xLuneti

33 minutes ago, ExplosionMare said:

I will never understand how Starlight’s been able to live rent free for so long  Same with Trixie, she just parks her wagon in Twilight’s backyard.

Well, Starlight is Twilight's pupil so she can live in the castle forever, plus, it's literally 20 meters away from the school she runs

Yes? it's showed right here

After Twilight became a ruler, do you guys think the mane 5 stop hanging out together or continue doing meeting in the friendship castle and be friends? the season 7 kinda implies they were friends before twilight, even if that contradicts the episode 1.

Also, what happened to the friendship castle, did starlight continue to live there alone?

I think Twilight (the princess of friendship, of all things) should have stayed in Ponyville, she already had a castle there and was doing friendship labors around all Equestria, that's her thing. If anything, Celestia should have let her sister rule (and that would be good, since part of Luna's arc is feeling less than her sister), do you guys think the same?

What's in your opinion the most underrated episode of the show? I have two that I consider are of the best from the franchise: "The gift of the maud pie" and "flutter butter" are so good

9 minutes ago, CloudMistDragon said:

How is the season that introduced Tirek, the Castle of Friendship, Coco Pommel, Cheese Sandwich, and Maud Pie in addition to providing a vital character development plot line for Twilight Sparkle's role as a princess the most irrelevant season in any way? 

They are good in the future but not that special in the context of season 4

I barely remember some episodes, and the show has a weird feeling overall, it's like a a transition season, from old to new, but there's barely memorable episodes.

Because the episode is

Maybe an episode where we learn about Starlight's mother, and we got to know her abandonment issues come initially from her.

4 hours ago, TomDaBombMLP said:

A different finale where the Mane Six don't have to be forced apart from each other. 

Twilight should have stay in Ponyville rejecting Celestia's idea, if anything, Luna should have been the new ruler of Equestria

For each character, I have an idea of an episode i feel I would have want to happen.

-An episode in season 9 about Twilight and Applejack trying to spend time together before her coronation.

-An episode about Twilight and Starlight having the roles of Celestia and Luna for a reason.

-An episode in season 9 about Rarity dealing with a rival on fashion who is just talented for clothes as she is.

-An episode in season 7 about Starlight and the cmc dealing with cutie marks issues.

-Just an episode in general where they portray the wonderbolts in a better light

To this I wonder why we didn't get any Starlight and Luna episodes, they deserve it together.

1 hour ago, Splashee said:

Question though: Can they levitate themselves? Moving objects are trivial, but if they can make themselves fly, they can visit Cloudsdale any time they want to.

Self-levitation is a characteristic of a very powerful unicorn.

We haven seen this ponies do it:

-Twilight

-Starlight

-Trixie

-Twilight's mom

-Snails, for some reason.

I have noticed that most unicorns in the show are only capable of doing the levitation spell, and they have to perform a great effort to move something big (like Rarity in the finale) so, do you guys think most unicorn are capable of the most basic spells? There's only 4 unicorns in the show that were shown capable of doing more, Twilight, Starlight, Trixie and Sweetie Belle

21 hours ago, Pathfinder of Ash said:

Starlight relied on magical shortcuts to break through her problems, which is something I don't think Fluttershy could handle. Sure, Discord is the LORD OF CHAOS, but he emotionally resonated with her. Starlight was a loner who had no familiarity with any pony; period. She had no concept friendship under any circumstance and was prone to breaking down & panicking. Fluttershy can only deal with so much.

This is the most accurrate take on Starlight I have seen in years.

I think she could, even easier than Twilight

2 hours ago, Starforce said:

Thing that bothers me about Fluttershy is - You don't have to be shy to be kind. If anything, Kindness is a rather powerful and empathic thing. So why did they make her shy?

Well that's her personality, we can say at least she doesn't let her shyness to be over her kindess, there's a lot of bravery for a pony to befriend Discord, and she did trust Cavaleron in season 9.

On 2022-02-09 at 12:14 PM, Kaitlynne said:

Her element is kindness when Rairty’s element is generosity. Isn’t being generous also being kind? Especially after the fact that she cut off her tail to help someone in need. Wouldn’t sympathy or comfort be more fitted to Fluttershy?

The elements of harmoany doesn't make any sense in the show

the moments of weakest from Rarity are because she is too generous

the bravest and best moments of fluttershy are when she is not-so-kind and she steps up

rainbow dash is not loyal at all, if anything, she is the less loyal mane 6

we never got a proper "why is important tell the truth" episode from applejack, and she lies sometimes

the only ones who make justice to their element are twilight and pinkie

12 hours ago, Kujamih said:

that episode was a MASTERPIECE!?

Explain to me how twilight being crazy and brainwashing ponies is a masterpiece? The princess of friendship manipulating the whole ponyville is not so much different from Starlight really, and it's awful because at least Starlight did it a for a good reason (in her mind) Twilight did it for selfish desires

Lesson Zero. The episode is not that bad but it creates the whole "Twilight goes crazy under pressure" that is horrible for the rest of the series.

Cmc 8-12
Twilight 15-19
Applejack 17-21
Rarity 17-22
Rainbow dash 13-18
Fluttershy 18-22
Pinkie 14-18

52 minutes ago, CloudMistDragon said:

Honestly, four princesses was enough in my eyes. One pair for the sun and moon and one pair for love and friendship, since what Cadance and Twilight ruled actually did go hand and hand like what Celestia and Luna ruled. Starlight Glimmer becoming a princess would've also conflicted with her character, since part of her character conflict was that she didn't even want to lead a village and had trouble being a counselor for a school. 

>since part of her character conflict was that she didn't even want to lead a village and had trouble being a counselor for a school. 

She got over it, she was actually excited to be headmare of the school

And rule along side Twilight in Ponyville?

If anything, I would make Twilight stay in Ponyville in the final. There's a part of me that thinks Celestia forcing Twilight to be the new ruler was a final lesson, Twilight was supposed to say she wants to stay with her friends in Ponyville, she ALREADY HAS A CASTLE THERE, why Luna couldn't rule if Celestia wanted to left the throne also?

2 hours ago, Kadeda said:

They are probably all above 18 at least in season 1 since they all have jobs. None of them are in some form of school except possibly Twilight who I would guess was in some form of college in season 1. We also have teenage models in later season which compare to fluttershy look in season 1 flashback.

Fluttershy also mentions she's 1 year older than Pinky.

In general... I would probably add about 5 years to everyone ages... while I think the flashback of them getting their cutie marks happened 10 years ago. That would make fluttershy around 12 and everyone else 12-8 which adds up.

I don't think Equestria has the same social economic rules as we do, the CMC have jobs as well, and they are children. For the same reason they are allowed to run a camp of their own. I took Faust' word of the mane six having the mental age of  10-15 year old girls