Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'limestone pie'.

More search options

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


  • Navigating and Using MLP Forums
  • Site Problems & Questions
    • Subscriptions & Donations
  • Moderation and Rules
  • Roleplay World
    • Equestrian Empire
    • Everfree Empire


  • Approved Characters
    • Approved Cast Characters


  • Regular Banner Submissions
  • Contest Banner Submissions


  • Fanfiction Requests
  • Pony Fanfiction
  • Non Pony Fic Recordings


  • Canon Characters
  • Original Characters


  • Pony World Cup
  • Forum Events
  • Episodes
  • Making Christmas Merrier
  • Golden Oaks Library Readings
  • BronyCon


There are no results to display.

There are no results to display.


  • My Little Pony
    • Welcome Plaza
    • FiM Show Discussion
    • Sugarcube Corner
    • Equestria Girls
    • My Little Pony: The Movie
    • Classic Generations
    • Pony Life
  • Events
    • Forum Events
    • Making Christmas Merrier
    • Golden Oaks Library
  • Roleplay World
    • Everfree Planning, OOC & Discussion
    • Everfree Roleplays
    • The Archives
  • Octavia's Hall
    • Commissions
    • Requestria
    • Octavia’s University of the Arts
    • Canterlot Gallery
  • Beyond Equestria
    • General Discussion
    • Media Discussion
    • Forum Games
    • Ask a Pony
    • Forum Lounge
  • Canterlot
    • Throne Room
    • Feedback
    • Site Questions
    • Support
  • Poniverse
    • Canterlot Avenue
    • PoniArcade
    • Ponyville Live!
    • Gallery of Goodwill
  • Conventions

Product Groups

  • Commissions
    • Valtasar's Digital Art Commissions
    • Midnight's Commission Shop
    • Ariida-chi's Commissions
    • Ambergerr's Art Shop
    • Ezzy-Arts
    • Deerie's Commissions
    • Ody's Commissions
    • Moony Commission Shop
    • SonicPegasus Commissions
    • Berry-Bliss Commissions Store
    • Unicornia Workshop
    • Usager
    • PoisonClaw's Traditional Commissions
    • Lucha
    • Nihi The Brony's Commission shop
  • Hosting
  • Commissions Closed

Find results in...

Find results that contain...

Date Created

  • Start


Last Updated

  • Start


Filter by number of...


  • Start



Website URL

Discord Username

Discord Server








Steam ID


Personal Motto



How did you find us?

