Squeakychu

Again, it was a very tough decision, both are very attractive ponies in their own right, with Rarity only slightly edging it out for me. Don't worry though! If I did make Fluttershy cry, and she does in fact lose, Rarity will be right there to cheer her up!

Applejack vs Lyra - I voted Applejack because while the mint color scheme Lyra has is cool, I find Applejack's orange color scheme goes much better, especially with her hat. Also, she has a much more attractive personality. Twilight vs Vinyl - I voted Twilight! No contest! Her color scheme, mane, and personality are much more attractive. Spitfire vs Octavia - While Spitfire has an an actual personality developed, and looks rather beautiful without the mask, I voted Octavia since I'm a sucker for more elegant, feminine personalities, and the color scheme goes along so nicely! Fluttershy vs Rarity - This one hurt me the most! Fluttershy is my favorite pony and the one I relate most to. She has a very attractive mane, body,and color scheme on her own, not to mention a beautiful voice. Of course, she's also the textbook definition of adorable! However, I find Rarity's charming, cute, hilarious, and almost seductive personality, along her eye's (the shape, the eyelashes, and eye shadow in particular), that mane (it's pattern is a marvel to look at), her almost mystical white/purple color scheme, and her Mid-Atlantic English accented voice, absolutely irresistible! Of the two, I find Rarity the more attractive pony, which is why I voted for her. I love both of them though, so best of luck to whoever moves on!