A Second Hearts and Hooves Day Episode

[FlareGun45 2,221]

We've had three Heart's Warming episodes, two Nightmare Night episodes, two Galas, and only one Hearts and Hooves Day. Are we going to expect one sometime in the future? I know alot of the fandom seemed unhappy how about the Cheerimac ship, because it cancelled out their Fluttermac ship being probable, so I'm sure the writers are being super careful of how they ship their characters.

 

Anyone expect a Hearts and Hooves Day episode in the future? And if so, what might it be about?

[ManaMinori 4,143]

So many possibilities. They could go for romantic shipping, with Twist and Truffle, or Caramel and Sassaflash, or familial love with the mane 6 and their families, or platonic love with cheerilee and her students

[Miss 6,211]

No I doubt it. Wouldn't want to see any shipping in the show. I don't see why many were upset about that episode if Big Mac and Fluttershy literally have no relationship what so ever. Pretty ridiculous.

But anyway, if there was one it would probably involve some new characters getting through some relationship struggles and the mane 6 are helping out or something maybe the CMC idk. Another big part of life that a message could be given through even if it is more for an older audience rather than young girls.

[cmarston1 5,951]

I don't really see why we need another one seeing how not well received romance in the show is.

[Storm 199]

I'd love to see another Hearts and Hooves day episode! <3

[Megas 27,052]

I actually liked the original H&HD episode, but I don't know how they can pull it off a second time, having a Valentines Day episode featuring the Mane cast(though they could probably get away with it with Rarity or Spike) seems to be taboo among fans and the writers alike, and I'm not really interested on the interests of BG ponies

[ManaMinori 4,143]

I don't really see why we need another one seeing how not well received romance in the show is.

it's a day for love in all its forms. Not strictly romantic.

[Foxy Socks 2,596]

I for one would love a FlutterDash one, but that will never happen of course. I wouldn't mind one, as long as it doesn't forcibly ship anyone. Then again, I don't like most ships, but I cannot speak for everyone.

 

It would make sense if there is one, but I doubt any shipping with the Mane Six, if anything it will be a new character or sode one.

[The_Gobo 36,257]

Here's to more MarbleMac!
Here here!

[Buttonmash1973 1,024]

Simple Ways felt like a Hearts and Hooves Day episode.

[Luminance 2,181]

Maybe Discord may want to go out on a lovely date with Fluttershy.

[Steve Piranha 28,752]

We've had three Heart's Warming episodes, two Nightmare Night episodes, two Galas, and only one Hearts and Hooves Day. Are we going to expect one sometime in the future? I know alot of the fandom seemed unhappy how about the Cheerimac ship, because it cancelled out their Fluttermac ship being probable, so I'm sure the writers are being super careful of how they ship their characters.

 

Anyone expect a Hearts and Hooves Day episode in the future? And if so, what might it be about?

Oh yeah, let it be about Flashy confessing to Twi and she accepts and take cover from a fandom nuclear meltdown 

[The_Gobo 36,257]

Maybe Discord may want to go out on a lovely date with Fluttershy.

Or better yet, with Celestia

[sweetolebob18 724]

According to Hasbro, the1st 3 seasons ccovered 1 year. In fact, Princess Twilight (S4 season opener) is "2 days to the Summer Sun Festival"   That is, 1 year to the day from the pilot. So, IMO, S4 was year 2, late June to mid October (Scaremaster is Halloween & it has to be after at least the pilot)

 

IMO, S5 & S6 are scrambled together & S7 might be mixed in also.  So, yes, another Hearts & Hooves daycould fit 

[FlareGun45 2,221]

According to Hasbro, the1st 3 seasons ccovered 1 year. In fact, Princess Twilight (S4 season opener) is "2 days to the Summer Sun Festival"   That is, 1 year to the day from the pilot. So, IMO, S4 was year 2, late June to mid October (Scaremaster is Halloween & it has to be after at least the pilot)

 

IMO, S5 & S6 are scrambled together & S7 might be mixed in also.  So, yes, another Hearts & Hooves daycould fit 

 

What about the third Hearth's Warming episode? THREE years have gone by! So we're in Year 3 now!

