"In mid-2016, I introduced a new scoring system based on four criteria: entertainment/humour, characterization, themes/morals, and story. Each of these is graded out of ten, and are then added together to find a mean grade out of 100. Here, I will list every MLP episode I have graded on this scale, alongside their rating out of 100. For accuracy's sake, I will not attempt to grade episodes entirely on distant memory. Ratings might be subject to change with future rewatches, and this list will expand as I rewatch more episodes (especially since this provides incentive to go through the whole series again). For now, I've rated the following media as follows, out of 100:

Season 1 (70/100) [72% enjoyed]

"Friendship is Magic" -  85

"The Ticket Master" - 70

"Applebuck Season" - 75

"Griffon the Brush Off" - 78

"Boast Busters" - 55

"Dragonshy" -- 78

"Look Before You Sleep" - 38

"Bridle Gossip" - 40

"Swarm of the Century" - 68

"Winter Wrap-Up" - 80

"Call of the Cutie" - 73

"Fall Weather Friends" - 90

"Suited for Success" - 90

"Feeling Pinkie Keen" - 73

"Sonic Rainboom" - 78

"Stare Master" - 53

"The Show Stoppers" - 33

"A Dog and Pony Show" - 73

"Green Isn't Your Color" - 55

"Over a Barrel" - 33

"A Bird in the Hoof" - 88

"The Cutie Mark Chronicles" - 93

"Owl's Well That Ends Well" - 48

"Party of One" - 100

"The Best Night Ever" - 100

Season 2 (74/100) [79% enjoyed]

"The Return of Harmony" - 80

"Lesson Zero" - 100

"Luna Eclipsed" - 63

"Sisterhooves Social" - 90

"The Cutie Pox" - 43

"May the Best Pet Win!" - 93

"The Mysterious Mare-Do-Well" - 23

"Sweet and Elite" - 85

"Secret of My Excess" - 78

"Hearth's Warming Eve" - 73

"Family Appreciation Day" - 70

"Baby Cakes" - 85

"The Last Roundup" - 100

"The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000" - 50

"Read It and Weep" - 95

"Hearts and Hooves Day" - 80

"A Friend in Deed" - 80

"Putting Your Hoof Down" - 65

"It's About Time" - 43

"Dragon Quest" - 88

"Hurricane Fluttershy" - 100

"Ponyville Confidential" - 50

"MMMystery on the Friendship Express" - 70

"A Canterlot Wedding" - 68

Season 3 (57/100) [50% enjoyed]

"The Crystal Empire" - 80

"Too Many Pinkie Pies" - 63

"One Bad Apple" - 60

"Magic Duel" - 60

"Sleepless in Ponyville" - 90

"Wonderbolts Academy" - 100

"Just For Sidekicks" - 60 (I actually like this one though)

"Apple Family Reunion" - 48

"Spike At Your Service" - 43

"Keep Calm and Flutter On" - 88

"Games Ponies Play" - 25

"Magical Mystery Cure" - 18

Season 4 (71/100) [67% enjoyed]

"Princess Twilight Sparkle" - 35

"Castle Mane-ia" - 75

"Daring Don't" - 65

"Flight to the Finish" - 80

"Power Ponies" - 48

"Bats" - 43

"Rarity Takes Manehattan" - 98

"Pinkie Apple Pie" - 70

"Rainbow Falls" - 45

"Three's a Crowd" - 75

"Pinkie Pride" - 100

"Simple Ways" - 45

"Filli Vanilli" - 78

"Twilight Time" - 50

"It Ain't Easy Being Breezies" - 88

"Somepony to Watch Over Me" - 50

"Maud Pie" - 60

"For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils" - 100

"Leap of Faith" - 95

"Testing, Testing, 1, 2, 3" - 65

"Trade Ya" - 73

"Inspiration Manifestation" - 80

"Equestria Games" - 83

"Twilight's Kingdom" - 95

Season 5 (60/100) [46% enjoyed]

"The Cutie Map" - 78

"Castle Sweet Castle" - 55

"Tanks for the Memories" - 28

"Bloom and Gloom" - 100

"Appleoosa's Most Wanted" - 73

"Make New Friends but Keep Discord" - 85

"The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone: - 50

"Slice of Life" - 83

"Princess Spike" - 43

"Party Pooped" - 93

"Amending Fences" - 38

"Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?" - 20

"Canterlot Boutique" - 53

"Rarity Investigates" - 100

"Made in Manehattan" - 43

"Brotherhooves Social" - 65

"Crusaders of the Lost Mark" - 85

"The One Where Pinkie Pie Knows" - 38

"Hearthbreakers" - 63

"Scare Master" - 53

"What About Discord?" - 18

"The Hooffields & the McColts" - 73

"The Mane Attraction" - 50

"The Cutie Re-Mark" - 53

Season 6 (72/100) [71% enjoyed]

