About My S9 Theories...

[Darkness Void 51]

So I've this theory in my head for a long time now. Btw this might contain a spoiler or two if you haven't seen Flurry Of Emotions or S8's final. So be warned. Let us begin with this.

Cozy Glow's plan seems a bit unfinished to me. After all, her goal was to get rid of all magic yet did not do a thing regarding the Tree nor the Elements. And after she was caught, sealed inside Tartarus likely without her parents' knowledge mind you, and she just smiles. But...if her aim was to get into Tartarus why didn't she just do so and not alert anybody until it was too late?

My guess? There's something in there she wanted, but what could that be? At first my theory was the Alicorn Amulet which I believe is the 7Th Element, corrupted. But there just isn't anything to back it up---but I'll post what I do know:

A red gem, one that changed your magical aura to red, and resembles the other 6 gems....this fits both the Alicorn Amulet AND Sunset's Geode. But, Rainbow's pony Element is red, and the only Geode without a matching color is Rarity's white Geode (unless you count that pearl we saw in the storybook flashback way back in 1, and again in S4's opener). The Alicorn Amulet corrupts the user, so therefore is corrupted itself.

 

The show has been hinting to us that there is a 7Th Element, being that of green. Now, there is a green Element....right here (we known the pearl is where Twilight's Element is hidden). However, note these 2 images.

As stone.

Wielded by the princesses.

The green Element just vanishes (and the shape of the gems does not match when they are stoned, were there other bearers before the Mane6? Plus the Elements when shattered, look pretty similar to the Geodes don't ya think?)....but wait...There it is! But the Mane6 fail to notice it, as did Nightmare Moon...My personal theory, the ONLY way for this to make sense, is this. Celestia found the green Element after defeating Nightmare Moon. But then why wasn't it in the Tree Of Harmony? Maybe it's at the roots? From here I suggest youtubing Dr.Wolf and Applegeek, both of whom put forward a theory that holds serious weight to them. Or you can look at this image.

BAM! But wait, the symbol is wrong...and Slenderpony is an uncanon easter egg...

Quote

The Devil's greatest trick? Making the world believe that he was gone.

And there you have it. So, what are your thoughts? I'll also link this image, of a character we are likely going to see without any doubt.

Concept art from the 2017 film, I think.

Where was I? Ah, yeah my theory holds very little water to what others have said. But my next theory could very well be true. Is it a known fact within the show that if it's in a book, it's canon. Nightmare Moon's return (which is a paradox when you think of the sealed forever bit, me thinks Celestia lifted that seal herself), the Dazzlings, Tirek's first defeat, and even Snowfall Frost's story could had been true.

And Grogar was name dropped in Flurry Of Emotions. In a book, being defeated. And where do baddies go when their defeated and not stoned? TARTARUS!

Cue Spike

Whose Grogar? Here's his Wiki page.

So my theory is that Grogar is what Cozy is after. But then, why alert Equestria? Why bother with the first plan? I have an answer, and it's from a brony who I wish was still following the show.

 

[EpicEnergy 23,247]

That's a good theory! I like it!