Best Pony

Best Princess

Best Mane Character

Best CMC

Best Secondary/Recurring Character

Best Episode

Best Song

Best Season

Hearth's Warming Helper

Fandoms Involved In

Found 13 results

  1. "Alright everypony, listen up, the name's Limestone Pie and don't forget it! Lately business has been slow on the rock farm, and Pinkie said doing one of these 'AMA' things would help get our name out there. Personally I don't buy it, but I'm willing to try anything at this point. So ask your questions I guess, me and my sisters will answer what you got." "But because I'm in charge you should ask me the most questions! Just keep 'em short, I got work to get back to - ain't that right Marble?" "Mhmm!" -------------- Welcome to the Pie Family thread, where you may feel free to ask questions of any of the sisters at your leisure! Have fun with it, but be sure to oblige by a couple ground rules if you'd be so kind Keep questions safe and within site rules Be mindful not to ask repeat questions Don't spam I look forward to your questions!
  2. It seems Pinkie's parents are very good people and they raised four great daughters as well. But I keep thinking, Pinkie has been quite depressed as a filly. And only by the luck of magical outside influence, she became Pinkie. It seems like Pinkie didn't had a chance or even an idea of being herself in that environment, and that environment was created by her parents (No talking, no smiling). Of course Pinkie could have turned out to be like Maud and Maud is one of the most awesome ponies of Equestria, but isn't it the parent's duty to raise a child for them to become what they truly are and give the opportunity for them to choose? What if Maud was like Pinkie Pie but only became Maud just because of the environment of the dull and harsh farm around her? What if the only reason Maud likes and knows so much about rocks are because she grew up having nothing but rocks around her? What if the reason she doesn't talk or laugh that much is just because her parents? How much is herself? I'm conflicted. Even they were very accepting of her when the party happened, but they didn't even know about it before. Do you think Pinkie Pie's parents are responsible for her unhappiness as a filly? Is it inevitable in some degrees for the parents to not see it beyond the reality they are in? In what circumstances that the parents have to give up free choices for the children? (It was an uncommon concept in the old days) How necessary are non-productive entertainment and hobbies for children? Are children doomed to inherit the flaws of the environment created by the parents? What if the rock farm was too harsh that they had do work extra hard to make a living? This isn't just an MLP question (the issue would be diluted if it was debunked by the trivia from the show), this is a more broad question about raising children. What do you think?
  3. As Season 9 marks the end of a groundbreaking generation of MLP, certain questions will be raised or remain, as I highly doubt that the show will address everything at once. For me, it is: what will become of Limestone and Marble Pie, the other Pie sisters? These two were interchangeable in the 1st season as fillies, and even though they were eventually given their own personalities, they still tend to be mentioned collectively. The MLP wiki didn't even give them separate pages. That may be because they were backburned by Maud Pie, a character whom the audience was supposed to pretend that she grew up with Pinkie, Limestone, and Marble on the rock farm, even though she was MIA in "Cutie Mark Chronicles." Maud Pie is a unique character in her own right and a welcome addition to the series, but she conspicuously overshadowed the two sisters we've known longer. As the series continues from "Hearthbreakers" onward, Limestone and Marble have become more layered characters, adding interesting details that I would not expect to see from them. For Limestone, I was turned off by her hostile behavior and bad attitude. But her actions are not without reason. She is essentially the leader de facto of the rock farm and is tasked with the important objective of guarding Holder's Boulder. I bet Limestone's dealt with quite a few threats to the boulder. She also suffers from misery, which may be due to spending her life on a rock farm, and has jealousy issues. Despite her flaws, she has some sage advice for Pinkie in "The Maud Couple," explaining to her that even if you may not understand someone, if someone you love understands said person, that's all that matters. I initially dismissed Marble Pie as a moeblob who was seemingly created just to be a potential love interest for Big Mac. Personality and character development seemed irrelevant; if a character could make some cute, shy faces and squeak, bronies would be all over that sh*t. I thought it was ridiculous that Marble Pie won a big poll for best Pie sister. Eventually, I gave in to her cuteness, especially as Fluttershy grows more assertive and less, well, shy, making Marble the go-to shrinking violet of the show. I love her color palette and her mane. I also love how she can speak so much without saying a word. In "Maud Couple," it was unexpected when she shot her rude sister Limestone a dirty look and managed to convince her to solve Pinkie's issues with Mudbriar without saying a word. She can say, "I can't believe Pinkie Pie and I are sisters," "Limestone, that wasn't very nice," or "I'm listening." She's essentially the Silent Bob of the MLP universe. Silent Bob's been chasing Amy. Likewise, Marble Pie may be chasing Big Macintosh. Her little ship tease with the big guy never panned out for whatever reason, and I thought the staff would pretend MarbleMac never existed. In the SugarMac episodes, Marble was not mentioned, not even as a first crush. But then, "Best Gift Ever" happened. It only lasted for a couple seconds and may be easily missed, but Marble Pie's heart was shattered that day. It was a powerful image for those who caught it, and reactions were all over the place. Some felt the scene built sympathy and relatability to the character. Some felt it was a slap in the face to MarbleMac shippers. Some fans felt Marble should've reached out to Big Mac more. Others brought up the, "Are the Apples and Pies related?" argument. But what most would agree on was that it was painful for Marble Pie and the audience. Regardless of the scene's intentions, it's laid the groundwork for an interesting concept: Marble Pie dealing with her unrequited love, moving on, and finding somepony else to love. I say unrequited because Sugar Belle was deemed Big Mac's first crush, implying that Marble had feelings for him the entire time that he never reciprocated. Ouch. It was that episode that solidified my love for the youngest Pie sister. Limestone and Marble are two characters who have grown on me over the course of the series. With Limestone's jealousy and Marble's heartbreak, a potential episode exploring possible romances for the two would likely give them a much deserved happy ending. And even if their romantic desires had been fulfilled prior to season 9, I would love to see them play off one another and find a way to escape the drudgery of working in a rock farm. Thankfully, them receiving additional exposure on the show is granted, evidenced by them and Maud playing a small, but pivotal role in Pinkie's story in "Best Gift Ever" like in "The Maud Couple." They even teased Marble speaking! I don't doubt they will make an appearance in Season 9, even if it is for the sole purpose of Marble saying something punchy, but a starring role for the two is uncertain, as countless plot threads, settings, characters, etc. vie for a role in the spotlight. But Season 9 may be the one that will go all out, so nothing is entirely ruled out. This could be the season which puts them at equal importance with Maud Pie, and if not, still ensures they are well-developed, much appreciated characters.
