DITR

Here it is, the big one: I like Friday by Rebecca Black. But before you flame me and call me the anti-christ for having a different opinion, read this quote from a College Humour article( Yes, the same people that made My Little Brony)

 "Friday" by Rebecca Black is a terrible chart-topping pop single. On the other hand, it's the best Bat Mitzvah video in the world. I'm sure Rebecca Black's friends and family think it's amazing. You think it sucks? No shit. A 13-year-old girl made it. You think it sucks because you're viewing it out of context. You're comparing it to every great song that exists. That's not fair to Rebecca Black, who I'm sure would agree that "Friday" is not the best song of all time.

I can understand people being offended by it. But other works of fiction make light of heavy subjects and aren't chastised for it.

-Family Guy (pedophilia)

-Ask Pinkomena (murder)

-South Park (everything)

No, not in any way shape or form. Change comes from within, not from a show. Nothing about my personality has changed since I started watching MLP 

Dolls that aren't sexist, what is the world coming to!? But seriously, you were amazing. You can barely tell they're the same character.

No, the last time I played with a toy was when I reenacted a scene from Family Guy with a kid on the bus. I don't have enough ponies to reenact an episode and I can't do the voices to save my life.

Well, just 'cause someone thinks differently than you, It doesn't mean you should be afraid of 'em. It means, you should be angry at them! How dare they think differently! What, my way of life ain't good enough for 'em!?

I think he's a bland, underdeveloped character and I see no redeeming qualities in him. I wouldn't mind if he appeared in the background but he does not deserve a major role in a future episode

I'll let Spoony sum up my feelings on the matter. ''"How joyless and paranoid is your life if you're afraid of children and adults armed with funny-shaped dice who still play with dolls?" 

My autism. To the point that I was harassed so much at a camp I really enjoyed that I never went there again. I still fantasize about comebacks I could've made to the people there

I'll let Fuuka from Persona 3 provide my reaction to the event : "No! It can't end like this!" It really depends on how well the scene is done : If it's a tragic yet beautiful ending like David Tenant's regeneration scene, I'd be sad but I would still watch the show. If it's lazily done and comes out of nowhere there would be a pretty good chance that I would give up on the show.

No, she is the benevolent and wise ruler of Equestria. She is not a troll, a tyrant, or a molester. Sometimes I feel like I'm the only one that likes Celestia more than Luna. Hopefully the new comic coming out will develop her character, because the writers did an amazing job with developing the character of Luna.

Make a Sweetie Belle in the flower girl outfit and I will love you. Yes, the figurine is too saucy. Although you have shown some talent.

I'll let Peter Griffin sum up what I think about the anti-brony page. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gutCFMc5khY

Don't worry about it, it will blow over soon enough. Ask him if he's seen it and see what he says.

Without a shred of a doubt I can confirm that Sunset Shimmer is one of the worst villains in the history of fiction. She was bland, underdeveloped, and cliched. Her reason for being that way just made me want to hurt her even more.

Wow, that's really good. I was never really in to Yume Nikki as a game but I did enjoy the idea of it. Your drawing is amazing and I look forward to what else you have.

I thought it would be okay, maybe good at best. However, the movie forgot every single thing that was good about Friendship is Magic and instead gave us a lazy, soulless, plot hole filled mess.

I think people should care about what's best for themselves, not what's best for others. It pisses me off when people complain about teenagers, being that I am one myself. One time I asked my dad "Why do people hate teenagers so much?" "Well, people don't hate teenagers, but teenagers are some of the dumbest people on the planet." Newsflash, there are plenty of stupid adults out there ; corrupt politicians, everyone on the Jersey Shore, child beauty pageant moms, religious zealots, the list goes on. This video provides more examples http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G2wh1-jdBrY 

For the love of all that is sacred she better not return. She was an extremely bland, underdeveloped character with no personality whatsoever. 

Despite the lips they're pretty good. Hasbro, these are the designs you should be using for the dolls, not those skanks targeted towards children!

Never want to leave  I guess I would just talk about life with Rarity and how we're like one another. It would be fun to be taught how to design but I'm assuming that the room doesn't have anything in it minus me and my favorite pony.

I will treat someone with a minimal amount of respect until they prove to me that they deserve to be respected, whether that was by making a good first impression or helping me out in a tough spot, things of that nature. I won't treat someone with respect if they are a. ignorant, b. don't apply themselves or refuse to try, c. they don't have manners. 

I wouldn't say anything that wasn't love and adoration to a pony, I love them too much to hurt their feelings like that. I got quite a lot of things to say to the Hasbro executive that dreamed up Equestria Girls though.

Thanks for the comment. I appreciate it when the reader takes the time to comment on the fanfics I write and post on various websites. Since you came up with some decent points I've decided to comment on them and explain my reasoning for doing so to the best of my ability.

 

1. I'm aware that it would never happen. This fanfic was supposed to be a fun what-if. Sure it won't happen, but I do like to ponder on alternatives to the canon.

2. That part was a joke against Celestia's expense.

3. Of course Sunset Shimmer deserved it. How dare she use the power of the elements to destroy Twilight?

4. As I've said, it's a fun what-if.

5. Not in this universe

You're still missing the point. Any person in Ted's shoes would've taken their own lives to escape from AM's torture, but instead,he seizes the one opportunity  he has to escape from his hellish life to free the people he was with, showing that even after 109 years of torture he still has genuine human emotions. What you did here was take a tragic ending out of a horrifying story and applied it to a bland, under developed, movie in an attempt to make it more profound, doing the exact opposite in the process. Lastly, a dark fic only works if it is believable. As said on TvTropes "When badly done (especially when the original work was a comedy), it will do nothing but squickreaders, who will quickly abandon it. Or make people laugh. Well done, though, it can provide an intense and unsettling view of something supposedly familiar." Your story was the former of the two.

When I was a little boy I was obsessed with a show for little girls. It was called " Magical Do Re Mi" Come to think of it, at a memorial day party a kid was bored and noticed I was watching My Little Pony so he joined in. The kid was 9 by the way.

Not in a million years. If it's just a little background event that's okay but if it's something that lasts an entire scene than no. That's not clever, that's just lazy writing.