What if Autumn Blaze was a villain?

[Props Valroa 25,959]

What if she was a villain? Perhaps it could be like she harbored resentment to the other Kirins for losing their voice, and she felt that she had to force them to get their voices back?

[Misty Shadow 7,059]

As much as I enjoy alternate realities, one where Autumn Blaze is a villain is not one I want to dwell on. Autumn Blaze is far too lovable to be a villain. 

[Props Valroa 25,959]

1 minute ago, CloudMistDragon said:

As much as I enjoy alternate realities, one where Autumn Blaze is a villain is not one I want to dwell on. Autumn Blaze is far too lovable to be a villain. 

Thats what she wants you to think. 

 

[Sparklefan1234 161,593]

3 hours ago, Califorum said:

What if she was a villain? Perhaps it could be like she harbored resentment to the other Kirins for losing their voice, and she felt that she had to force them to get their voices back?

 

In my opinion, Autumn Blaze would be a very upbeat and silly villain. 

[ExplosionMare 18,007]

She would probably sneak Foal’s Breath in everyone’s tea and force them to talk and sing in all her plays  She’d probably have less control over her Nirik form, too.

[Props Valroa 25,959]

11 minutes ago, ExplosionMare said:

She would probably sneak Foal’s Breath in everyone’s tea and force them to talk and sing in all her plays  She’d probably have less control over her Nirik form, too.

That would be hilarious.

[Goat-kun 2,495]

Mandatory friendship issues. We had enough, so I think I'd pass. Give me a kirin villain, but do not give me a FIM villain that is a kirin.

[North Star 4,448]

Then she would be a cute villain :3

[Gaines 1,105]

If she's a villain then the story she told Applejack about the Kirins agreeing to give up their voices would be a lie. She could've been jealous of their beautiful voices and singing so she'd trick them into touching the Stream of Silence somehow. There would then be two reasons why she might've lived separately from the Kirin village: one is that the Kirins might've found out about her doing and, despite being unable to speak, they manage to banish her from the village; the second concept is that she claims that she'll find a cure but instead she just ditches them, leaving them miserable 

[Props Valroa 25,959]

12 hours ago, Gaines said:

If she's a villain then the story she told Applejack about the Kirins agreeing to give up their voices would be a lie. She could've been jealous of their beautiful voices and singing so she'd trick them into touching the Stream of Silence somehow. There would then be two reasons why she might've lived separately from the Kirin village: one is that the Kirins might've found out about her doing and, despite being unable to speak, they manage to banish her from the village; the second concept is that she claims that she'll find a cure but instead she just ditches them, leaving them miserable 

Thats actually a really good idea!