Yes this kinda summarizes some of my issues. Although I would honestly give the film a B- ( note: that is like a 7.5 on a scale from 1-10, any film that get's an A of some kind from me, while not perfect, is a "Classic Film"), although I would give the writing a B+.
The trouble with the movie largely stems from the fact that they had a great idea, "Let's make a film where the antagonist is reformed by an act of self sacrifice on the part of the protagonist!" but the execution didn't work out, because Disney 1 ) made the audience forget that Elsa is the stories antagonist (shocking reveal about guy during the last 15 minutes does not make one the stories antagonist proper) and 2 ) Disney execs are at this point making films, they can turn into musicals in five minutes now.... :okiedokielokie:
Case in Point: the VA they chose for Elsa, was textbook miscasting. I am not saying she is a bad actress ( she has a great voice and all that), but that her voice doesn't fit the role of Elsa. Elsa is the type of character who is becoming a good person, not good person becoming villain as is the case in the VAs work in the musical Wicked ( in which case it is great casting). The opening song has a flippin line' ,"Beware the frozen heart", the story is about Elsa's 'frozen heart'... melting ( sorry about the unintentional puns). The VA sounds too... warm ( ach! can't escape ), and then the song "Let it Go" should have been story boarded better and done in a different key as it is not the "I'm finally free!" song it is the "I don't want to deal with people!" song. One of the lines is "the cold never bothered me anyway", cold has not yet been used in a positive sense, that line could be clarified to read "My cold never bothered me anyway".
If you think I'm reading to much into that and then please tell me then how can I interpret Elsa's actions as not being selfish ( she had a tough childhood, I'm sympathetic, but so did a number of other Disney villains apparently; but I have yet to hear someone justify the character Scar's actions and some early interactions in The Lion King with him and his brother, which cause me to suspect his relationship with his brother and parents wasn't very good). Every time someone approaches Elsa, saying "Your kinda causing untold suffering on your people, via ice storm", they get met with her uncontrolled angst and fear. The fact that it is Han's that has to point blank tell Elsa, "Don't become the monster they think you are", should be evidence enough.
So while the writing is there (I did say I gave it a B+) is there, bad production choices in other areas really distract from what could have easily been on par with or potentially surpassed The Lion King. 'Critics' like myself don't enjoy hating on stuff, I would much prefer gushing over a film that nailed it *cough* Princess and the Frog *cough*.
So tl;dr in the case of Frozen:
Olaf is by far 'Best Pony'.