We KNOW who coughed!

[Pinkiepie321 1]

Okay I am going to assume you guys have read the cough? For those who haven't:

 

Spoiler Alert::

 

In an apocalyptic world, where a horrible sickness is spread via cough and the only way to stop it is to kill the pony who coughed, The Mane 6 [i have NO idea where Spike is] lock themselves in a room with no windows and enough food and water to last them months.They are in pure darkness. It is the only safe place in Equestria. That is, until someone coughs.

 

The Mane 6 goes around asking each other who coughed. Fluttershy admits it's her and asks Rainbow Dash to deliver her a swift death. Rainbow ills her, and then they discover the truth, Fluttershy WASN'T the one who coughed

 

Spolier Ended

 

So, by reasoning, I can narrow this down to two ponies, I will leave the discussion up to you guys. I did process of elimination, so,yeah.

 

First off, Apple Jack is off the suspect list, being the element of honesty that she is, it would be impossible for her to say that she didn't do it.

 

Obviously Fluttershy is off as well, because, although she could of been the pony to cough first and then somepony else caught it, I don't think it spreads that quickly.

 

Third, Rainbow Dash. The meaning of loyalty is willingness to lay down your life for someone else's, so,no.

 

Then, Rarity. Genorosity means "showing a readiness to give more of something [i.e your life]  than is expected." If Rarity DID cough, she would give herself up so her friends could live.

 

And that leaves two, Pinkie Pie and Twilight. These two are hard, because though both of them have one or two things that cold help, there is nothing that proves 100% that they are innocent.

 

First Twilight:

The Princess Of Friendship, well yeah but that doesn't mean she wouldn't lie to save herself.

 

Her element is magic, that does not help her with this, it couldn't be Rainbow Dash, Rarity,Fluttershy or Apple Jack, because their elements are the only evidence they need. If Apple Jack was accused she could say "I am the element of honesty, how could I lie?", but TWILIGHT can't say that.

 

Second Pinkie Pie

 

She wants to keep others happy, well, she may think that without her, nopony will be happy.

 

Also with Twilight, Pinkie Pie's element REALLY does not help her here.

 

So who do you think it is?

[AlbaTross 1,581]

Okay I am going to assume you guys have read the cough? For those who haven't:

 

Spoiler Alert::

 

In an apocalyptic world, where a horrible sickness is spread via cough and the only way to stop it is to kill the pony who coughed, The Mane 6 [i have NO idea where Spike is] lock themselves in a room with no windows and enough food and water to last them months.They are in pure darkness. It is the only safe place in Equestria. That is, until someone coughs.

 

The Mane 6 goes around asking each other who coughed. Fluttershy admits it's her and asks Rainbow Dash to deliver her a swift death. Rainbow ills her, and then they discover the truth, Fluttershy WASN'T the one who coughed

 

Spolier Ended

 

So, by reasoning, I can narrow this down to two ponies, I will leave the discussion up to you guys. I did process of elimination, so,yeah.

 

First off, Apple Jack is off the suspect list, being the element of honesty that she is, it would be impossible for her to say that she didn't do it.

 

Obviously Fluttershy is off as well, because, although she could of been the pony to cough first and then somepony else caught it, I don't think it spreads that quickly.

 

Third, Rainbow Dash. The meaning of loyalty is willingness to lay down your life for someone else's, so,no.

 

Then, Rarity. Genorosity means "showing a readiness to give more of something [i.e your life]  than is expected." If Rarity DID cough, she would give herself up so her friends could live.

 

And that leaves two, Pinkie Pie and Twilight. These two are hard, because though both of them have one or two things that cold help, there is nothing that proves 100% that they are innocent.

 

First Twilight:

The Princess Of Friendship, well yeah but that doesn't mean she wouldn't lie to save herself.

 

Her element is magic, that does not help her with this, it couldn't be Rainbow Dash, Rarity,Fluttershy or Apple Jack, because their elements are the only evidence they need. If Apple Jack was accused she could say "I am the element of honesty, how could I lie?", but TWILIGHT can't say that.

 

Second Pinkie Pie

 

She wants to keep others happy, well, she may think that without her, nopony will be happy.

 

Also with Twilight, Pinkie Pie's element REALLY does not help her here.

 

So who do you think it is?

Hi, as this is the show discussion board, I have decided to move this thread to Sugarcube Corner where more general pony discussion takes place.

[Snake 515]

Based on what you've provided, my best guess would be Pinkie. Pinkie and Twilight were also the only one sitting by themselves, but I think Pinkie was the culprit.

[Venomous 18,813]

I remember listening to this fanfiction on YouTube a few years ago and I never came to a solid conclusion as to who it was that originally coughed. When I think about it now, I still don't have an idea; and I believe that's something the writer had intended. I suppose one could look deeply into it and decide for themselves who he or she think started coughing, but I would honestly rather leave it as a mystery.

[Brony Mata 134]

Reading the fanfic.... BY CELESTIA.... this is the worst case of Lavender Unicorn Syndrome ever....

Anyways, if it wasn't pinkie then I vote that all of them had it.

[Vulcan 3,254]

Discord obviously...

*Read in twilight's voice*    
Listen girls ...it's clear to all of us that NONE of us would have ever chosen to put the rest in danger. *insert long rambley speech about friendship*... Which brings me to one conclusion.

It was discord!

*rainbow's voice*   

Twilight! If it WAS discord, don't you think he would have stopped us from killing fluttershy?

*unknown voice*   

And just How do you know you killed "fluttershy"?

Edited March 27, 2016 by Vulcan

[FlootahBabby 265]

Fluttershy did cough. The cough spread to someone else after she was killed.

[BlinkZ 1,151]

nver rea this fic thing but uh..that not how air born viruses work!! killing the pony who coughed..that wont' stop  spread of an airborn virus at all.

[LHfunk 422]

nver rea this fic thing but uh..that not how air born viruses work!! killing the pony who coughed..that wont' stop spread of an airborn virus at all.

Haven't read it either, but it doesn't seem airborne, it like magic. Lame answer, but it fits.