Spoiler S08:E23 - Sounds of Silence

[Loyal Defender 2002]

1 minute ago, RyanMahaffe said:

"nothing but uncharted terrain and wild beasts that way

AHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

AHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAH

..

MUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHhaha."

anyway I loved this episode.

If that becomes a GIF, I'm just done.

[RyanMahaffe 952]

11 minutes ago, Loyal Defender said:

If that becomes a GIF, I'm just done.

[Loyal Defender 2002]

12 minutes ago, RyanMahaffe said:

. . . .

 

*grabs drink, stands up and leaves without a word*

[gingerninja666 334]

Spoiler

I'm weirdly torn on this one. Because I wouldn't call it a "great" episode, but I'm going to be listening to that song on repeat so much.

Basically, I thought the mane cast were the weakest part of this episode. And that's not entirely fair because I thought AJ had some great lines and moments of being humble and protective.

But really, I thought the Kirin were by far the best part of this episode, and whenever Autumn is driving the conversation of a scene, the episode works. Her dialogue is really well written. She's sweet, you get her plight. Her song paints the picture of the tale so well and sums up the theme really touchingly I thought. I also loved the way their voices changed when they became the Niriks. I don't know why that stuck with me, but it did.

In contrast I kinda felt like the Appleshy disagreement and resolution and coming together of their skillsets felt a bit bleh. I know what they were going for by having them argue and then still be fine. It's a demonstration to the Kirin that you can disagree and still be ok. It still felt a bit... off.

I tend to feel like Map episodes work best either when it's the story of one of the called ponies (like Made in Manehattan is Applejack's story about feeling unworthy of being tasked with the mission), or if the problem involves things that the summoned ponies know about or are heavily involved with (like Dash being a Bolt during Top Bolt, or AJ knowing Flim and Flam in Viva Las Pegasus). This episode is neither. This is a completely new situation, and the episode is more focused on the situation than on the people sent to solve it.  It's like Hooffields and McColts in that sense. But I liked this more because I liked the kirin a LOT more than those two families.

I'm not saying this Starlight should've replaced someone in this ep, but it stood out to me that the chorus of the song felt like the exact inverse of Our Town. "You can't have a nightmare if you never dream," vs "You can't give up your laughter because you're scared of a little pain." I kinda wish Starlight had been there to hear it for some reason.

 

Edited September 1, 2018 by gingerninja666

[ShootingStar159 1924]

@gingerninja666

You should probably spoiler your review post.

Spoiler

I agree though, the kirin’s extreme solution to what seems to be a simple problem is very much like Starlight, and I think she could have taken AJ’s place easily and given the conflict greater depth. It really does feel like they used AJ and Flutters here just because they needed another episode.

 

[Photon Jet 2790]

I think I've got a new favorite character after seeing this episode.

[darkwingmare 1295]

I LOVE IIIITTT~ Autumn Blaze is an actual kirinfication of me and my personality. I haven't ever felt anything more relatable in the show than her. First of all, they live in a forest. They are Kirins! And she's even got copper hair like me!(and she's also pale as a ghost like mee) <33 She loves musicals, like me also..  I absolutely loved the Hamilton and Phantom of the Opera references in this episode as well.

Spoiler

The song was BEAUTIFUL, I can't wait to cover it. I also I love the moral of the story in general. The episode was beautifully animated and it included two of my favorite ponies out of the mane 6. Especially AJ of course. <3 

Did you all see her beautiful little loner house by the way? I would have LOVED to live there! Look at that view. <33

All of the Kirins were adorable! I've been wanting to see Kirins on the show since years back, 3 years to be exact.  v

Under the spoiler tag is an example of how I drew them in the "MLP" style in case anyone's curious.

Spoiler

ANYWAY, I love this episode more than I love.. Rainbows! <33 Okay not really more than rainbows but at least the episode was just as beautiful as one. <3

I'll stop now but I loved it! <3

Edited September 1, 2018 by darkwingmare

[Tao 5025]

Da List:

• Ok Kirins are the Vulcans of the pony world
• Please, let the OCS role out from this!
• Applejack still throws in apple refs...
• I like the designs,  it sticks to the historical fasts of the kirins from Asia.
• Ok so Breeze is a deep thinker,  REFLECTIONS  ! WE ARE PART OF EVERYTHING!
• MORE RAINBOWs
• Breeze and Pinkie should never meet,   the hyperness would be our DOOM!
• And a rodent saves the day! 

