Hierok

Then we have Chaos, Malice and Fear covered. A really interesting idea. It reminds me a bit of Tom Bombadil.

https://www.deviantart.com/imalou/art/Creator-of-all-monsters-793887581 I still think Grogar was an awesome character, and I hope to see more of him in the comics, or in the movie. (There is going to be a movie right?)

Big Mac probably didn't want a big crowd, just like his mother and father.

Happy of course, because it ended on a good note. We had a good run and I'm happy we got the experience and I'm happy G5 is on it's way to bring new ideas and changes to the franchise.

Interesting idea. Of which force do you think he was the embodiement of?

This is also what me bottered the most. He should have atleast had a bigger fight before his magic was drained...

I would say it is Ember.

I have a couple of things: More dept into the backstories of characters and lore. Make the timeline believable. (Example: Starswirl has lived for a coupled of hundred of years, which is not realistic.) Give Discord a bit more development. Give Zecora a bit more development. A bit more mystery surounding the show. (Example: Gravity Falls where we learn of the thing that drives the plot at the middle of season 2.)

I have also my version. Take a look if you will. 5926 b. Eq The alicorns settle in a land and name it Equestria. 5720 b. Eq The alicorns drive of the dragons to the east, where they form their own land. 4174 b. Eq King Grover reunites the griffons and builds the city of Griffonstone. 3693 b. Eq Arimaspi steals the idol, which in the process kills him and king Guto. 3636 b. Eq A part of the Griffons leave Griffonstone and go live on Mount Aris. 1999 b. Eq Discord comes to Equestria. 1912 b. Eq The alicorns take charge at him. 1827 b. Eq Discord defeats the alicorn leaders and takes control over the lands. 955 b. Eq Grogar is born. 909 b. Eq Grogar is adopted by Discord as his apprentice. 666 b. Eq Discord is betrayed and defeated by Grogar, who declares himself emperor of all he saw. 606 - 82 b. Eq Grogar experiments on animals and create monsters. 494 b. Eq Grogar becomes known as 'the Father of Monsters'. 121 - 98 b. Eq Grogar tortures most of the alicorns and creates not only earth ponies, unicorns and pegasi, but also Windigo's, Nirik's, Umbrum and the Siren in the process. 98 b. Eq Gusty the Great is the first naturally born unicorn. 85 b. Eq Gusty the Great finds the last few alicorns and they begin making plans to defeat Grogar. 82 b. Eq Grogar is defeated by Gusty the Great and his magic is trapped inside his own bell. 78 b. Eq Earth ponies, unicorns, and Pegasi begin to live together under extremely hostile conditions. 77 b. Eq Grogar dies inside his prison. The alicorns find a home in a hidden land to the west. 54 b. Eq Gusty the Great reforms the Nirik so they become Kirin. 48 b. Eq Clover the Clever is born. 25 b. Eq Gusty the Great adopts a new aprentice named Clover the Clever. 9 b. Eq Clover the Clever becomes the advisor of Princess Platinum 1 b. Eq The windigo's are defeated by Clover the Clever's friendship fire. 0 a. Eq Equestria is created again. 1 a. Eq Gusty the Great dies of old age. 42 a. Eq Clover the Clever dies of old age. 150 a. Eq Starswirl the Bearded is born. 164 a. Eq Celestia is born. 169 a. Eq Luna is born. 172 a. Eq Lord Tirek and Scorpan arrive in Equestria and begin to destroy the land. Scorpan reforms after experiencing the kindness of Equestria 173 a. Eq Scorpan and Starswirl go to the alicorns and convince them to fight agains Lord Tirek. Lord Tirek is defeated and Scorpan returns to his land after seeing the beauty of Equestrian citizens. Starswirl adopts the last two alicorns, Celestia and Luna. 200 a. Eq Stygian gets the pillars together. 202 a. Eq The pillars banish the Siren to another dimension. 212 a. Eq The pillars plant the Tree of Harmony to keep the Everfree forest at bay. 222 a. Eq The changelings are created in the Everfree Forest. 240 a. Eq Stygian gets infected by the darkness and begins to call himself 'the Pony of Shadows'. The pillars banish themself and Stygian to Limbo. 241 a. Eq Discord comes to Equestria and takes control again. 243 a. Eq The Umbrum are locked up in prison by Discord and he builds the Crystal Empire on top of the prison. Discord creates the Crystal Heart as a weapon against the Umbrum. 299 a. Eq Discord is turned to stone by Celestia and Luna. Celestia and Luna become princesses of Equestria. 367 a. Eq The Crystal Empire is formed to guard the Umbrum. Princess Amore is crowned first queen of the Empire. 375 a. Eq Luna becomes bitter and turns to Nightmare Moon. Celestia banishes Nightmare Moon to the moon and becomes the only princess of Equestria. 376 a. Eq King Sombra takes over the Crystal Empire and defeats Amore. 377 a. Eq King Sombra is banished under the frozen north by princess Celestia. The Crystal Empire vanishes thanks to a curse put on it by King Sombra. 383 a. Eq The school of magic is made. 1345 a. Eq Shining Armor is born. 1347 a. Eq Cadence is born. 1348 a. Eq Sunset Shimmer is born. 1351 a. Eq Apple Jack is born. Rarity is born 1352 a. Eq Twilight is born. Fluttershy is born. 1353 a. Eq Pinkie Pie is born. Rainbow Dash is born. 1355 a. Eq Starlight Gimmer is born. Sunset Shimmer is going to another dimension and betrays Celestia. 1357 a. Eq Spike is born. Twilight becomes Celestia's aprentice. Celestia transforms Cadence into an alicorn. 1362 a. Eq Scootaloo is born. 1363 a. Eq Apple Bloom is born. Sweetie Bell is born. 1375 a. Eq Nightmare Moon returns Nightmare Moon is defeated by the bearers. 1376 a. Eq Discord returns and tries to take over again. Discord is defeated by the bearers. 1377 a. Eq Queen Chrysalis covers herself as Cadence and tries to take over Canterlot. Queen Chrysalis is defeated by Cadence and Shining Armor. King Sombra and the Crystal Empire return. King Sombra is dispelled. Shining Armor and Cadence are the new leaders of the Crystal Empire. 1378 a. Eq Discord is reformed by Fluttershy. Twilight becomes an alicorn and is crowned the Princess of Friendship. Sunset Shimmer is defeated and reformed. Lord Tirek escapes Tartarus Lord Tirek is defeated by the bearers. 1379 a. Eq Starlight Glimmer is defeated and made Twilight's aprentice. 1380 a. Eq Flurry Heart is born. Queen Chrysalis is defeated by Starlight, Trixie, Thorax and Discord 1381 a. Eq Stygian is freed from the darkness. The stromking is defeated and Tempest is reformed. 1382 a. Eq The school of friendship is made Cozy Glow is defeated. King Sombra is resurrected by the fake Grogar. Lord Tirek, queen Chrysalis and Cozy Glow are also summoned. King Sombra is defeated by the bearers. 1383 a. Eq Tirek, Cozy Glow and Chrysalis are defeated and turned to stone. Celestia and Luna retire and Twilight takes their place.

