerunning everything that happened in that episode through my head, and, like pretty much everything else you criticized her for, it was only stuff you were blowing way out of proportion to make her look worse than she really is
And yet you tried to use it to make her look like a total bitch I can't really say I'm buying this, man.
Was it wrong of her? Yes.
Did it help provide her character with development, maintain a sense of realism in the episode, and did she make up for her wrongs in ways that outweighed the initial wrongs?
Yes, yes, and yes.
I'm scratching my head at all of this...it really seems like the first post was TRYING to make her look bad while the second post was just a bunch of backpedaling in case someone like me or Sunny came along. That's what it seems like to me.
S01E01: Friendship is Magic
Gives Twilight a free makeover after Rainbow Dash messed up her mane.
S01E02: Friendship Is Magic
Cuts off her tail to give a monster or something the missing half of his mustache.
S01E11: Winter Wrap Up
After Twilight did a horrible job making a nest, she spent all of her time trying to fix her friend's mistake, putting her horribly behind quota.
S01E14: Suited For Success
Made all of her friends dresses for the gala free of charge, and they kept complaining about how they looked and how they wanted them to look, which made her dresses look horrible in front of some huge name in the fashion business.
S01E16: Sonic Rainboom
When Twilight wanted to try out a new spell that she had never done before and warned it could have possible side effects if botched, Rarity readily subjects herself to the spell, so she can go cheer on Rainbow Dash at her flying competition.
S01E20: Green isn't Your Color
Keeps quiet about her jealousy of Fluttershy's newfound fame in the fashion business, something she had been trying to accomplish before the show even started. After Fluttershy stumbles and trips on the runway and the crowd turns against her, Rarity begins cheering to save her friend, despite feeling it should've been her making it big instead of Fluttershy.
S01E25: A Party of One
Purposely ruins her mane, which she's extremely proud of, in order to keep Pinkie's surprise party a secret.
S02E05: Sisterhooves Social
After making a mistake in the way she took care of her sister, she hid IN MUD in order to complete a race with her sister for forgiveness, when all and all, it was just siblings fighting over trivial matters, like EVERY siblings do.
S02E08: Mysterious Mare Do Well
Makes 4 costumes for her friends to wear in their mission of bringing a borderlining on narcissism Rainbow Dash back down to earth.
S02E09: Sweet & Elite
When it came down to it, she chose her unsophisticated Ponyville friends over the Canterlot Ponies, who she had dreamt of fitting in with.
S02E10: Secret of My Excess
Spares the feelings of a horny baby dragon who stole half of the city and kidnapped her, even going as far to kiss him on the cheek.
S02E14: The Last Roundup
Rides a damn whatever you call that thing all the way back to Ponyville with an extremely repetitive Pinkie Pie due to Rainbow Dash's negligence.
S02E19: Putting Your Hoof Down
Tries helping Fluttershy learn how to stand up for herself, and welcomes Fluttershy back after she attacks her dreams.
S02E21: Dragon Quest
Attempts to stand up for Spike when the other 5 laugh at his apron. Creates a huge costume so RD, Twilight and herself could follow him to make sure he was alright. Stands directly behind Rainbow Dash's flank the entire time they're hiding, without complaining. Prepares to fight dragons in yet another attempt to stand up for Spike.
S02E25: A Canterlot Wedding
Makes a ton a fricken' dresses for the wedding, free of charge.
S03E01: The Crystal Empire
In order to buy time for Twilight, makes a bunch of hats and shit out of hay and straws. Does a very good job at it, I might add.
S03E12: Games Ponies Play
Takes the extremely difficult job of preparing Cadence's mane in the intricate detail it had to be done in, with only 15 minutes of time left. Also does a good job.
(Note: Rarity got screwed in Season 3. I assure you Season 4 will be different.)
Equestria Girls:
Makes dressed for them to all wear to the dance free of charge. Helps clean up the gym so Twilight could when the crown that night, despite hating messes. After Sunset Playdough-Hair ruins Twilight's reputation, tries helping Twilight go incognito until it can be fixed. Share her idea and Wondercolt's costume with the rest to change Twilight's horrid reputation.
S04E03 - Castle Mane-ia
Heads to the Castle of the Two Sisters in order to restore ancient tapestries out of respect to art. She'd be giving her time, effort, and possibly money for needed supplies to restore something that's not hers for free.
S04E08 - Rarity Takes Manehattan
Gave an extra large tip to the Bell Boy numerous times
Gave her scarf to a cold stranger
Gave a potential job that could've landed her in fame to Coco
Helped fix the Taxi Driver's broken thing.
Bought Spike a hot dog.
Gave Suri pieces of her one of a kind fabric to use in her ensembles, despite Suri being her competition in the fashion contest.
S04E10 - Rainbow Falls
Made outfits for the Ponyville Relay team free of charge. Not talking about quality here - she took the time and effort to make the outfits and expected nothing in return.
S04E13 - Simple Ways
She accepted the job of organizing the community event, even though her job keeps her extremely busy and working constantly.
S04E14 - Filli Vanilli
Constantly performed with the Ponytones in order to help Fluttershy enjoy herself singing.
S04E17 - Somepony to Watch Over Me
Even though she doesn't make an appearance, Applejack says "Rarity is on her way over to watch y'all while I'm gone" - hence, took time out of her day to watch Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo when she didn't have to.
S04E18 - Maud Pie
Offered to help Maud with fashion and make her an ensemble - we know that in the end Maud just wanted a dirty dishrag, but Rarity was ready to make a whole outfit for free.
S04E19 - For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils
Puts a celebrity client's order to the side in order to help make Sweetie Belle's dresses look nice.
S04E21 - Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3
Made replicas of old Wonderbolts costumes in an attempt to help RD study for her test - participated in the reenactment of the Wonderbolts history in order to help RD study.
S04E23 - Inspiration Manifestation
Made that douchebag Puppteer a puppet booth free of charge. An entire fricken' puppet booth, for nothing in return.
From Vocabulary.com:
Generosity is a quality that's a lot like unselfishness — someone showing generosity is happy to give to or share time, money, food, or whatever with others.
Generosity is a quality — like honesty and patience — that we all probably wish we had more of. When you show generosity, you might give away things or money or put others before yourself. But generosity is about more than cash and stuff. When you're forgiving and gentle to people, you show generosity of spirit. If you give others help or credit, that shows generosity. The world would certainly be a better place if more people showed generosity to others.
Like it or not, not every one of the ponies lives up to their element all the time.
Like, you can actually see that here:
You're acting like none of the other ponies have their moments, and you're dead-set on crippling her with small, minor nitpicks that are not "outweighed" by her acts of generosity but flat out crushed. You failed to acknowledge most of these things in your criticisms of her character. Why is that? You're an analyst, you know