Scariest Moments in MLP FIM!

[Golden Harvest 17]

Ok I want you to show me the most sariest or most confusing moments in the show so far.  Just list the season and episode or the just the name of the episode, what happened, and what your reaction to it was.>>>>>    <<<<<

 

I will start this off with one moment that I almost threw my phone when I was watching the episode... It was the terrible episode .... "Too Many Pinkie Pies" when one of them says the worst line ever... "Bet ya can't make a face crazier than... THIS?!" and shows her head as if it were generation 1.

 

[null123456 759]

When Twilight went all nuts and bolts on us.. I mean, seriously! That episode produced some of the creepiest scenes in MLP FIM!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l7iv09RirHU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYV0tnRe-i4

Seriously, this is freaking creepy stuff.

[SparklingSwirls 21,261]

I don't think the show is all that scary... but I can see some people getting scared of the villains at times, such as when Queen Chrysalis transformed.

 

 

My personal favorite creepy scene? The "eye hallway" from Hurricane Fluttershy.

 

 

. 

[pinkiefan1287 610]

When Pound Cake and Pumpkin Cake are missing from their crib. The next one from Baby Cakes, is when Pound Cake is walking on the ceiling. The creepy background music makes it even more scare. Also Pound Cake laugh before it goes cute and I think they used music from Psycho.

 

[An Old Head 4,815]

One does not use "Too Many Pinkie Pies" and "terrible episode" in the same sentence. Unless you want me turning up at your door with a machete :3

 

There are flat-out no genuinely scary moments in MLP:FiM. One creepy one, however, was the scene in Hurricane Fluttershy where they show Fluttershy surrounded by a thousand pairs of eyeballs. (Which an above user managed to ninja me in getting!)

Edited May 20, 2013 by Flipturn ツ

[drawingpandapony 84]

When Pinkie Pie started talking to non-living things in part of one:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHy3ZhY9VKs It's really creepy when she crosses her eyes like Derpy and turns into Pinkamena.

Edited May 20, 2013 by Drawingpandapony

[Zygen 6,065]

I think theres a good bit funny enough even if this is a children's cartoon .

 

The scene with all the eyes in Fluttershy is up there for me.

 

Queen Chrysalis banishing Twilight to the caves under canterlot is pretty freaky at first.

 

Oh and Pinkamena is kinda funny and freaky, its more freaky when she has her weird eye twitch or stuff like that.

 

And that scene in "Baby cakes" that Pinkie's in the hallway with the creepy music, I think that might've actually scared me if I was a younger child legit.. .

[Scootalove 10,684]

The episode where Fluttershy tries to be assertive, and then after a while she locks herself in her cottage.

 

So here is a very scary moment!

 

[Gone Airbourne 21,969]

When twilight was rejecting spike in the 3rd season first episode. When he walked through that door and had Twilight basically reject him like that was not just scary but man spike must have felt so helpless in that moment in time .... that scene was sad..

[Raiden21 804]

To me, the creepiest episode for me was Lesson Zero. Twilight's face made me just go like what?

Come on, just look at that smile and pupils.

[NeverAgain653289he32 285]

There was not really any scary moments, but there are creepy moments.

 

Such as, Twilight in Lesson Zero, Pinkamena, and the wall of eyes in Hurricane Fluttershy.

[Gone Airbourne 21,969]

I remember the very first time I had seen Lesson Zero.... My face o.O 

 

Took me for surprise since it was a kids show and all but I found it funny and kinda disturbing in a way lol.

[Guest]

Uhh..lol I don't think I've ever been scared by anything in the show. But I have remembered thinking something like 'how are they gonna get out of this one' or something like 'why would you do that'.

[Golden Harvest 17]

OK allow me to rephrase my statement when I said that Too Many Pinkie Pies was scary, I really ment that it was a big shocker and I wasn't expecting it.  The only actual scary part I thought was scary ( or at least for a childs show) has to be the baby cakes!!! I mean walking on the celing, come on when isn't that scary (even though your a pegasis).

