So sad that the competition ended, I feel bad that people aren't aware of it's deadline, however the competition seems a real challenge indeed -- who'll win?
@AnonyPoni, I think the best way is for the thread starter (@Motion Spark) to be going through all pages and collect all posts that contain the entries of every participant (as quoted posts) that entered the contest AND edit the first post of the thread by putting those quotes in that very first post (better spoiler-tag each post to save space and make the page load faster for slower connections), and only after compiling all entries in the first post, shall the contest organiser (yup, none other than @Motion Spark, of course) create a poll.
That's what I did for a contest on another forum, anyway. It's fair for those who participate as contestants and those who participate as voters this way.