Leafeon

Well, technically going left is a change of pace from going right. I'm not trying to shun anyone. I'm trying to get a decent answer, before I re-review this episode.

Nope. I'm asking for a validated opinion. And; I've been on far too many threads where I'm been shunned away due to not liking the finale. So a change of pace isn't bad. I also didn't say that that invalidates your opinion. I'm asking for you to confirm why the songs were good. But; I agree the plot was not very predictable. Provided I didn't know that it was going to end with Twilicorn, but I'm pretending I knew nothing for this thread, so yea.

Well, yes. And I'm talking about how the story is conveyed. The songs could be crap, and it would still do the same thing for the plot. Plus; if you like it for the songs, that's fine. I didn't like the songs though. I'm asking for a reason. (And I didn't find them catchy, like at all. Which is what everyone has been saying)

As I said already, what if I didn't know that? Then I would just take it for what it is, and it's not good. But, I see your point. Uhm. Ya. Songs are a bit less heavy weighted then the main point of a snack. So it does make sense... quite a bit.

I would suggest reading the OP again. I specifically said that the songs quality weren't one of the things I wanted to be an answer. The plot was a good idea, as I said. But it wasn't executed well. I didn't even notice many nice visuals; but it's this show, so I'm sure it was stellar. Regardless; eye candy is generally not why I like something (Except maybe with Moulin Rouge) Oh, sorry. Must have passed over that bit. ^^' I was just skimming, but I'll re read it sooonnn. Fair enough. I just like actual reason, personally. All your other points are what I'm thinking too.

Basically, you're reason is that it tried to do something, but failed miserably? And that's why you like it? Kay. Fair enough. Though you mention no cons. I apologize: But I can't take a completely biased review seriously.

People are actually agreeing with me? What sorcery is this? Well, yes. I completely agree. But like I said in the OP: What if I didn't know that? I would only know of the stand alone. So yea.

While I hate to bore you all with yet another thread about the finale; I would quite like an answer to this. (Sorry if existent - Search did not find anything) Well anyways; I would really like to know why everyone seems to be backing up this episode so much. Why am I asking this? Well; I haven't gotten a single answer yet. I've only heard "I just liked it." or "The songs were good." or even "I know it was rushed, but I liked how they were experimenting, which makes it a good episode." None of these are reasons I want. Songs are fine and dandy. I freaking loved The Flim Flam Brother's Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000. In fact; it's my favorite song of the show. But I didn't like the episode that much. Of course; songs made up half of this episode, so that point is valid. It's just not enough to love an episode. Experimenting is great! But; last time I mixed pizza and mint chocolate; it didn't taste too good. I didn't like it. I won't try it again. That's no reason to like something. And what most people are saying: "I just liked it." Why, though? I didn't; and I have multiple things to back up my opinion, while those saying this, don't. What I'm asking for is actual reasons. Also; don't say the premise was a good idea. I agree completely. I had so much hope for the idea, but it was executed awfully. A good idea is only worth anything if it's done well. And the last thing. I know that this is supposed to become a three parter. But that's also not a reason. For now; we have this. I am only asking why people like this. Alright. Thanks all of you who answer!

Well; seeing as how many fans have left the fandom thinking other episodes will be like it is a thing. Being experimental is fine; but I'll still critique it like any other episode.