A question about human Twilight

[Cosmic Spiral 19]

Every time we see the human Twilight Sparkle "pony up" we see her with wings. So does that mean if the human Twilight Sparkle ever made it to the pony world would she turn into an alicorn like her pony counterpart or would she be a pegasus even though her pony counterpart was originally a unicorn? 

[Will Guide 21,325]

1 minute ago, Cosmic Spiral said:

Every time we see the human Twilight Sparkle "pony up" we see her with wings. So does that mean if the human Twilight Sparkle ever made it to the pony world would she turn into an alicorn like her pony counterpart or would she be a pegasus even though her pony counterpart was originally a unicorn? 

I bet it's the alicorn one.

[Cosmic Spiral 19]

And yet the human Twilight hasn't really done anything to achieve alicorn status. She may be a Twilight Sparkle but there is subtle differences that makes her far from being the Twilight Sparkle.

[CypherHoof 26,479]

7 minutes ago, Cosmic Spiral said:

Every time we see the human Twilight Sparkle "pony up" we see her with wings. So does that mean if the human Twilight Sparkle ever made it to the pony world would she turn into an alicorn like her pony counterpart or would she be a pegasus even though her pony counterpart was originally a unicorn? 

Might be interesting if she arrived as a pegasus...

[Ganondorf8 11,118]

I'd say she would become a unicorn though the fact that she has wings when she "pony ups" would make her an alicorn.

[Cosmic Spiral 19]

Who knows. This could a more major difference in the two Twilights other than there personalities. 

[Steve Piranha 28,770]

On 2/1/2018 at 2:44 PM, Cosmic Spiral said:

And yet the human Twilight hasn't really done anything to achieve alicorn status. She may be a Twilight Sparkle but there is subtle differences that makes her far from being the Twilight Sparkle.

Yeah, I've been confused by that as well. Maybe the reason is familiarity, but I don't think human Twi ever remotely earned to be an alicorn if she was a pony. Sunny is the closest one for that privilege, if not earned it already by now  

[Castle Bleck 19,166]

To be fair, her becoming Midnight Sparkle might've influenced said wings.

Edited February 4, 2018 by A.V.

[Cosmic Spiral 19]

27 minutes ago, A.V. said:

To be fair, her becoming Midnight Sparkle might've influenced said wings.

That may be a good point

[Thrond 3,257]

I sort of assume she would have the wings if she crossed the mirror. It fits my headcanon that whatever magic is working to keep these worlds together also works to keep them in some sort of balance.