Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

Cutie Mark Evaders?


ManaMinori

Recommended Posts

What if a counterpart club of fillies to the Cutie Mark Crusaders was found existing in Ponyville- and the club members were against getting their cutie marks. (And also had names that resembles the CMC's) maybe in attempt to having responsibilities and contribute to society after coming to discover their special talents (Peter Pan syndrome), or adopting the mindset of forever blank flanks being just as helpful to society without a cutie Mark.

Apple Sprout (earth), Cottonbell (Pegasus), and Star Dreams (unicorn), though all toyline exclusive ponies could perhaps be the CME club members. The "Rowdyruff Boys" counterpart to the Crusaders as far as goals go. Maybe eventually they can team up as 6 and help the Crusaders cave the world when the Mane 6 are saving it elsewhere. (And hey, they could get more merch and boost Hasbro's profit if they get an episode or two)

 

Going by their boxart designs, not actual toys(except for Star Dreams)...

post-23572-0-39581000-1489560868_thumb.jpgpost-23572-0-57283300-1489560890.jpgpost-23572-0-89443000-1489560920_thumb.jpg

Thoughts to share, anyone?

Edited by Nightmare Muffin
  • Brohoof 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The CMC meeting with fillies is an idea what I want to see. But Peter Pan syndrome is not healthy so I would want the CMC help the other ponies to see that (even there is no rush to get the marks, they should just accept it will happen eventually and its nit a bad thing).

 

And imo saving the world should be left for adults. I like that the CMM behave their age and not do exraordinary things like with many other kids shows, it keeps things grounded a bit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The CMC meeting with fillies is an idea what I want to see. But Peter Pan syndrome is not healthy so I would want the CMC help the other ponies to see that (even there is no rush to get the marks, they should just accept it will happen eventually and its nit a bad thing).

 

And imo saving the world should be left for adults. I like that the CMM behave their age and not do exraordinary things like with many other kids shows, it keeps things grounded a bit.

the Peter Pan issue could definitely be addressed,if they chose to go that route. But I think it should be gradual, as it's more realistic, and can offer more opportunity for the CMC's counterparts to make future appearances.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the idea for the story seems pretty cool and the whole counter part thing, seeing as the cmc lost their antagonist in diamond tiara... but seeing as fillies harass other ponies about not having their lives figured out, and many of the ponies seem insecure about not having a cutie mark, i doubt they would be "avoiding" getting their cutie mark.. this was more or less a flutter brutter type thing... now this could be explored by an adult pony that somehow still hasnt found their mark, but id imagine it would be more likely them helping him find his mark in some way rather than a pony that represses having a cutie mark, since it seems like something ponies judge other ponies about, you even see diamond tiaras mother referencing the blank flanks of the cmc...

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the idea for the story seems pretty cool and the whole counter part thing, seeing as the cmc lost their antagonist in diamond tiara... but seeing as fillies harass other ponies about not having their lives figured out, and many of the ponies seem insecure about not having a cutie mark, i doubt they would be "avoiding" getting their cutie mark.. this was more or less a flutter brutter type thing... now this could be explored by an adult pony that somehow still hasnt found their mark, but id imagine it would be more likely them helping him find his mark in some way rather than a pony that represses having a cutie mark, since it seems like something ponies judge other ponies about, you even see diamond tiaras mother referencing the blank flanks of the cmc...

the CMC definitely need a challenge, now that DT and SS aren't in the way. I think more episodes can come from my idea, rather than just an adult blank flank that is only around for one episode, in which the CMC help him.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That'd be a bit to silly for my taste. For starters, you can't avoid getting a cutie mark so the whole idea of such a club wouldn't work. Secondly, there's no real reason to avoid getting a cutie mark in the first place. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think this would be a BAD idea. The CMC finally got out of their "cutie mark pursuing" shackles, let them stretch themselves a bit. Or should I say, let the writers have a little freedom with CMC focused narratives.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...