Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Star Petal

User
  • Posts

    273
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Star Petal

  1. I think my biggest GRIPE about the movie is that they made magic come back. I REALLY do not think they should had done that in this movie. Had this been a stand alone movie it would be great, but they need to retcon the ending so that magic didn't come back. I think a whole "mystery" and a "season long adventure' would had been a much better way to resolve this. Maybe all 3 pieces coming together could had revealed a symbol or a set of, I dunno, a clue of some kind that would had given the ponies something to search for together. Maybe they had to uncover what happened in the past that led to them losing their magic in the first place that could had been how they gotten their magic back and they resolve this at the end of season 1. Pegasi flying again would had been ok, but not both of pegasi flying and unicorns getting magic again. If the "superstition" thing doesn't remain, it would be too jarring of a change imo. It would be like all of them forgetting their culture completely which the bing bong thing basically is a part of as well as the pegasi being use to not flying. If it's been thousands of years since any pony flew than actually flying would be a scary thing for many of them which I hope they explore. Unless a villain of some kind or lingering prejudices are around, I don't see where else they can go with this atm since everything is resolved completely. All the leaders are in agreement they are wrong, magic is back, evil doesn't exist, the end? hmm....I dunno. Seems like making magic come back entirely would had been a great season 1 ender to me. Or maybe season 1 will be the first clues they will get to them knowing what actually happened in the past in the first place? Maybe we will start seeing the gaps of history between g4 and g5 and see what happened to twilight and their successors and what happened when the evil trio got out of their stone? Were they responsible for this and stellar or whoever took over after her was not prepared? Did the windigos destroy everything but died out themselves leaving the last surviving ponies of each race the only ones left and they blamed each other for the windegos return and destruction which is how thousands of years after the ice age we have today?
  2. You guys think they will keep the "BING BONG" thing going or is this a one time joke for the movie and then 100% of all the unicorns will never do that again whenever someone mentions magic or mayo?
  3. The only reason this isn't a cyberpunk future space travel series IMO is because civilization had to fall and fall really hard at some point and i think we are seeing them built their civilizations back up to just a little bit above where they left off. G4 being equivolent to the 80s or maybe the 70's before computers but stuff like turntables existed and now they have smart phones and computer tech. Only question is, if Equestria girls was set decades further into the future than their pony counterparts as far as tech goes, and thousands of years went by, does that mean that the new equestria girls will be set in a future where star trek tech is the norm?
  4. Yeah, but 1000 years ago is ancient history to us and celestia and luna were basically in their 30's when twilight took over. She had to have lived at least two thousand years and for even more time to be beyond that is hard to believe that they are not walking on other planets by then. lol.
  5. On one hand the movie was amazing, but on the other hand, this has SERIOUS implications for G4. The story basically means that everything twilight sparkle and her friends did, the royalty, Discord, the school of friendship and all the adventures they went on were basically meaningless. Twilight Sparkle ultimately failed and I don't know how to feel about that.
  6. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/tonyyotes/battle-gem-ponies-a-pony-wranglin-monster-tamer-rpg?fbclid=IwAR3nM76hZY2tZeJO5uZSKjYRsZwxLpHgnMoMUVNVwekDRS35fkySwE8cFlg It's like pokemon and mlp combined. I am getting a pony tamer named after me. I wanted to know if anyone else is backing this kickstarter.
  7. Highly unlikely. Twilight took over and is now the ruler and it showed a considerable time skip of at LEAST 20 years after the show ended and she was very obviously more perfect then ever. Twilight as a villain would not make any sense at all since she is the literal god of friendship.
  8. What concerns do you have for MLP G5? I have a few myself. The first is that they might go less musical with the new series which is what, to me, one of the main reasons that made G4 so great! The second was a sentence that stated that the main premise that G5 would focus on Modern Inclusion. The problem is Modern inclusion includes Gender and Gender only, and I don't want G5 to be My Little Pony: Gender is Magic. While I REALLY like how Izzy looks, the Toy Story Art style just doesn't allow for as much creativity and fantastical elements in it, not to mention it is much harder for facial expressions to be easily recognizable and can easily lead to scenes where we cannot tell what they are suppose to be feeling. What concerns do you guys have?
  9. Rainbow Dash's turtle was already old. Owls have a life span of 4 years. Twilight owned it before moving to ponyville. Bunnies have a life span of 1-2 years. It is 100% certain that Angel died several times through the series and just names the main bunny all angel. Dogs can die as young as 7 years. Applejack probably just kept it on the farm all the time though. Gummy has always been around and the final episode, gummy got big. Rarity's cat hates rarity. She could had finally gotten rid of it finally after realizing her cat hates her or it just stays at home.
  10. The way Rainbow Dash stated what she said heavily implies that they live together and this is a multiple occurrence of how she always takes care of the chores instead of letting rainbow dash do them. I see very little room to doubt they live together and AJ's normal pride being why she does all the chores around the house. Rainbow dash didn't say "If you just let me do YOUR chores" She said "THE" chores which means they share the same responsibilities around the house. They are shipped confirmed.
