jolliapplegirl

So... You agree with me? My avatar is Simon Petrikov. I'm happy someone noticed that. As for what you said, I can agree with that. It is possible that the human mane 6 are just younger versions of the pony versions. I can accept that. But I still don't feel that would mean they would embody the same virtues. As you said, they are in that stage of life where they are still deciding where they want to be in life. They don't have cutiemarks to help guide them, as such, they will endeavor to do a bunch of different things.For example, human Rainbow Dash is very athletic, so she is involved with as many sports as she is able, but she won't end up like Pony Rainbow, who wishes to be apart of what i can only assume is the military. Really, its because they are younger that i believe they would embody different virtues. They hold similar personalities, but they aren't exactly the same,

To be honest, I'd never actually heard of MLP before FIM. I knew of it but i had never actually seen it before, As such, i only saw it as another fad for girls. In fact, the only reason i started to watch the show was because of Discord and his awesome design!.

Well, they are from an alternate universe where they most likely lived entirely different lives than their pony counterparts, That an it was stated in the first movie that the human doesn't have magic, which is the main drive for both movies, so i doubt magic would be one of them. Why would you even need an element of magic in a world without magic? There is a human Twilight. Pinkie said in the first movie that she just lived far away and didn't go to school, i think. So its not like she never existed. She is just not around. As for the tail and ears, Twilight had brought magic to that world but notice they can't do any rainbow beams without her (Twilight).

So, for those of you who have watched Rainbow Rocks, we have seen that Sunset seems to have filled in for Twilight as the 6th element of harmony in the human world, but that begs the question, what are those elements. We all know the pony Elements: Generosity, Laughter, Honesty, Loyalty, Kindness and Magic. But that is in the pony universe, where magic is everywhere. In the human world, there is no magic. Not only that, but the human versions of the mane 6 are not the same as the pony versions. Human Fluttershy is a bit more blunt that pony Fluttershy (Rainbow Rocks). Human Rainbow is a lot more arrogant. Human Applejack is easier to provoke. As such, I believe that the human Mane 6's elements would be different since their lives as humans make them very different from their pony versions. What do you think their elements would be?

I don't think she is. I mean, the elements seem to work differently in the human world and the human mane 6 aren't really that in tune to the elements of the pony world. It'd be a lot more interesting if the human world Elements were entirely different. Why? Because while we can relate to the ordeals of the Ponies in MLP, the human world is definitely different. The human Elements of harmony should be something entirely different. As such, i don't think Sunset would be the new element of Magic. Especially since Magic doesn't exist in the human world usually.

I would definitely call Sunset the Main protagonist. Despite Twilight being a main character, she is by no means the protagonist. For one thing, the story mainly focuses on Sunset and her journey in the aftermath of the first movie.

i think she is, in a way. The same way she acted as a guide for the folks in Ponyville around season 2 or 3 (I can't recall), Twilight is guiding Sunset on the path to a more healthy lifestyle. Sunset has no experience with Friendship, she she definitely needs someone like Twilight to help her. Twilight being younger says nothing on whether or not she can be a teacher. Half my classmate in College are twice my age while my professor are only a few years older than me. so age is not a factor.

She is adorable. I never noticed it since in the first movie, she was boring as hell and annoying. It's hard to notice ones looks when they're personality is practically nonexistent.

My Lolita Star! (real name: Pixal Pizzaz) http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20140918175153/mlp/images/thumb/8/8c/Pixel_Pizzaz_ID_EG2.png/150px-Pixel_Pizzaz_ID_EG2.webp Oh, you like Lolita Star (My name for her) too?! Yay

Flash is boring. He has no personalty, no motives and hasn't done anything for the plot in either movies or the main series. So at this moment, no, he and Twilight wouldn't be good match. If they gave him something to do and a personality, then yes, they might be interesting. In fact, I kind of want him to have a personality that is the exact opposite of Twilight's. Why? Because if he does, he'll create an interesting dilemma within Twilight. A guy she likes is her exact opposite, but she does actually enjoy herself when around him. She might learn to loosen up if she has a free spirited kind of flash to mellow her out.