[sweetolebob18 724]

IMO S5 & S6 are scrambled together & run from mid October year 2 to Winter, year three (the year running from June to June). If S7 is mixed in, it would be Spring, year 2.  That is, some of year 7 episodes are going to be before some of S5 episodes

 

Or, possibly, the Cutie Mark Crusaders are taking longer to graduate than any class since The Sweat Hogs on Welcome Back Kotter    

[Starlighty 790]

Personally i think the first episode was so well done and just simplying amazing that they would try too hard trying to make a second episode..

[Sovereign Leader Rarity 12,000]

Hopefully not. I can't say that I care for the original episode.

[snowflame 189]

Hopefully. But I don't think that the show cares much for romance, the Hearts and Hooves Day episode was a comedy one with a Emma type moral against matchmaking and the other romantic episodes; Canterlot Wedding and the two Cranky and Matilda episodes were more about the plot than anything (and the first one was due to Hasbro wanting it) and I can't think any really plot heavy Hearts and Hooves Day plot. But little romance is nice and it would be nice to see more of a existing holiday that we have.

 

My idea for an episode would be a Shining Armor/Cadance one where they are super busy trying to arrange some traditional Crystal Empire version of Hears and Hooves day celebration (that has some added reasons we could learn and not just love poison) and taking care of Flurry Hearth that they have no time for each other. And maybe some flashbacks to how they met (or are they able to do that when they comics had some explanation already). And have a moral of making time for each other (romance is a type of friendship anyway, it can be framed that way). We could learn about their relationships and traditions of the holiday the same time. Not the most innovative plot I know but we barely see the pair of them that I don't think it needs to be that if the Crystal Empire holiday plot has something interesting to going on (like if we could get a Crustal pony with a name finally) or there is flashbacks.

 

But I kind of think it won't happen. A new Nightmare Night episode seems more likely, there has been 2 to Hearths Warmings 3. And Hasbro probably likes Halloween themed episodes it can put on a DVD and market separedly. If we get Nightmare Night episode going back to the Castle of Two Sisters were the Pony of Shadows is a real thing or some kind of Daring Do episode that is related somehow to it would be my picks.

 

I guess I am getting exited for the new season to write episode plans like this lol.

[TwilightPomegranate 324]

If there is another H&HD episode, it should be about Starlight and Trixie.

 

 

Plot summed up in one for the episode: (Also, I think it'd be called "Kingdom Of Hearts")

 

 

Starlight and Trixie are faced with a dramatic Discord on H&HD. He wants to impress Fluttershy, but scared that her brother will take his idea. So, he decides to make a crazy Valentine's Day Kingdom, with traps and puzzles. But with Starlight and Trixie in the mix as well.

[Red Cedar 1,406]

Since we've had three Hearths' Warming and two Nightmare Night episodes, I'd say we're overdue for another Hearts and Hooves Day episode.

[FirePuppy 621]

I don't think there will be one in Season 7 because Valentine's Day only occurs on February, and the season will premiere from April to November.

[FlareGun45 2,221]

I don't think there will be one in Season 7 because Valentine's Day only occurs on February, and the season will premiere from April to November.

 

Oh yeah? If a Hearth's Warming episode can air on an October, a Hearts and Hooves Day can air on a May! XD

[GrimGrimoire 4,970]

 

Well it was not H&HD exactly, but we got the whole romantic relationship thing with BIG Mac and Sugar Belle recently. So maybe in S8 we will see her move to Ponyville or some such to be closer to him and tie it all up in a H&HD episode with the whole town kind of causing a ruckus and such.

[Jeric 46,834]

36 minutes ago, DallasGreatPyrenees said:

It's RISK

Silly pup, this is Risk

31 minutes ago, GrimGrimoire said:

 

Well it was not H&HD exactly, but we got the whole romantic relationship thing with BIG Mac and Sugar Belle recently. So maybe in S8 we will see her move to Ponyville or some such to be closer to him and tie it all up in a H&HD episode with the whole town kind of causing a ruckus and such.

Yeah, that episode fit the bill for the luvs and cuddle holiday. Also I am hoping that the SugarMac does lead to the relocation question. Sweet Apple Acres or Our Town? Perhaps a compromise ... Seaquestria!