Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky

BlueEyedPegasus

User
  • Posts

    198
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by BlueEyedPegasus

  1. You and me both! P.S. I HATE not being allowed to post less than 20 characters!
  2. Well, that's Rainbow Dash for ya. No offense, of course.
  3. You're welcome. In a sense, Rainbow Dash was being completely indecisive until at least one of her friends got her to think straight.
  4. I can just sense that that does not make it a broken aesop. It was merely a case of Rainbow Dash being Rainbow Dash and does not, in any way, break the episode's moral which still manages to leave an impression on Rainbow Dash in the end. Hope that helps.
  5. I understand that I myself was recently banned from TV Tropes due to the edit war concerning the MLP: FIM entries on the Broken Aesop page. Currently, they are: ** In the episode "Swarm of the Century," the lesson is that you should always listen to your friends, even if what they say doesn't make sense. Pinkie has the solution to the problem, but she just demands that everyone help her without telling them how or why, and when another method almost works, she screws it up by not listening to ''them''. [[AccidentalAesop It's a better illustration of how important it is to explain yourself properly if you want to get your ideas across to others.]] ** In the generally infamous "The Mysterious Mare Do Well", the moral imparted by the Mane 6 on Rainbow Dash at the end of the episode is that humility and humbleness is necessary in the wake of great success. Not only did the other five ponies brag about their own contributions to Mare-Do-Well's achievements in front of Rainbow Dash, it still took all of them working in a team to just barely outdo her, which is pretty damn impressive. ** "A Friend In Deed" aims to teach that you can't force someone to be your friend, and that if someone doesn't want you hanging around them all the time, you should give them their space. The problem is that Pinkie doesn't leave him alone until she figures out what she needs to do to endear herself to him. ** "Rainbow Falls" presents Rainbow Dash with the choice of competing with the Ponyville team, who are terrible but counting on her, or the Cloudsdale team, who are great flyers but have been retconned into jerks. The intended Aesop is that one should be loyal to one's friends in the face of temptation, but the episode never addresses the fact that Rainbow Dash never feels comfortable talking to said friends about her problem. In fact, Twilight Sparkle, the only pony who notices that RD has been practicing with the other team, confronts Rainbow with hostility and guilt rather than support. Ultimately, the show's Aesop is closer to "Silently sacrificing is better than communication, since your friends will abandon you at the slightest hint of betrayal." Except for the Mare Do Well one, I just don't think these entries are eligible for Broken Aesops. Anybody agree? Why or why not?
  6. Speaking of Apple Bloom... 1. How excited did you feel for her and her friends when you heard that they won the chance to represent Ponyville for the Equestria Games? 2. Being that Apple Bloom and her friends managed to beat Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon who both mocked Scootaloo for her inability to fly, do you think they both deserve a talking to, especially since they're the ones who have constantly taunted Apple Bloom and her friends for being blank flanks, made fun of your grandmother, and forced Apple Bloom and her friends to write all those hurtful gossip stories about you and Big Macintosh and the rest of Ponyville?
  7. To say Twilight could have handled the situation better is not very accurate either, most likely because it never even occurred to her then. But I guess that's just me. In the long run, of course, the way Twilight DID handle it would have worked only a LITTLE better if Chrysalis hadn't pulled that Wounded Gazelle Gambit to alienate Twilight from her peers.
  8. Anger or disappointment, it was still a far more justified scenario in "Lesson Zero". Plus, since it's evident that she forgot said lesson in "A Canterlot Wedding", I'd say she learned it all over again after witnessing what occurred after Chrysalis revealed her deception, even prior to Celestia's 'karmic' defeat at the hooves of Chrysalis. And would you simply ask Twilight to apologize instead outright banning her? Probably so. At least, due to how hard the ban was pulled here. Also, I'm honestly surprised you actually think Celestia's defeat at Chrysalis' hooves should be considered karma. Of course, there's another side which says it was bad luck that Celestia lost to Chrysalis due to the latter feeding off so much love, but that's another story.
  9. I couldn't agree more. Of course, it probably isn't my place to say, but it's not the first time Celestia ever got angry at Twilight. The first time we ever saw that happen was in "Lesson Zero", which may I remind you is when Celestia had a more JUSTIFIED reason to be angry at her star student. Not only that, but as I've pointed out many times before, the lesson that Twilight's peers learned from that episode really does seem forgotten by them in "A Canterlot Wedding". It's even lampshaded in part 2 by the part with Chrysalis gloating to Twilight's friends about how they let their wedding planning go to their heads to such an extent that they forgot to give Twilight's doubts even a smidget of consideration, along with Applejack apologizing on everypony's behalf right after that. It really bugs me how some viewers don't seem to wanna face that straight on, instead thinking that such a part should have been explored more deeply on the characters' part. Also, as much as I hate to admit it, one side of me can't help but feel that Celestia being defeated by Chrysalis was KARMA for Celestia for not believing Twilight earlier on. You can probably imagine some viewers going "Who has a lot to think about now?!"
