Miss

I always preferred Halo 2's campaign to Halo 3's (even with the fuck you legendary) but I'm currently doing a replay of the first 3 Halo games and I think I might actually like Halo: CE campaign's more than 3 as well. 

Like story wise, I prefer 3, but gameplay I think 3 is just kinda stale in a way.  The first one feels so fun and challenging and in the 3 it just feels like when I die it's because I made a silly mistake as opposed to the enemies out smarted me. I will say CE and 2 had alot more "FUCK YOU" moments and 3 is more balanced, but it's just not as fun. The weapons aren't as fun to fight with and the enemies aren't as fun to fight. Kind of at odds here. But when I finish the game we shall see. 

(disclaimer: I am playing with scoring on so maybe that's tainting my experience a bit, for last two levels I'll turn it off)