Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Thrond

User
  • Posts

    3,190
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Status Updates posted by Thrond

  1. My head canon is that time moves differently in the Equestria Girls world than it does in the pony world, but what if it got so far out of sync that the pony CMC became older than the human mane six? 

    1. Sparklefan1234
    2. Thrond
    3. Sparklefan1234

      Sparklefan1234

      *Rarity observing the school ponies in their natural habitat*

       

      She must've taken lessons from Twilight Sparkle.

       

      800?cb=20110903171511

  2. I feel like a lot of people overlook how weird a character Starlight Glimmer is compared to the rest of the My Little Pony cast. All the other main characters are flawed but generally wholesome, and then there's this sketchy former cult leader who still has a slightly off moral code. I mean, that's why I like her, at least. 

    1. Show previous comments  5 more
    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      Because the show likes to do fun things with them sometimes?

      An episode without the main characters would be interesting.

    3. Number62

      Number62

      The recent episodes featuring them (has Cadance gotten anything, btw?) might have worked better if they weren't previously fed so much

      And if they weren't, those recent episodes would've turned out differently.

       

    4. Thrond

      Thrond

      Well, I'm not complaining. 

  3. One thing I do hope for the next generation of My Little Pony is that all of the fictional cultures are more integrated. I want to see griffons living in pony cities, for instance. Would be a good reason to make non-ponies less stereotypical, too. 

  4. Apparently some people are really invested in the idea of Celestia as this kind, benevolent, wise monarch, to the point that they don't like her being fallible or showing relatively intense emotion. I never noticed this. 

    1. Lambdadelta

      Lambdadelta

      They expect an ancient one-thousand-year-old creature to be the wisest because she lives that long. 

    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      Ok but that’s boring

  5. Just watched "Loving Vincent." Am I alone in thinking that animating Van Gogh's paintings completely ruins them? 

    1. Sparklefan1234

      Sparklefan1234

      I saw a review for "Loving Vincent" & I thought the idea was unique but also silly at the same time. 

    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      They put rotoscoped actors against animated versions of Van Gogh paintings. I'm not a fan of the effect, but it's certainly interesting. 

  6. I don’t really know anything about cartoons. Rather, my approach to My Little Pony is mostly influenced by movies and TV sitcoms. 

    1. Show previous comments  1 more
    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      It's just something I thought was interesting, because I see a lot of people on this forum who have clearly watched a lot of cartoons. 

    3. Number62

      Number62

      I can't speak for everyone, but I have mostly watched cartoons as well. I'd like to watch some live-action shows, but there are a bunch of cartoons out there whether they are being made right now or that have aired in the past that I'm curious about.

    4. Thrond

      Thrond

      I mean, it makes sense that people who like cartoons would watch a cartoon. 

  7. Wait a minute what happened to my reaction options

    1. Passion
    2. FlareGun45

      FlareGun45

      We can have tea at least!

    3. Thrond

      Thrond

      @FlareGun45 I'm honestly surprised the tea thing stuck around so long. 

  8. TWO terrific Hearth's Warming stories in one year? You spoil me, My Little Pony. 

  9. I'm not entirely sure what this MLPF world cup thing is but I guess it wouldn't hurt to try it out. 

  10. There are a lot of cute Pokemon. 

    1. Castle Bleck

      Castle Bleck

      Yep, plenty of Badass Adorables in that franchise.

  11. If the mane six went to a convention together, Applejack would probably be the only one not in cosplay.

    1. Thrond

      Thrond

      Maybe Fluttershy too, but not for lack of interest.

    2. Sparklefan1234

      Sparklefan1234

      Applejack could just say she's a cowmare. :mlp_smug:

  12. Considering that we've gotten an Equestria Girls short about the last day of school, does that mean the girls will have to graduate at some point? 

