melody5697

We have no proof that she doesn't have wings!

You're saying she doesn't have a mane like Celestia's even though it specifically says she DOES? It's true that alicorns aren't the only ones who can be tall, but we have only seen TWO ponies with a mane like that, and they're both alicorns. Oh, and Twilight's mane was sort of like that briefly when Luna, Celestia, and Cadance transferred their magic to her. More evidence that it's connected to alicorns.

It doesn't SAY she doesn't have wings, so there's no proof that she doesn't.

You clearly don't understand what I'm trying to say. Now I'm just arguing that it's POSSIBLE that Duchess Diamond Waves is an alicorn. There's no real evidence that she doesn't have wings. As for Applejack being part timberwolf, that's different. We've seen her. Does she LOOK part timberwolf? There's actual evidence against that. But there is no evidence against Duchess Diamond Waves being an alicorn. Therefore it is POSSIBLE. Maybe not PROBABLE, but POSSIBLE. But there are things that make it sound like she might be an alicorn!

I know that the book didn't SAY that she has wings. But just because they weren't mentioned doesn't mean they aren't there.

You're still committing an appeal to ignorance.

No, it didn't just say "unicorn magic". It said, "One fateful day, the younger unicorn refused to lower the moon to make way for the dawn." Don't believe me? Go watch it!

I just found where Luna was called a unicorn. It's in the beginning of the first episode. So there. Oops, I posted at the same time yayayayayala posted.

I wasn't saying it's LIKELY that Duchess Diamond Waves has wings. I'm saying that we can't say for sure that she doesn't when we don't have any proof of that either. Why don't they teach logic in these schools? I'll try to find where I heard it.

I can't remember, but I'm pretty sure I heard them called unicorns at least once.

You can't know for sure that she doesn't have wings just because they aren't mentioned. That's a logical fallacy. It's called appeal to ignorance. It's when you say that because something can't be disproved it must be true or likely.

As I said, Luna and Celestia have also been referred to as unicorns a few times. There are only four alicorns in EQUESTRIA. Monacolt is a different country. I don't think her having wings would be important to the story.

I just finished reading Princess Celestia and The Summer of Royal Waves and Duchess Diamond Waves has some traits that, as far as we know, only alicorns have. It sounds like she's unusually tall. She has a magical mane like Princess Celestia and Princess Luna. She's the only one who can make waves in the ocean (at least in Monacolt), just like how Princess Celestia and Princess Luna (and maybe Twilight and Princess Cadance) are the only ones who can raise the sun and the moon. She was referred to as a unicorn, but Princess Celestia and Princess Luna have also been called unicorns a few times, so that doesn't mean anything. Is she an alicorn?

THAT WAS SO BEAUTIFUL!!! *cries* And Neopets is AMAZING! There are lots of people who still play it! Isn't Fallout: Equestria a crossover? I don't play Fallout. I know nothing about it except the genre and the ESRB rating. I don't play video games very often, and when I do I usually just play Super Paper Mario over and over and over. Sorry, I really just want a story, not people's comments.

I need to listen to MLP fanfics all month because there's an event on Neopets this month that requires me to play the same game over and over and it gets boring if I don't listen to a story at the same time. So what are some good ones I can listen to on YouTube? I just finished listening to Past Sins. Sorry if this isn't the best section for this post. I didn't know where else to put it.

FINALLY, A PERFECT PLACE TO TALK ABOUT MY CONSPIRACY THEORY! I think the flashback potion didn't tell the truth (or at least not the whole truth). Since the potion only responds to alicorn magic, it's very likely that Princess Celestia had something to do with its creation, and she did something so whoever drank it would only see what she wanted them to see. Now, the theory that I truly believe is that she changed Princess Luna's appearance in the flashback so nobody would realize she'd banished a filly who looked no older than 14 to the moon, and she may have changed her own appearance as well because she was ashamed that her hair had become the way it is now after she banished her own sister to the moon. But that's not crazy, so here's the crazy theory. Princess Celestia didn't just change a few details. She changed the entire event. What actually happened was that Luna started a rebellion against Celestia's tyrannical rule and that's the real reason she was banished to the moon. And Princess Celestia and Princess Luna didn't really defeat Discord together. Discord and Princess Luna were leading the rebellion together, and that's the real reason Princess Celestia turned him into stone. Princess Luna was the one who later freed him. Princess Celestia doesn't know that Princess Luna did it. It was actually Princess Luna's idea to "reform" Discord. She pretended it was so his powers could be used for what Princess Celestia said was good, but really it was so Princess Luna and Discord could continue planning the rebellion. Discord hopes that by being friends with Fluttershy he will eventually be able to show her and the rest of the Mane Six that Princess Celestia is actually evil and they'll use the Elements of Harmony against her. The producers of the show are actually servants of Princess Celestia and will never show us what's REALLY going on.

I've seen tons of people say they don't have electricity in My Little Pony. Why do people keep saying that? I've seen light switches tons of times. And remember when Pinkie was interrogating Spike in "Party of One"? She had an electric lamp! And in "Testing Testing 1, 2, 3", Rainbow Dash asked if she could just watch the History of the Wonderbolts movie. Therefore they must have TV (even though I can't think of a time when they've actually shown one). Why do people keep saying there's no electricity? Why is part of what I typed highlighted in light gray...

I hated it, but after reading what everybody else likes so much about it, I guess it's okay. But I'm very disappointed. I actually felt like I was watching a little kid show. Before I read what everybody else likes so much about it, I thought it was almost as bad as that G3 episode where everybody's freaking out because they all wanna get their friend the exact same thing for her birthday. I was tempted to refuse to watch it with my grandpa later.

I was trying to watch it on bronytv.net, but it kept on freezing. At first it just paused when it froze, but then it kept on going when it froze and I missed something important. I don't wanna wait until it's on iTunes tomorrow! Is there any place that already has it uploaded?

So I'll be able to watch the episodes as they air on TV? I don't care if there are ads. I'd rather have to watch ads than not watch the episodes when they air.

I'd prefer for it to be free, but I don't mind paying as long as it's not expensive like cable.

That's a relief. That stuff sounded really stupid. I already thought it was fake. I just wanted to be sure.

I just found this thing with a bunch of season 5 spoilers (well, actually just four spoilers), and I was wondering if it's a joke or something. Here's the link: http://www.wattpad.com/story/17729430-mlp-season-5-spoilers

That's not what I meant. Luna was acting differently. She wasn't using the Royal Canterlot Voice in the Nightmare Rarity arc. Why would she use it on Nightmare Night when she didn't use it when talking to ordinary ponies before? And didn't you see Tank? Tank didn't become Rainbow Dash's pet until later that season. So it had to have been after Luna Eclipsed.

No, that doesn't make sense. Look at the way she was interacting with the ponies in Ponyville.