Living dreams and nightmares among the pony populace?

[ManaMinori 4,145]

Looking at "Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?", We see Luna has literally used her powers to give life to a sentient, living nightmare homunculus, with it's own powers that allow it to walk both the nightmare and dream planes, but exist in the waking world as well.

 

And in the FIENDship is Magic comics, we find that Luna/NMM learned her dream abilities from the Nyx, who have been influencing pony dreams since before the royal sisters (possibly since the dawn of time).

 

If a living, sentient nightmare can be created, and influence the waking world, then can a living dream do the same? What if a certain Sunbutt solar princess is a created dream by either by Luna (after the original Sunbutt went missing in episode 2, and between the time NMM was stripped from Luna, and the "reappearance" of "Sunbutt", Either Luna, or the Nyx created the replacement dream Sunbutt, and she's been around ever since?

 

What do you guys think? If living nightmares can be made and Influence the waking world, can living dreams do the same?

 

Is Sunbutt living dream?

 

Who else might be created dreams from Luna or the Nyx's interference? (I have an inkling a certain pony named Star Dreams might also be....)

[Johnny1226 14,674]

It could be possible though once something enters the physical world it ceases to be a dream and becomes real so if celestia was such a creature she would still be celestia in most ways the only difference would be that her own memories of her experiences would be gone and she would only know what others knew of her

[ManaMinori 4,145]

On 3/20/2017 at 9:40 PM, Johnny1226 said:

It could be possible though once something enters the physical world it ceases to be a dream and becomes real so if celestia was such a creature she would still be celestia in most ways the only difference would be that her own memories of her experiences would be gone and she would only know what others knew of her

well of course, otherwise it wouldn't be tangible in the real world. i don't think memories would be an issue. if she were born  or- created, rather, as a dream, then she couldn't have the ability to make memories herself. But upon entering the waking world, then yeah. She'd be a real pony