  10. I really don't wanna bring this up again, but when you REALLY think about it hard enough, there was absolutely NO WAY Twilight could have gathered any evidence in this case. With that in mind, the very least her own peers could do is give her accusations some consideration. Besides, Twilight did NOT bully a princess at all. She was doing what was most likely the only choice she had. Again, I bring this up because I just can't get upset about Twilight's actions in that scene, most likely because, like Rainbow Dash saving other ponies in danger, it seems like a perfectly natural thing to do. Furthermore, if you were gonna get upset like her peers in that scene, I would suggest you NEVER EVER ban Twilight from the wedding. In my mind, anybody who defends the actions of Twilight's peers in that scene is a genuinely heartless fool, and I know you're not that kinda person. Plus, if there's anything more I should point out, it's that Twilight only appeared to screw up because of the fake Cadance. You see what I'm saying? It's NOT Twilight's fault at all, despite her hostility earlier on. Twilight did NOT do anything to get alienated. It was Chrysalis' actions and Chrysalis' actions alone. Am I making myself clear?
  11. This episode's moral and its heartfelt delivery aside, I gotta say that, in my opinion, the Mane-iac is FAR more evil than Chrysalis, Discord, King Sombra, and even Nightmare Moon combined, with her Hairspray Ray Of Doom which freezes ponies in place and renders superpowers useless! THAT MONSTER!!!!! If anything at all, I think this should be the Mane-iac's theme music: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-51ZvV6ISD4
  12. Please don't take this hard, but it appears that your opinions aren't making a valid argument for me. I did not find those words weak or not meaningful at all, and I can still accept Applejack's apology on behalf of herself and everypony, because I feel they all apologized to her symbolically that way.
  13. I'm sorry, but I may have to disagree with you in some points. First off, you say that nopony apologized to Twilight prior to the Changelings' defeat. Clearly, that's not true. Applejack apologized on BEHALF of herself and everypony else for not taking Twilight's concerns seriously, even if it never occurred to any of them, including Twilight herself, that Chrysalis had been masquerading as Cadance for some time. Now I know you're gonna argue that it doesn't count, but it actually does, hence the words ON BEHALF. Secondly, regarding your claim about what Celestia said after the Changelings' defeat, well, news flash, buddy: the lesson she delivered at the end about learning to trust your instincts has often been said as Celestia's way of apologizing, and I have no reason to disbelieve those who have claimed that. So I'm sorry, but you're outta luck on those points. No offense.
  14. I say, good show! On the other hand, I'm sorry if we've both caused you trouble, but you know how I am when it comes to defending Twilight's actions. Again, on Noodles' behalf and mine, I'm sorry.
  15. Alright, you know what? I'm clearly getting nowhere with you. I don't want you to respond to my posts ever again.
  16. But don't forget that Twilight was RIGHT. The most intelligent thing to do in my mind would be to at least give her accusations some consideration. Besides, even if Twilight's parents would be upset with her as well, I feel they'd be even more upset at Shining Armor. And to answer your question about seeing things from the perspective of Twilight's peers, well, I'm sorry, but I just can't, mainly because what they did makes it 100% clear beyond a shadow of a doubt that they forgot the lesson they learned about taking your friends' concerns seriously. There's absolutely NO difference here. Our conversation is over.
  17. Blind faith does NOT apply to this scenario. Besides, has it ever occurred to you that Twilight and Shining Armor's parents would be rightfully upset with Shining Armor for kicking his own sister out of his wedding?
  18. From what I understand, this episode was meant to be a highlight towards folks with disabilities, and I can honestly see that what they ended up for the final cut of this episode is something that shows how us folks with disabilities (I have Asperger's syndrome) can put we are really able to do to good use, which is real important, and I applaud them for that. With all that aside, though, judging how Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon started the whole mess, all I can say is they're both officially worse than Lucy Van Pelt of the Peanuts!
  19. I'm sorry, but the reaction of Twilight's peers was indeed out of place, mainly because it contradicts what they learned in "Lesson Zero" about taking your friends' concerns seriously.
  20. Hey, I've got a question: how DO you rip the music from the episodes?
  21. That's a very good insight, and I may have to agree.
  22. Of course not. I just feel that there was absolutely no way Twilight could have collected any evidence in this case. The reason I bring this up is because if you really expect me to get upset about what Twilight did at the end of part 1, well, I'm sorry, but I just can't. If you were in Twilight's position and saw the bride-to-be to be truly evil, you'd naturally get all worked up about it, and most likely have no alternative but to out her as being so, even if you didn't have any proof to back you up, and in the case of Twilight's peers, they still should have at least given her accusations some consideration. Am I making myself clear?
  23. I don't know about you, Firebolt Blitz, but I feel that Twilight's were called for and NOT OTT at all. If I may remind you, she had no other alternative but to deliver it the way she did, and in my mind, she made no mistakes at all. Therefore, I do not think that Twilight has any mistakes to confess your story. I hope you understand.
  24. The one who caused the incident needs more consolation at this point. Besides, I maintain that you are practically 95% wrong. I don't wanna talk to you anymore. Good day!
×
×
  • Create New...