Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

GreyScholar

User
 View Profile  See their content

  • Posts

    2,274

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by GreyScholar

  1. GreyScholar
    @@Shift First off, I accidently brohoofed your post. My apologies. Second, I seem to be one of t b e few who actually liked Sword Art Online... and with this, Kirito. Which also means, I disagree with a lot that you said about the anime and it's protagonist. Also, another detail. You can play video games, even MMOs, with as much skill as Kirito. Heck, as an example, you can play through the whole of most any Pokemon game without losing a single battle. With this, though more challenging, play the game without a single one of your pokemon fainting. One just needs to train your pokemon right, have good strategy, and do a lot of grinding.
  2. GreyScholar
    Personally I feel if anypony is a Mary Sue, worst character, or badly written in MLP:FiM it is Starlight Glimmer. Warning, do NOT READ below if you have not seen the beginning and end of season 5. All in all, I feel Starlight Glimmer is a train wreck and is the worst redemption out of all shown. She is undeserving of what she had gained by season 6.
  3. GreyScholar
    Well now, we must view the show much differently because for me is on the top of the list and very much best pony.
  4. GreyScholar
    Who, pray tell is this? Why is he an asshole?
  5. GreyScholar
    Superman from Man of Steel and Dawn of Justice, worst portrayal of the character ever in my eyes. Especially in the second movie where he never bucking smiles and is as dark as Batman. A joyless and unlikable version of the hero I feel, hell the own universe is too dark and grim in my opinion.
  6. GreyScholar
    Oh hell no, that I completely disagree not and never understood at all. Here, this is a good place to look going over why Firestar isn't a Gary Stu: http://forums.warriorcats.com/topic/is-firestar-a-gary-stu
  7. GreyScholar
    @, Yes, but there is a difference between forgiving someone and still punishing them for what they did. Heck, neither even got community service or were put on probation. Also, Equestria is a world with magic all around it. With each race having there own magic and a third able to cast spells. I find it reasonable that their forensics team would have unicorns who specialized in spell able to help identify criminal whether they be other unicorns or any other race. Seriously, in a fantasy setting you must consider the world as if it was one who as adapted to magic in their everyday life. Even perhaps, with scientists or inventors who blend magic with technology. That is what is most logical.
  8. GreyScholar
    Starlight Glimmer being easily forgiven I feel is a major problem, as too there being no punishment for her actions. Her redemption in general was gravely mushandled. Heck even Trixie got away for her actions without consequence when it came to the Alicorn amulet becoming a dictator in a single day. Also don't give me it the the amulet controlling her and thus not her fault. If someone chose to get drunk, drives and then hits someone they are still at fault. Or someone who uses illegal drugs and commits a crime while under the influence, they too are also still punished. Trixie chose to buy the Alcorn amulet, despite the warnings given to her, and chose to put it on. Thus her actions are her fault, as simple as that.
  9. GreyScholar
    "She isn't too fond of vegetables either - I mean, has anypony ever seen her with any?" Weeeellll, there was that party with Mr. Turnip. Then that Head of Lettuce float with the CMC.
  10. GreyScholar
    You know, for those who follow a certain fanfiction, Twilight herself is a mother: For those that can't tell, this is Nyx wishing Twilight a Happy Mother's Day.
  11. GreyScholar

