The Recherche

The tail fell off, due to it being in used condition.  I know that this would make a lot of you want to slam your head into a wall until you knock yourself out, but I honestly don't mind too much. What I want to know is...

What kind of adhesive should I use to bond it back together? I already tried a form of superglue, and that didn't work at all. I just want to know what you guys and gals would recommend; I don't want the end of the figure to just become so caked in worthless adhesives that it's beyond repair. Should I even bother to fix it at all, and just buy a new one, or its there some kind of glue or epoxy that works really well on these kinds of figures?

Thank you very much in advance for an responses; it helps a lot~!