Sooooo...we all know that MLP's been around for awhile. And the previous series can REALLY get people angry. But I'm curious to know the general mindset of the former series and/or movies amongst you bronies here.
A quick recap, for the unintiated:
G1
You got your original ponies, with two tv specials and a series. Probably the most famous or infamous part of these series is the villain of the first special, Tirec. He was like Nightmare oon in that he wanted to bring about enternal night. He was nothing like Nightmare Moon in that he was a frightneing minotaur/cenotaur demon that turned ponies into dragons. Yeesh.
Another good thing to note about the original series is that they were the inspiration for the ponies we know and love today. Firefly is now Rainbow Dash, Posey is now Fluttershy, etc etc. And from what bits I've seen, you can really see the family resemblance.
I personally liked 'Escape from Catrina,' the second tv special. You've got a villain who's basically a drug-addict and her shape-shifting boyfriend who wants to see her be on the side of good again. And the aforementioned Posey is in it. Yes, the ending sucks. Yes, the songs are kinda dumb (though I liked the villain song). But it's rather charming in it's...meh-ness.
I gotta admit, I'm liking the old-school ponies. They're no where near as awesome as FiM ponies, but they're not super-girly like everyone thinks. Though they come dangerously close sometimes.
G2
To be technical, the G2 toy line didn't have a tv series. This one, My Little Pony Tales, is actually part of G1. Kinda. But it's easier to say G2.
So basically, the fantasy/adventure aspect is completely gone. The ponies are all now boy-crazy teens who do human things instead of pony things. It's...a weird one. Ponies all walking around on two legs, using hooves as hands, singing about the boys who look just like the girls...its HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL WITH PONIES. D8
I can't really say much about this series, cuz I haven't watched it beyond a few clips. I will give it credit for introducing Bon-Bon to the world.
G3
....ahem....excuse me one moments....
....*shaky breath*...okay.
All I can say about G3 is that it sure broke a lot of stuff. This is the girliest crap I've ever seen. At least it gave us Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash, but even then...dear Celestia.
I remember sitting down and watching a G3 movie with my nieces. I only remember one song from it (it was about not wanting to take responsibility in life, and it was actually pretty catchy). And that I was writhing in agony the whole time. This is the girl who survived Manos. AND I COULDN'T HANDLE A PONY MOVIE.
So anyway, yeah. Terrible voice-acting, terrible characterization, terrible animation...and to be honest, I think THIS is the reason ponies are looked down upon so much. It is painful to watch something that was custom-designed to be this girly.
AND DON'T EVEN GET ME STARTED ON G3.5. For one thing, the ponies look like they're eternally in pain. They're even more shallow and toy-promoting than ever before. Then there's the newborns...
...ANYWAY. Yeah, that's my personal view on the past generations of ponies. None of it can hold a candle to FiM (well, duh , of course not ^^), but the original series is...nice...in its own way. No opinion on Tales. Wish to burn G3 to the ground.
What do yall think?
(if my essay was tl;dr, I apologize. ^^