  11. pretty sure since rarity has grey mane hair that they are all going to die of old age and twilight's immortality will keep her going. Probably happened to Celestia dozens of times with any friends she has ever had.
  12. I just saw a gif meme on Facebook and saw that Bon Bon and Lyra proposed to each other half way through The Big Mac Question and I don't see anypony talking about this. WHHYYYYYYY [][/img]
  13. Rainbow Dash and Applejack Married. That is completely Obvious. Rainbow Dash and Applejack enters room together. Rainbow Dash: We could get to places faster if you just let ME do some of the chores instead of doing them all yourself! Then she has her hoof on AJ's head. Furthermore, RD has a lesbian hair style at the end. So obvious she became a super lesbo for applejack and they married.
  14. Give me a brohoof if you want to see MLP FIM end up like the simpsons. Anypony?
  15. So, if Grogar was Discord, and Discord was just pretending to be Grogar, and Grogar's bell DOES in fact exist which means there was a grogar.....what happened to grogar? The princesses never mentioned or hinted at him ever existing in the series, even during flash backs in the past. The final season is all we got and we got like 3 episodes or something of Grogar and the final episode is just a few seconds of him before he gets zapped into discord. So, where is Grogar, Why do you think his belle was locked up in some mountain instead at some sort of secret vault under the castle in the same manner so the princesses can keep an better eye on it, assuming THEY were the ones whom defeated him? How come with all of the friendship magic, the bell could not be destroyed? What happened to it post time skip? IS the real grogar going to stand up anytime soon? I think we have an movie straight to t.v or something coming out, right?
  16. What's everypony talking about? THEY ALREADY ARE! I already have Pinkie Pie and Twilight. Fluttershy comes around December I think, then Applejack, then Rarity comes after that and Finally...for some reason they made a black skinned Rainbow Dash which makes zero sense for what ever to make her a black girl because doing it for the sake of "diversity" alone would be pointless if None of the other characters were a different ethnicity and nothing in the series or EQG says she's black in any way and Fluttershy is still white despite also being a pegasus like RD. So...werid. BUT, they did say it was just a concept for RD so far so maybe they will correct the issue. Either way I will still buy it.
  17. Trixie Lullamoon, def Sweetie Belle and amethyst star. Trixie is best pony and the other two are my favorites.
  18. I think the ending to this HEAVILY implied that Rainbow Dash and Applejack are married. They were talking about chores and at the end RD had her hoof on AJ's head at the end.
  19. Totally did not expect to have the three main bad guys NOT be reformed at the end. Also, I got questions and complaints. 1. WTF?! Middle aged ponies? GAH! why did cheese and Pinkie, and 2. Are Rainbow Dash and Applejack a pair? This ending HEAVILY imploy this. Especially at the end where rainbow dash and applejack talk about "chores" and dash has her hoof on aj's head at the end. 3. I WANT MORE TRIXIE...why no show how everypony else ended up like?
  20. I am not so sure about this. It might be interesting, but some of those villains are far to reformed to come back as villains.
  21. Yup. I am sure that character will be back though. Especially since they are in the comics a lot. Probably be brought back sometime and made into a mind slave and then freed.
  22. I have a guess as to how the series will truly end. Grogar will be the shows one and only unredeemable enemy at the end despite it going against the curve for what the show teaches. Cozy glow, being a "friendship based enemy" is going to try her cutest and darndest to befriend Tirek and Chrysalis non stop. Eventually when it gets to the end of the series to the finale we are going to see moments of Grogar treating Chrysalis and Tirek and Cozy Glow, basically as his slaves. I think that with what Cozy Glow has learned about friendship at that school while trying to use it to gain power is going to play in a lot here. I think SHE is what is going to reform Tirek and Chrysalis. I think that at one point, towards the moment when the story seems it is going to end ( I cannot think of what that word is right now, someone please help me. The name for the height of the story at the most important moment before its conclusion begins? Like right just as the bad guy is going to win and when the story is at its most tense...what's that word! GGAH! It's bothering me) I think Grogar is going to do or say something that will drive Cozy Glow to do something, something like Stand up for her new "friends" Tirek and Chrysalis. Something like, You cannot say that to them or do that to them" etc. I think grogar might even try to hurt or KILL one of the two and cozy glow, with her friendship lessons in hand and having truly found someponys...or some monster and changeling, that she can truly understand and relate to since they too are power hungry villains and having spent ALL that time together for so long since we have no idea how many months in prison Cozy Spent with Tirek in Tartarus, I think she might stand up to Grogar somehow and maybe, maybe even become Hurt by a spell or some other thing he might do to hurt or even kill her villainous friends. When Chrysalis or most likely Tirek, since she has spent the most time with him sees her stand up for him and even maybe get really badly hurt, he might ask something like "why would you do that, for me?" Triggering the three most powerful words in all of animation, "because we're friends". With friendship swelling up in tirek and Chrysalis finally, I think an event like this is what is going to most likely happen setting up for the one key part of Grogars "master plan" to fail since it would instigate the one thing that his plans never accounted for and that is the evil villains learning the value of friendship through each other and I think they will end up saving the mane six and the land of equestria.
×
×
  • Create New...