    movies/tv New Ghostbusters Movie

    GreyScholar replied to a topic in Media Discussion

    Personally I’d be just fine will an all female Ghostbusters team, or a new team in general… If the movie showed that they were a taking up the mantle of those who came before. The role of being Ghostbusters passed onto them by the original team and the challenges of such responsibilities while proving they are up to the take of taking over… Perhaps even offering updated tech and new tricks/ideas showing improvement in how things are done. Heck the original actors wouldn’t even have to make an appearance as long as the original team was brought up by the new and the whole situation involving the changing of the guard was explained in universe. They could even have Real Life Writes the Plot, offering that Egon died and Peter just wasn’t interested in staying on the team. Such would be better then pretending the new all female team are the originals and no one came before. That would have been more agreeable and would bring less backlash… At least for me, admittingly I can’t speak for others. It is about respect to the original, and not brazenly thinking they can redo the franchise with an all female cast without understandably have complaints/upset by fans of the original.
  12. GreyScholar
    Anyone disappointed in Sunset Shimmer not being in the movie needs to have some sense knocked into them, especially since she is by far overrated and somewhat poorly written, at least in the first and second movie. I don't get how some fans obsess over her as if she is some great character. I find the love many fans have for Sunset Shimmer almost as annoy as many fans hatred of Flash Sentry. Before any argue he was a badly written character, I argue most of the characters were in the first two movies.
  13. GreyScholar
    I believe Twilight Sparkle and the Crystal Heart Spell is just the book for you, Hasbro of course published it for younger readers but it clears up a lot of mysteries involving Princess Cadence. You should be able to find and read it online if you don't want to buy it. Onto your questions: Cadence was a pegasus orphaned as a foal, adopted by an earth pony couple in a small village. So no they were not nobility nor rulers of a kingdom. (A) Yes the Crystal Empire had already vanished when Cadence met Twilight, as that event took place a thousand years ago. (A) Cadence and Shining probably met when she started foalsittering Twilight, though they could have met at school. The IDW comics show that Cadence and Shining Armour knew each other in high school... but there is much debate on whether or not those comics can or should be treated as canon. (A) That... Can only really be answered with the IDW comics as well, in which the answer is yes though if memory serves not Saddle Arabia. Otherwise, there is nothing saying one way or another. One such 'country' was a surgery sweet and adorable race of felines with much love to give... Which Queen Chrysalis and her changelings drained mercilessly of love until there was nothing left.
  14. GreyScholar
    Well I find Twilight and Sunset together comically laughable, but admittingly I never put much stock the Equestrian Girls movies. If that is who you wish to ship so be it. I admit the second one annoyed me a bit but that is water under the bridge. I like Twilight and Celestia myself, maybe Rarity or RD.
  15. GreyScholar
    Hmm, really now? I would argue that Twilight would make more sense with Celestia or one of her friends, among the Mane Six, then with Sunset.
  16. GreyScholar
    I support Twilight and pony Flash, I ship them.
  17. GreyScholar
    @@Nuke87654, I had no idea what you were referencing, my apologizes.
  18. GreyScholar
    @@Nuke87654, Huh, really now? -stops taking you seriously- Well I do believe Twilight and a few other mares would take quite a bit of offense to you speaking such ill things involving their friend, Rarity herself being most hurt. I hope you are happy with your 'findings' and 'proof' because it will cost you the company of six wonderful mares. Rarity knows she is not guilty of any crime, as to does her friends, and anyone who ever knew her.
  19. GreyScholar
    @@Nuke87654, Actually, I had voted for Twilight* and she is my first favorite with Rarity being my second. *Or at least I had until I saw Twilight had a good lead, and then I switched to Rarity because I do find her more attractive. I wanted Twilight to win though, and I am glad she did.
  20. GreyScholar
    @@Nuke87654, Rarity Is Not That Sort of Mare! Do not defame her for the actions of another. :okiedokielokie:
  21. GreyScholar
    @@Nuke87654, I argue that Rarity would have had no idea, and be horrified to know some were trying to rig the competition so she would win.
  22. GreyScholar
    Wow, Twilight had a jumped quite a bit ahead in posts... though I also noted there was a number of ties and some cheating.with fake accounts.
  23. GreyScholar
    Twilight is two votes behind, lets see just how close this can get! Maybe Twilight can beat Rarity, surprising both mares with the outcome.
  24. GreyScholar
    @@Captain Sorzo,@@Cleverclover, @@Shimmer Sparkle, Please lets not make this negative, they are both wonderful characters each with their own traits and character to love.
  25. GreyScholar
    Now, now both Twilight and Rarity are amazing ponies and I will not allow anyone to say otherwise. I don't want to see any mudslinging! :okiedokielokie:
×
×
  • Create New...