  4. Don't mind the fact that some of these are sideways. Also don't mind the fact that these were drawn using pencil and paper. The other spoiler contains everything drawn using my primary art style.
  5. During the song in the season 8 premiere "School of Friendship" there is a part where the book is levitating but Twilight's horn is not lit and in the season 8 finale there is a pink stream of magic going into Pinkie. Is pinkie levitating the book? Does one of her parents have a kind of genetic disease that keep the horn from growing out but still exists, Marble and Limestone might be earth ponies but having Maud and Pinkie will explain "some" of their abilities with Maud's super speed and strength from "Maud Pie", and Pinkie's ability to teleport in "Party of One" and "A Friend in Deed", and being able to keep up with Rainbow Dash by using a speed spell in "Party of One". P.S. Please don't say that this was just an animation error in the first picture, i know it is, unless the writers go back to this in season 9.
  6. I generally avoid posting here because of how I never get any feedback, but I want to see if this is any different. I'd highly appreciate verbal feedback, not just a brohoof by itself. (Title idea based off a suggestion by my brother)
  7. Hi everyone. Welcome to the Limestone Pie fan club, the rules are as follows: No bad language (no swearing, cursing) No bullying (no badmouthing any other forum members, let's all be friends here) NEVER post naughty/NSFW images (please keep this fan club clean for all ages) If you wanna break the rules, then... That being said, have fun!
  8. HEY, EVERYPONY!!!!!!!! Welcome to my super awesome totally PINKIE-TASTIC "Ask a Pony" topic! I know I've already got a couple here in the forums, but I figured I'd make one for all of my amazing sisters and I! So, if you've got any burning questions for one of us, feel free to ask them. *squee* What Pinkie said. Mmhm. DON'T TOUCH HOLD--oh wait, hi, everypony. I'm a bit busy here on the rock farm, but I'll try to answer questions when I can.
  9. Among the Pie sisters, it is very clear that Maud is the only other Pie apart from Pinkie that gets the most attention and interaction with other ponies. Suppose one of her other sisters such as the grouchy Limestone Pie tried to do the same thing. How much more of an uphill battle would that be for herself, for Pinkie, and for everypony else to get Limestone to interact and get along with other ponies?
  10. There's something about the concept of sharing traditions that drives me to think how wonderful differences are. We don't see the world on the same way; each one of us have our motivations, experiences and dreams to accomplish. We want to share our own perspective with the world, and also want to see what others have to offer. That's one of the bases of fandoms, expand what we think we know and learn about different ways to see one particular thing. To make it work, we have to learn how to listen, and try to understand why other person thinks differently than you, and be grateful that this idea can be not only spoken, but heard. Season 5 episode "Heartbreakers" portraits this idea wonderfully. It's not perfect, but goes well with the standards of the show. I enjoy seeing Pinkie Pie and Applejack interact like the knew each other for years. I mean, like a childhood best friend. It's heartwarming, and anyone with that one friend can relate. The are almost opposites in personality sometimes, but also share a lot in common, particularly the silly sense of humor. If you want Pinkie to be your best friend, just go along with that. The pies are also unique and interesting. The 4 sisters are three extremes and a neutral centerpoint in the spectrum of emotions. Limestone is anger, Marble is timidness, Pinkie is joy, and Maud is... Maud. It's a clever way to make a character. I'd love to see them around on season 7. A family related episode is always welcome to my list of personal favourites. Bring me the Pie and the Maud, gud sir. Twitter! deviantArt!
  11. Finished this during this mornings live stream. I hope you enjoy it! Who is your favorite sister? Connect with me here:
  12. The holidays in My Little Pony are brought to you this time by Nick Confalone. Can he do ANY better than his first episode? To subscribe:
  13. I've always enjoyed the notion and the idea of the songs we know and love to sing have a pony twist to it. A Pony Parody if you will. I got this idea from watching "Heartbreakers". And the idea of Maud rapping about her love for rocks in her deadpan state was hilarious to me. I thought the name Igneous Paradise would a perfect fit for the work. Feel free to give me any feed back. Hope you like Igneous Paradise by Maud Pie featuring Limestone Pie (In the style of Coolio’s Gangsta’s Paradise, and Weird Al Yankovic’s Amish Paradise) (Maud) As I walk through the farm in which where I was raised I take a look at my rocks, and I truly am amazed Coz life’s just perfect for a pony like me Where the rock farm’s the pride of my family. We got Marble hitchin’ a wagon of slate And Limestone’s chippin’ fragments of conglomerate But I can only contain my excitement for so long, that Even Pinkamena thinks my mind is gone I’m a mare of sediment, it’s my discipline We got flint, marl, and even travertine… fool I’m the Pie-ist Pie the little fillies want to be like Rock farming day and night, scoring’ points in rocktorate (Limestone) Been spending most our lives Livin’ in Igneous Paradise We make quartzite walls and tiles Livin’ in Ingneous Paradise Its hard work and sacrifice Livin in Igneous Paradise We sell shale at discount price Livin’ In Igneous Paradise (Maud) They got the situation, the got me facin’ Can’t live a normal life, because rocks are my passion But I wouldn’t change a thing, because rocks are my love For me to turn my back, you know that’s unheard of Boulder is my homie, my sisters are my crew And my parents would agree that rocks are totally dope… fool If you come to our farm, you’ll be spoilt for choice We have rocks of all kinds to add to your invoice Would I choose chalk or chert, or even breccia too? With all the options here I don’t know? (Limestone) Tell me why are we, so blind to see? That the pony in charge, is the one you see. Been spending most our lives Livin’ in Igneous Paradise We’re just plain and simple Pies Livin’ in Igneous Paradise Holder’s Boulder’s the gleam in my eye Livin’ In Igneous Paradise But stay away unless you wanna fight Livin’ in Igneous Paradise (Maud) Diggin’ up the quarry, wagon on my shoulder Cuttin’ slabs of sandstone, getting’ food for Boulder You say that rocks are all the same, but I’ll be here to teach you That rocks are much more than what lies beneath you They so grey, they’re so round And your new pet rock will certainly astound… fool (Limestone) Been spending most our lives Livin In Igneous Paradise We’re all crazy geo-ites Livin In Igneous Pardise Our mine’s full of stalactites Livin In Igneous Paradise But don’t you ever think it bites Livin In Igneous Paradise