Jump to content
Banner by ~ Ice Princess Silky
  • entries
    31
  • comments
    54
  • views
    9,015

Nürburgring Nordschleife 2015 crash analysis


Admiral Regulus

869 views

This is the crash I'm referring to:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9eUwJ79fvo

 

And the same crash from a second point of view:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5quxhNEio_g

 

This doesn't even look real, but I can assure you it is. So, what happened here? Why is it that a car—especially one with such tremendous downforce—could do something so crazy as this? Well, first, I think it's important to take a closer look at how these aerodynamic systems work.

 

Think of what happens when you're skating on ice. You slide. You have less friction with the ground, so you can't grip it to walk like you normally would. Now, imagine that you're carrying a heavy weight over your head, and this weight pushes your shoes into the ice (without breaking it). The force of the weight would give you better grip and allow you to walk on the ice, right? Sure, that makes sense.

 

So, obviously, the better you can grip the ground, the faster and easier it is for you to walk. Race cars work by this same principle—the more weight there is pushing down against the ground, the more power can be applied without the wheels slipping.

 

 

Notice there how at around 35 seconds in, the wheels start to spin, but they slip on the ground. Now imagine that if there was a force pushing the car to the ground, the wheels wouldn't slip, and the motion would be transferred entirely to the car. Thus, the car would be faster.

 

This is where downforce comes in. Using wings, race cars generate a literal force pushing downward, and this helps the car stick to the ground. It does so without adding mass to the vehicle, so acceleration is largely unimpeded. This is why more downforce is generally better.

 

The rear wing of the car is what generates downforce. It works in the same way a plane's wing generates lift, just in reverse. The wing creates a pressure difference in the air around it, so that a force is generated on the wing itself. This force pushes the rear of the car downward. This force allows the tires to grip the road better, which, as I mentioned, allows for better cornering and more stability.

 

So, why is it that this one time, the downforce didn't work? You saw that car—it was literally flying. Something must have gone horribly wrong here, but what?

 

The answer is actually not that complicated. Notice that before the car takes off, it is coming up on a hill. Due to the car's speed, the front of the car comes off the ground a little at the top of the hill. When this happened, it reached a critical angle. It reached the angle at which the air flowing under the front of the car starts to push the front upward.

 

So, what we have is a car with a front end going upward, and a rear end going downward. This creates a moment, or a torque, or a spin, most informally. The back goes down, the front goes up, and voila! You're airborne. The car still has downforce, but it's all in the back of the car. The front of the car loses its downforce, and instead creates lift. Effectively, the whole thing acts like a wing, and up it goes.

 

Still don't believe me on this? Consider what would happen if you have a sheet of paper sitting on a desk. If there's no wind, the paper won't move. If there's a little wind, the paper still may not move. But if you lift the edge of the paper up slightly and into the wind, air will flow between the paper and the desk, and this will push the paper up, up, and away.

 

These cars work in a similar way; they're just heavier and we're talking about much stronger winds. Once that front end goes up, it's like that sheet of paper in the wind.

 

As crazy as it looks, the phenomenon is hardly as uncommon as you'd think. This isn't the only time race cars do this. This happened once to a Mercedes prototype in 1999, and again to a Porsche in 2008...

 

 

 

Notice how it always starts as the car rounds the peak of a hill. Notice how the back end still keeps pushing downward, even when the front of the car is high in the air. That's the combination of downforce and lift at work, simultaneously.

 

There is one crash that doesn't involve the car first going over a hill, though. It's this one.

 

 

So what happened in this case? When the Ferrari hit the prototype, the left rear wheel came off. You can see it rolling along the track. This impact made the left rear corner of the car go down, and by extension, the right front corner of the car came up. It's the same problem, just a different cause. The motion, in principle, allowed too much air to flow under the car, and again, the whole thing acted like a wing. Up, up, and away!

 

And to think some people say flying cars are infeasible. Nonsense! :P

  • Brohoof 1

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

Cars have been catching air at Flugplatz since forever, so I find it astonishing that a blowover like this only happened now. One thing that puzzles me is that the GT-R GT3 is seemingly more prone to wheelie than other GT3 cars at that section. I also figure that Jann was doing ~150 MPH when the car took off.

 

GTR_wheelieR_large.jpg?v=1377251348

 

Someone on Jalopnik suggested that cutting GT3 cars by 50 HP and a mandatory ride height rise could prevent that. I think differently.

 

As much flak as I would get for saying this, but I think the Nordschleife should be either done away with, or heavily reworked to meet German road regulations (because the ring is considered a public road).

Link to comment

 

 

As much flak as I would get for saying this, but I think the Nordschleife should be either done away with, or heavily reworked to meet German road regulations (because the ring is considered a public road).

 

Naw, I understand completely. I agree. This particular problem aside, the track is still largely unsafe. It's not just because of the hills, but because of the way the barriers and runoff areas are designed.

 

As stupid as NASCAR can be, we (Americans) have actually learned a lot about safety from stock car racing.

Link to comment

As stupid as NASCAR can be, we (Americans) have actually learned a lot about safety from stock car racing.

 

We know because that's what we watch here...

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...