web What is the worst fanfiction you've ever read?

[Lord Bradley 1,319]

Read too many to choose, honestly. I've probably read over 50 overly disgusting, vulgar and/or stupid fanfics to even choose choose one for spot Nr. 10.

 

Maybe i should stop reading them... Nah, i need the time-waster.

Edited January 15, 2015 by Bradley

[VitalSpark 1,830]

I won't post a link because it would probably fall foul of this site's policies on NSFW material. But it's about unbirthing, and includes a pony called "Appleblume" (sic).

[ponylaces 1,869]

I got into reading fanfiction because of this fandom, and fortunately I haven't read any horrible fanfics yet.

 

I do remember reading this horrible but hilarious Sonic fanfic that a friend showed to me.

A long Scootaloo fan fiction that I shall not say the name of. You can note me if you really want to know, but it has various disgusting elements such as the R word that rhymes with tape, torture, intercourse that causes great harm to Scootaloo, gore, pure cruelty, and... descriptively mutilating ponies' parts.

 

It was nonetheless well written and had an interesting story in some ways, which is why I read quite a bit of it, but it got too sickening for me eventually.

I think I've read something like that. I felt very uncomfortable after reading it.

[10InTheTardis 509]

my own fanfiction from when I was 11. cringefest.

[Lyra's Pants 154]

I once wrote a fanfiction about a relationship pairing with Trevor Phillips and Fluttershy. What was I thinking?

[Hocus Pocus 636]

"My Immortal"

 

It was one of the worst experiences of my life funniest things I've ever read!

[Mand'alor Dash 2,224]

When I was a younger man, I would have said My Little Dashie was the worst thing in the world to ever feature ponies. And while that fic is still pretty bad, my anger has begun to subside, thanks in part to a lesser-known SFM adaptation of it that I actually kind of like.

 

But thanks mainly to my discovery of a horse story that beats out its shittiness in every category. Now, it may not be a written work, but that's no trouble. The animation and voice work are so bad that it may as well just be text. The story patronizes the viewer at every turn and insults their intelligence in ways that MLD could only dream of. The characters are portrayed egregiously, to the point that it has Rainbow Dash berating Fluttershy for not aborting Scootaloo, and it isn't even the kind of bad you can make fun of. It's the kind of bad that shits all over these characters you've come to know and love over the course of the show.

 

THIS is the single worst thing that bronies have ever created.

[Windseeker 546]

The Pony Centipede.... or any other Trollfic for that matter.

[Rainbow Dash1 92]

My Immortal. It's amazing.

[IJoinedForPonies 124]

I would have to say Cupcakes... Every time that gets mentioned I get depressed thinking about it. Normally I am immune to such content, but that one really hits me hard. -.-

[cuteycindyhoney 13,282]

I thought "My Little Dashie" was terrible. I never finished reading that mess. There was also one I hesitate to mention. I do not recall the title, but it concerned

I changed my mind and edited what it was about out of my post. It was too nasty for words

 

Edited January 20, 2015 by cuteycindyhoney

[Toaster Bot 183]

My Little Pony: Will of Fire. My god, it was awful. And that was what I read of it, which wasn't much (very quickly I felt that my internal organs were conspiring to shut themselves down in anyway possible so as to spare me the torment). It is really bad. In the community where I first discovered, it has a legacy unlike anything I have ever seen. People made dramatic readings and tried to see how far they could get through what was then only a list of 40 or (fake) episode synopsis. It is that BAD.

[pakicetus 312]

From MLP, "Fluttershy's Burrito Adventure". Highlights include Rainbow Dash dying because of how bad Fluttershy's farts smell. I wish I were making this up.

[hawkflame 3,308]

Rarity's New Dress.  Even ignoring the material( which is cupcakes like) the writing itself was just really, really shitty.

[pakicetus 312]

I forgot to add: My Inner Life, from a delusional Legend of Zelda fan.
 

My Immortal. It's amazing.

Isn't it?
 

Rarity's New Dress.  Even ignoring the material( which is cupcakes like) the writing itself was just really, really shitty.

 

*loads up a new tab"

[Odyssey 5,713]

Aww, come on guys, My Immortal is not that bad. It may have started some notorious character clichés, but Enoby's cringeworthy dialogue and personality is hilarious. Plus I'm really convinced that it's a trollfic due to the constant grammar mistakes, Mary Sues, self inserts and references.

 

I forgot to add: My Inner Life, from a delusional Legend of Zelda fan.

 

If you go to the Trivia page of My Inner Life on TV Tropes, you'll actually learn that the creator of My Inner Life is ashamed of what she has written. It's still a silly fanfic regardless.

Edited January 20, 2015 by Odyssey

[Shadow Beam 1,179]

One of those "Human goes to Equestria and actually gets a strange power that no one else have and then for some reason goes with Spike to some new continent and learns martial arts" thingy

[ghostfacekiller39 23,856]

My Little Dashie sucked, in my opinion. 

 

Then there's the amazing fics I wrote for the Ace Attorney series a year and a half ago, which are pretty terrible too

[Yellow Diamond 7,561]

About a week ago, my friend and I started sifting through Frozen fanfics. We came across several fics involving Hans and Kristoff, none of which I can link here without violating the NSFW rules. What I will say is that they were terribly overwritten; sentences and descriptions were absolutely tortured; dialogue attribution was mishandled. The author wrote so much yet lacked any sense of how to write.

 

We ended up reading lines and injecting commentary for our amusement. The experience was marvelous in terms of humor, but the stories were garbage.

[BritishBrony2012 718]

Some of them that read, I'm not really into fanfic much, but enjoyed some. Worst I read was Cherliee's garden and it's squeal.

Edited January 20, 2015 by AdamBurt

[[NULL] 906]

Okay, maybe this isn't the ABSOLUTE worst of the worst fanfictions I've seen. That honor goes to My Immortal.

Edited January 20, 2015 by SpaceOnion

[Celli 4,332]

Can't remember the name, but I read this one fanfic where the Mane 6 are eating a picnic and Twilight's sitting on top of a hill, and then Pinkie comes up and accidentally pushes her off the side, and then there are multiple Twilights that keep reappearing and getting killed. It was weird.

[10InTheTardis 509]

Everyone here hates my little dashie but I'm just here like. "umm that's my favourite mlp fanfiction.  "

[whitetiger187 197]

Hey, I actually really like My Little Dashie. It just needs some refining in many parts.

[FoxyCryptid 4,327]

Would you believe I don't remember?

 

There's this fanfic on the edge of my memory that was so bad I've blocked it out and can only remember that it pissed me off on every conceivable level.

 

Also, SAM(I wasn't going to mention it because it's so bad, but other beat me to it). It's one of the few things do depraved it got cut from the Creepypasta Wiki for content reasons.