Maybe his magic is even strong enough to keep her alive. I think he will be very sad and depressed and then I see two options: He has build new friendships over the years and keeps in contact with the ponies He falls back to evil because his friendships have faded away and he reformed again by Twilight again.

I think the song should be the same, but maybe longer with all the characters coming along. Maybe even an orchestral version. In my opinion the last problem is the first episode which should have the theme song playing at the end.

Gusty the great probably trapped his magic inside the bell, which made him mortal. I guess he died thousands of moons ago without anyone knowing about it.

Maybe it wasn't even the real Sombra, but something created by Discord to show the other characters what happens if the trio don't work together. Would explain the weird voice. But this is also a long shot. XD https://www.deviantart.com/wonder-waffle/art/Discord-Sombra-One-Deadly-Combo-405460985

I think Grogar should have been the end villain of mlp, and this is how it easily could have worked. Grogar could have been trapped inside the bell. Maybe Grogar was trapped inside the bell by Gusty. The trio of doom come to understand the bell, and just like in the canon version, and plan to get the magic for themself. Instead of the magic coming out, Grogar appears and tells them he is set free at last. After a talk he captures Chrysalis and Cozy since they are only interested in themself, and steals their magic. Tirek joins Grogar on his crusade. Then Discord comes back, but seeing the real Grogar with Tirek he tries to battle them, which he can't win. Discord returns to Canterlot and warns the ponies. Twilight informs the pillars, Starlight and the Crystal Empire. Trixie takes care of the students, and Starlight joins the pillars and try to return to Canterlot, but Grogar and Tirek caught them on the way. A big battle breaks out (Not like in the canon where plot armor was necessary) and Grogar takes the magic of the pillars, but Starlight barely escapes. From here it would be kinda simmilar, except for the trio being a duo. Chrysalis and Cozy could maybe reform or be of use for fanfics. This I think would leave a bit more impact on me then it did. I was quite good, but a bit anti-climactic.

Twilight Sparkle Starlight Glimmer/Sunset Shimmer Fluttershy Spike Rarity Apple Jack Rainbow Dash Pinkie Pie

28 pranks later was the worst imo. It just didn't feel right to me.