  13. Season 8 reflections post is now live on my blog. So check that out if you're interested. 

  14. There is a lot I will forgive if next season gives me a good Cadance episode. 

  15. Seasons ranked:

    1. season 2
    2. season 1
    3. season 4
    4. season 6
    5. season 8
    6. season 3
    7. season 5
    8. season 7

    Percentage of episodes I enjoyed this season: 63%

    Average rating of episodes this season: 64/100

    Full ranking of the season: 

    Liked

    1. Horse Play (100)
    2. The Mean 6 (85)
    3. Marks for Effort (83)
    4. The Hearth's Warming Club (83)
    5. Molt Down (80)
    6. The Break Up Break Down (78)
    7. Road to Friendship (78)
    8. Grannies Gone Wild (75)
    9. School Daze (75)
    10. Friendship University (73)
    11. What Lies Beneath (70)
    12. Father Knows Beast (70)
    13. The Maud Couple (68)
    14. A Rockhoof and a Hard Place (65)
    15. The Washouts (65)

    Didn't like

    16. School Raze (58)
    17. Surf and/or Turf (55)
    18. Yakity Sax (53)
    19. The End in Friend (43)
    20. A Matter of Principals (43)
    21. Sounds of Silence (43) 
    22. The Parent Map (35)
    23. Fake It Til You Make it (35)
    24. Non-Compete Clause (25)

  16. Totally forgot about Spike when I counted up all of My Little Pony's confirmed orphans a couple months ago. To wit: there are definitely 6 orphans, including Apple Bloom, Big Mac, Applejack, Gallus, Spike, and Princess Cadance. Cursory reading on mlp.wikia.com suggests that Scootaloo's parents are alive and haven't abandoned her, even if they're never around. 

  17. Got a new lengthy post about on my blog about the new "Equestria Girls," so check that out if you want. 

    1. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      You make a number of great points about the new EQG format. Well put on the charm they seem to possess (I was never a huge fan of EQG from its conception waaay back when, but some of the recent shorts are actually more similar to early-season FiM tonally than season 8 is, although I am in no way a season 8 detractor) - it's neat to see the series finally come into its own after a long string of repetitive films (although I liked "Rainbow Rocks", the others range from okay to awful ("Legend of Everfree" was one of the least watchable installments G4 has output to date, and that's despite the existence of "Hard to Say Anything")) and a trio of bizarre specials.  

    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      I think if they can fit in some 22-minute entries and sort out the problems with the 45-minute ones, they might really have something. Those chose-your-ending shorts in particular were way different than I was expecting - in a good way. 

      I think I'd find Legend of Everfree way more watchable if it were half as long. As is, the combination of murky metaphors and mild humour made that thing just go on forever and ever. I still hold "Mirror Magic" as worse, simply because it seems completely vapid to me, but at least that one's short and quick. 

  18. I like Spike episodes. 

    1. Lambdadelta

      Lambdadelta

      I like Spike episodes but not all of them.:dash:

  19. I feel like "Newbie Dash" gives RD more respect and sympathy than a lot of people realize. 

    1. Show previous comments  1 more
    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      My main problem with it is actually that I don't find it very funny at all, and in particular I find the impressions part difficult to watch. I think it might have been nice to have some indication that the Wonderbolts would have stopped calling her that if she was still upset, but I don't know what the right way to suggest that would be. 

      What I mostly like about it is that Rainbow becoming a Wonderbolt makes me happy, and the fact that she reclaimed the "Rainbow Crash" nickname reminds me how far she's come. She acts bad in this episode because she's anxious and insecure, and that's sympathetic to me. 

    3. Them's Seeing Ponies

      Them's Seeing Ponies

      This episode is honestly not as bad as the majority of the fandom's viewpoints indicate. The moral is kind of clunky and the lack of humour contributes no means of lessening the impact of the episode's structural inadequacies, but it's mostly an okay watch (and certainly better than a number of S6's other episodes).

    4. Thrond

      Thrond

      I can see how people come to the conclusion they do regarding the moral, but it's never really been my main takeaway. 