[Rainbow Dash Loyalty 1,274]

The episodes Party of One and Lesson Zero seem to be the creepiest moments for me lol, crazy Twilight and Pinkamenia, they're just like psycho serial killers, something you don't see in an everyday cartoon lol.

[Rarity1337 18]

   Sombra when you first see him...... oh man... this actually scared me a little, i was totally not expecting that from a show like this

[hawkflame 3,308]

The creepier moments for me in the series have already been mentioned (Lesson Zero, Party of One, the Hurricane Fluttershy eyeballs) but there's one more that has yet to be mentioned:

 

Pinkie Pie's discording in Return of Harmony Part 1.

 

 

[Dr. Frasier Crane 319]

I wouldn't consider FiM all that creepy, but I guess that scene from a Canterlot wedding where Twilight sees Chrysalis using her magic on Shining Armour for the first time is a little unsettling.

And of course when Pinkie was babysitting Pound Cake and Pumpkin Cake and they disappear, and then the insanity scenes from Party of One, and Lesson Zero.

[I used to be a stranger 7,988]

 

I have two older brothers and one younger sister. I'm old enough now that I get along with them all the time due to the relentless series of breakfasts and birthdays and christmases, waves crashing upon the shore and eroding away frustrations and annoyances we've had against each other. But there were times when I was much younger when I resented them and disliked them, and likewise they against me. Such is growing up.

[IronPonyApplejack 318]

The episode where Fluttershy tries to be assertive, and then after a while she locks herself in her cottage.

 

So here is a very scary moment!

 

 

As far as a moment from the show, this! ^ It kinda freaked me out, but was also AWESOME.

 

But if you want scary...read the MLP:FiM comics, guys. It gets waaaay freakier in those.

[TheStareMaster 45]

In the grand galloping gala when fluttershy goes insane. Its hilarious and terrifying at the same time. "YOU'RE GOING TO LOVE ME"

[~StatesTheOblivious~ 1,794]

Actually, scary and creepy things in shows cause me often to laugh. Hysterically. I don't know why.

When I first saw Gen-1-Pinkie-face-transformation i was like "Dafuq! What... Bwhahahah!"

[Yellow Diamond 7,561]

You know, when I first watched "The Return of Harmony", I considered the discording of the Mane Six to be unnerving, especially as the first part ended with Discord victorious. It was the first time the ponies had ever really been "defeated" in such an overwhelming fashion. Discord was also such a magnificent bastard, manipulating everyone and letting them know how badly they had been fooled. With the resolution well in place, and Discord having been domesticated by the fandom and canonically, I don't have any trouble watching those episodes nowadays; but the first time was, again, unsettling.

 

Night Mare Moon is probably the greatest piece of fridge horror the series had to offer. If the Mane Six had failed to stop her (or if Celestia had failed to initially seal her in the moon), Equestria would have slowly wasted away in eternal night. Grim stuff for a kids show.

[Pinkie4eeeever 38]

When Pinkie Pie questioned Applejack in party of one and she said in a sinister tone "Okie Dokie Lokie" makes me giggle nervously every time. Another scary moment that freaked me out is when Discord grew two faces in keep calm and Flutter on. 

 

But if you want scary...read the MLP:FiM comics, guys. It gets waaaay freakier in those.

 

Oh my god yes! Those had some scary scenes. Like a certain page with Chrysalis and a kitten in issue three. Scary! All I'm going say on that subject. 

[Hdc 155]

Crazy Twilight in Lesson Zero and crazy Pinkie in Party of One are probably the creepiest moments, but in a funny way.

 

The scariest to me would be:

 

"I'm sorry..."

"You will be."

 

followed by Twily getting pushed through the floor while Chrysalis walks into the camera with an evil smile.

 

That was truly unnerving and menacing.