[ThE-DESpEraDo_4 8454]

Kinda liked the episode, specially with a new race, Kirins that is, added in the MLP Universe and all. Also, dig the designs of the Kirins too. And Autumn Blaze is awesome! It's a good thing that they chose Rachel Bloom to do her voice! Definitely fits her IMO. 

Edited September 1, 2018 by VenomPLA_04

[RulesofRarity 217]

Applejack and Fluttershy were so cute in this episode, that was definitely my favourite episode of the season. 

[TwilySparky 19772]

Wow, this was a fun episode to watch even if some people were insensitive and spoiled it. I really liked that song in the episode. People say this season has been awful, this episode laughs in there face and tells them they are wrong.

[Oleks 1111]

I really loved this episode – it’s definitely one of my favorites of this season.

Spoiler

A bit goofy first part, Fluttershy and AJ dynamics and the cute and brilliantly designed new race – all this worked very well.

This episode also has one of the most valuable lessons of the history of the show – anger is not something that should be avoided at all cost, it’s just one of natural emotions, and anger management is very important. After all these years MLP still continues to surprise me with the topic choices.

Some other notes. How the Kirin decided to refrain from emotions to avoid social conflicts and built their society around it gave me strong Equilibrium vibes. While the Kirin’s design is really great, I couldn’t tell their gender from their head shapes – it works for ponies, but apparently not for Kirin.

And I wonder how many takes it took for Tara Strong to deliver the “Flanks don’t lie” line without laughing.

 

[Steve Piranha 16101]

This episode marks the total ponyfication of the Powerpuff Girls Z

[Loyal Defender 2002]

5 hours ago, Photon Jet said:

I think I've got a new favorite character after seeing this episode.

I know, same here! Something about Autumn is just SO darn adorable!

[Loyal Defender 2002]

Now, we just sit back and wait for art of a floofy Autumn Blaze to be posted onto the internet. ^3^

[StitchandMLPlover 632]

I loved this episode! I thought it was beautifully executed with a beautiful lesson. I think a lot of people who shut out emotions really need this lesson. The song has great lyrics and the new actress who plays Autumn Blaze did a wonderful job. I thought the magic of Autumn Blaze's species is very interesting 

[Jeric 42067]

Autumn Blaze is my favorite character from this season so far! Holy crap please have her come back and interact with Pinkie Pie! The song was nicely done and fits Bloom's musical comedy numbers to a tee. The Hamilton and PotO references made me jump with a resounding yes! Applejack .... okay this is how you write AJ perfectly. Everyone that said she can't be written to be interesting needs to watch this episode. 

Fluttershy similarly hit that perfect balance. I especially loved the moment that she expressed her concern about the animals and the destruction from the Nirik flames. It appeared to be a scenario where both sides had a point. The resolution fits the lesson metaphor so no issues there. 

 

Lalalalalala

Loved this episode!

 

 

Guys Spoiler tags are optional in a Spoiler Thread. Don't be getting on anyone's case for following my previous directions that they are optional. 

[Loyal Defender 2002]

If I ever have to take mythology classes, I know what I'm studying now.

[A.V. 16354]

I suppose Autumn Blaze is people's newest waifu now.

Edited September 1, 2018 by A.V.

[Lord Valtasar 6499]

I Loved it, first of all, Officially having Kirin is a big thing as they were in fanmade content for quite a while, and they were handled in a very interesting way having them turn to NiriK aswel
Autumn Blaze is pure awesomeness and her song was also great, I wish they'll sent some Kirin to the school of friendship, it would spice things up quite nicely, the new location was really nice, fluttershy-Applejack interactions were really well done Fluttershy putting her hoof down to be heard by AppleJack took me by surprise, i thought she'd be dragged along the whole way and then be able to talk, only to go back again. GO Flutters! 