  20. Every time I see someone making up theories about where Applejack's parents went, I feel sad, like they're missing out on one of this show's most poetic and moving stories because they refuse to see what's right in front of them. If they turned out to be alive, "The Perfect Pear" would lose most of what makes it such a great episode. 

    1. Will Guide

      Will Guide

      I have to agree with you on that. If it turns out they're alive, it could make them look like deadbeats and ruin the point of how the parents lives affected several ponies' lives for the better as well as (the following spoiler box is just my head fanon, so don't take it too seriously)

      Spoiler

      in my head fanon, a certain hungry Changeling guard to one day have a change of heart due to their influence. (C. Will Guide before he had a name)

       

    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      I'm also concerned for the bittersweet feeling of the Apples bonding with people over filling an absence in their lives, as well as for the tragedy of Grand Pear screwing up his last ever interaction with his daughter. The sad stuff in that episode is just so poignant. 

    3. Lambdadelta

      Lambdadelta

      That remind me of the credit of Kung Fu Panda 2, the parents turn out alive ruined that movie for me.

  21. Despite how weird individual strands of Rainbow Dash's hair have looked in the show, I don't think she dyes it, simply because dying her hair rainbow doesn't seem to me like something Rainbow Dash would do. Like, how long would she need to sit still to make that work properly? 

    1. EpicEnergy

      EpicEnergy

      Rainbow Dash would faint if she had to sit still for more than an hour. She has to show everyone just how awesome she is, and she can't do that by standing still! Unless you gave her a video game. so overall, you make a really good point.

    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      Plus I just don’t think rainbow is the colour she would go for.

  22. Really hoping for Equestria Girls to stray further out of its musical comfort zone. Gimme full-fledged rap songs! Slather on the auto-tune! Maybe even put in some extended instrumental solos! They sky's the limit if they go that far. 

  23. I really wish My Little Pony would stop adding immediate peril to episodes which don’t need it.

    1. Show previous comments  3 more
    2. Thrond

      Thrond

      This season? “Sounds of Silence.” Last season, “Rock Solid Friendship” was the one which really bugged me.

      My complaint in “Sounds of Silence” was that it didn’t fit the rest of the tone; with “What Lies Beneath” was that it basically forced character development to happen; with “Molt Down” was that it made Rarity and Zecora damsels in distress. 

    3. CypherHoof

      CypherHoof

      Only real peril in SoS was that the two ponies would be forced into the stream - given at that point we already knew the process was reversable, that isn't much of a peril (but gave Autumn Blaze a chance to be the heroine anyhow)

      I don't mind a bit of excitement to help the plot along, provided an 11 year old wouldn't be genuinely upset by it. In that, I think WLB went too far, and could give young children nightmares (while by contrast, the other dangers characters have faced are sufficiently unrelatable that viewers are going to just be waiting to see how they get out of it, rather than actually scared)

      you might see it differently of course.

    4. Thrond

      Thrond

      I just didn’t feel that sudden spike in intensity was necessary there, and it also annoyed me that the Kirin would just force them in against their will. It was just very jarring to me. 

  24. SEASON 8 RANKINGS (so far)

    Liked

    1. Horse Play (100)
    2. The Mean 6 (85)
    3. Marks for Effort (83)
    4. The Hearth's Warming Club (83)
    5. Molt Down (80)
    6. The Break Up Break Down (78)
    7. Road to Friendship (78)
    8. Grannies Gone Wild (75)
    9. School Daze (75)
    10. Friendship University (73)
    11. What Lies Beneath (70)
    12. The Maud Couple (68)
    13. A Rockhoof and a Hard Place (65)
    14. The Washouts (65)

    Didn't like

    15. Surf and/or Turf (55)
    16. Yakity Sax (53)
    17. The End in Friend (43)
    18. A Matter of Principals (43)
    19. Sounds of Silence (43
    20. The Parent Map (35)
    21. Fake It Til You Make it (35)
    22. Non-Compete Clause (25)

×
×
  • Create New...