"The Crystalling" - 93

"The Gift of Maud Pie" - 90

"On Your Marks" - 75

"No Second Prances" - 38

"Gauntlet of Fire" - 68

"Newbie Dash" - 63

"A Hearth's Warming Tail" - 100

"The Saddle Row Review" - 90

"Applejack's Day Off" - 48

"Flutter Brutter" - 68

"Spice Up Your Life" - 65

"Stranger Than Fan Fiction" - 88

"The Cart Before the Ponies" - 53

"28 Pranks Later" - 63

"The Times They Are a Changeling" - 88

"Dungeons & Discords" - 88

"Buckball Season" - 55

"The Fault in Our Cutie Marks" - 98

"Viva Las Pegasus" - 65

"Every Little Thing She Does" - 58

"Pony Point of View" - 43

"Where the Apple Lies" - 53

"Top Bolt" - 95

"To Where and Back Again" - 85

Season 7 (59/100) [40% enjoyed]

"Celestial Advice" - 50

"All Bottled Up" - 38

"A Flurry of Emotions" - 93

"Rock Solid Friendship" - 60

"Fluttershy Leans In" - 35

"Forever Filly" - 48

"Parental Glideance" - 80

"Hard to Say Anything" - 25

"Honest Apple" - 40

"A Royal Problem" - 80

"Not Asking for Trouble" - 63

"Discordant Harmony" - 80

"The Perfect Pear" - 85

"Fame and Misfortune" - 45

"Triple Threat" - 70

"Campfire Tales" - 53

"To Change a Changeling" - 53

"Daring Done?" - 35

"It Isn't the Mane Thing About You" - 65

"A Health of Information" - 78

"Marks and Recreation"  - 43

"Once Upon a Zeppelin" - 83

"Secrets and Pies" - 63

"Uncommon Bond" - 50

"Shadow Play" - 48

The Movie - 35

Season 8 (64/100) [67% enjoyed]

"School Daze" - 75

"The Maud Couple" - 68

"Fake It Til You Make It" - 35

"Grannies Gone Wild" - 68

"Surf and/or Turf" - 55

"Horse Play" - 100

"The Parent Map" - 35

"Non-Compete Clause" - 25

"The Break Up Break Down" - 78

"Molt Down" - 80

"Marks for Effort" - 83

"The Mean 6" - 85

"A Matter of Principals" - 43

"The Hearth's Warming Club" - 83

"Friendship University" - 73

"The End in Friend" - 43

"Yakity Sax" - 53

"On the Road to Friendship" - 78

"The Washouts" - 65

"A Rockhoof and a Hard Place" - 65

"What Lies Beneath" - 70

"Sounds of Silence" - 43

"Father Knows Beast" - 70

"School Raze" - 65

"Best Gift Ever" - 95

Season 9 (66/100) [63% enjoyed]

"The Beginning of the End" - 63

"Uprooted" - 73

"Sparkle's Seven" - 83

"The Point of No Return" - 95

"Common Ground" - 85

"She's All Yak" - 53

"Frenemies" - 85

"Sweet and Smoky" - 50

"Going to Seed" - 90

"Student Counsel" - 58

"The Last Crusade" - 65

"Between Dark and Dawn" - 75

“The Last Laugh” - 50

”3, 2, 1, Greaaat!” - 35

"A Trivial Pursuit" - 35

"The Summer Sun Setback" - 50

"She Talks to Angel" - 68

"Dragon Dropped" - 28

“A Horse Shoe-In” - 73

"Daring Doubt" - 65

"Growing Up is Hard to Do" - 83

"The Big Mac Question" - 58

"The End of the End" - 73

"The Last Problem" - 80

"Rainbow Roadtrip" - 70

Equestria Girls

Equestria Girls - 60

Rainbow Rocks - 88

Friendship Games - 70

Legend of Everfree - 40

"Dance Magic" - 45

"Movie Magic" - 70

"Mirror Magic" - 25

"Forgotten Friendship" - 60

"Rollercoaster of Friendship" - 75

"Spring Breakdown" - 33

"Sunset's Backstage Pass" - 43