Overal i Really enjoyed this episode, i give it a 9/10

[Loyal Defender 2002]

1 minute ago, A.V. said:

I suppose Autumn Blaze is people's newest waifu now.

Hasbro intended this. They knew so many would find her adorable :3

 

[Ganondox 735]

First, kirin, they were great. Autumn Blaze in particular was phenomenal, and Rachel Broom did an incredible job. While the silent kirin were kinda creepy, their quizzical head tilt was adorable. There was one thing about them that was a pet peeve of mine though. The claimed the water of silence took away their emotions as well, but while their emotions were muted, they clearly still had them. Autumn Blaze explicitly got bored, and we can see how the other kirin made choices on whatever emotions they were feeling that caused them to want to speak again or whatever. IMO true mastery of cognitive empathy comes from not trying to read people's expressions, but from trying to understand people's behavior. The other thing is I think the resolution came across as somewhat rushed and could have used more time, they did a 180 on their policy too quickly and then we hardly saw anything of what they did once they could speak again. I wish they spent less time on the exposition and random jokes and more on communicating with the kirin and hearing them. Just a couple minor nitpicks though, otherwise I loved everything about. 

With Applejack and Fluttershy though I had more problems. Much of their dialogue came across as quite forced and lacked any subtly. I agree with some other users that Applejack could have been replaced with Starlight Glimmer and it would have been more interesting. Applejack insisted that her honesty was essential, but I really don't see how it made any difference. Finally, Fluttershy really needs to learn to tell people what she's doing when she takes detours during hikes.

[gingerninja666 334]

9 minutes ago, Ganondox said:

First, kirin, they were great. Autumn Blaze in particular was phenomenal, and Rachel Broom did an incredible job. While the silent kirin were kinda creepy, their quizzical head tilt was adorable. There was one thing about them that was a pet peeve of mine though. The claimed the water of silence took away their emotions as well, but while their emotions were muted, they clearly still had them. Autumn Blaze explicitly got bored, and we can see how the other kirin made choices on whatever emotions they were feeling that caused them to want to speak again or whatever. IMO true mastery of cognitive empathy comes from not trying to read people's expressions, but from trying to understand people's behavior. The other thing is I think the resolution came across as somewhat rushed and could have used more time, they did a 180 on their policy too quickly and then we hardly saw anything of what they did once they could speak again. I wish they spent less time on the exposition and random jokes and more on communicating with the kirin and hearing them. Just a couple minor nitpicks though, otherwise I loved everything about. 

With Applejack and Fluttershy though I had more problems. Much of their dialogue came across as quite forced and lacked any subtly. I agree with some other users that Applejack could have been replaced with Starlight Glimmer and it would have been more interesting. Applejack insisted that her honesty was essential, but I really don't see how it made any difference. Finally, Fluttershy really needs to learn to tell people what she's doing when she takes detours during hikes.

The song seemed to imply that their emotions were locked away into voices inside their head.

[Ganondox 735]

Just now, gingerninja666 said:

The song seemed to imply that their emotions were locked away into voices inside their head.

My problem in that regard wasn't the song lyrics, it was things some of the other characters said, like so: 

 

Quote

Applejack: [gasps] I can't believe it! Nopony should give up feelin'... their feelin's just to keep from gettin' angry!

And there was a few other lines with similar implications. The issue is not that I didn't understand what was going on, I dislike how it was articulated. 

[Goat-kun 1469]

... Twilight has kirin blood in her confirmed.

 

An AJ episode that does not revolve around family. That almost deserves a positive reaction. Also an episode where H-Bro gets to sneakily test a pre-alpha version of the new unicorn design. K. Mastering rage instead of trying to push it away. Also K. And no, all-encompassing emotional incontinence is not a substantial reason for a character appearance. The logic behind the pony choices was good, the execution, on the other appendage, a little less so, but this time I blame 22 min. Oh, what a twist!

 

Still, the name of this episode displeases me. So without further ado: I heard you like Autumn Blaze. Too bad she's gonna vanish in one season.