Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

How did Pinkie know Twilight was a pony Princess?


KatySimmer

Recommended Posts

Dear Princess Celestia Bronies and Pegasisters,

 

How in Equestria did Pinkie know Twi was a pony princess? At first, it seems like Pinkie just being Pinkie, but look a little deeper, you realize that's not it. After some thought, I'm guessing that there is a Pinkie Pie in every universe, including ours, but instead of several Pinkies spread across dimensions, there is only one Pinkie (in Equestria) and the other Pinkies are simply clones or robots controlled by the pony Pinkie. Pinkie might hop universes every now and then. This would also explain why Pinkie has 2 party cannons in the Friendship Games instead of just one, because this was the pony Pinkie coming in from Equestria and having a clone or robot replacing her in the pony world. It seems crazy, and I haven't got much info to back this all up apart from the fact Pinkie knew that Twi was a pony princess and the 2 party cannons. If you have anything to add to this, please inform me. Thanks!

 

Your Faithful Student Fellow Fan,

KatySimmer  :pinkie:

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm going to repost my answer from another similar topic about this:

 

I always thought that when Pony Pinkie put her hoof in the mirror at the beginning of the film, a little of her knowledge slipped through and planted itself inside Human Pinkie's mind. So when Twilight was about to confess, the info slingshot right outta Human Pinkie's mouth. Likewise, at the film's end, Human Pinkie slammed into the closed portal. That caused some of Human Pinkie's knowledge to slipped through and planted itself inside Pony Pinkie's mind. Need I explain more?

  • Brohoof 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

She knew because it was funny. That is what she does, she uses cartoon logic to do funny things. There is no profound reasoning, no conspiracy, no intricate backstory, she just knew because it was funny. Any head canons and make-belief on anyone's part as to how she knew is just a form of insanity on the persons part and inability to simply accept simple notions in a cartoon. Just suspend your disbelief and enjoy the show.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pinkie is an Idiot Savant (usually, the accent is on the idiot).  However, sometimes she has some truly AMAZING insights.  For example, in Luna Eclipsed, she figured out what was going on hours before Twilight did.  IMO, she simply saw the horn & wings & reached the logical conclusion before anypony else did.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@@WiiGuy2014,

There are a few flaws to your theory:

1. Human! Pinkie would have to be by the portal in order to get the knowledge from pony! Pinkie.

2. If human! Pinkie was at the portal, I'm pretty sure she would have noticed a hand sticking out of the statue.

3. If human! Pinkie was at the portal, she would have been the first to meet pony! Twilight.

 

But apart from those little nitpicks, this is by far the most interesting theory I've gotten! No offense to anyone else. The majority of replies were 'that's just Pinkie'. But I still don't know how did Pinkie know Twi was a pony princess! HOW?

 

The world may never know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@@WiiGuy2014,

There are a few flaws to your theory:

1. Human! Pinkie would have to be by the portal in order to get the knowledge from pony! Pinkie.

2. If human! Pinkie was at the portal, I'm pretty sure she would have noticed a hand sticking out of the statue.

3. If human! Pinkie was at the portal, she would have been the first to meet pony! Twilight.

 

But apart from those little nitpicks, this is by far the most interesting theory I've gotten! No offense to anyone else. The majority of replies were 'that's just Pinkie'. But I still don't know how did Pinkie know Twi was a pony princess! HOW?

 

 

The world may never know.

I never said the Pinkies had to be touching each other for the knowledge to pass; just that Pony Pinkie had to just dip her hoof into the other world and the info would invisibly find its way to Human Pinkie's mind! They both follow cartoon logic way more than the characters after all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd say it's just a manifestation of her Pinkie Sense. She's used to accepting vague feelings and hunches and acting on them. :proud:  Seems simple enough to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

I never said the Pinkies had to be touching each other for the knowledge to pass; just that Pony Pinkie had to just dip her hoof into the other world and the info would invisibly find its way to Human Pinkie's mind! They both follow cartoon logic way more than the characters after all.

 

Hmm.. true. I'm gonna let this pass for a while. I've got some episode watching to do. What do you think? Stay brony.

 

*brohoof*

 

KatySimmer 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...