Here is my personal scorecard for all of MLP! It's just my personal opinions at work for the episodes, so don't take this as me saying "this is a be-all, end-all list." Anyway, without further adieu here's my list (posted in chronological order for each category):

 

LOVED IT!:

Applebuck Season

Dragonshy

Swarm of the Century

Winter Wrap-Up

Suited for Success

Sonic Rainboom

A Dog and Pony Show

Green Isn't Your Color

The Cutie Mark Chronicles

Party of One

The Best Night Ever

-----

The Return of Harmony

Lesson Zero

Luna Eclipsed

Sisterhooves Social

Sweet and Elite

Secret of My Excess

Family Appreciation Day

A Friend In Deed

Hurricane Fluttershy

Ponyville Confidential

A Canterlot Wedding

-----

Too Many Pinkie Pies

Magic Duel

Sleepless in Ponyville

Wonderbolts Academy

Magical Mystery Cure

-----

Flight to the Finish

Bats!

Rarity Takes Manehattan

Pinkie Apple Pie

Pinkie Pride

Filli Vanilli

Twilight Time

Maud Pie

For Whom the Sweetie Belle Toils

Testing Testing 1, 2, 3

Inspiration Manifestation

Equestria Games

Twilight's Kingdom

 

 

LIKED IT!:

Griffon the Brush Off

Look Before You Sleep

Call of the Cutie

Fall Weather Friends

-----

Hearth's Warming Eve

Baby Cakes

The Last Roundup

Read It and Weep

Hearts and Hooves Day

Putting Your Hoof Down

It's About Time

-----

The Crystal Empire

Keep Calm and Flutter On

Just for Sidekicks

Games Ponies Play

-----

Princess Twilight Sparkle

Castle Mane-ia

Daring Don't

Three's a Crowd

Simple Ways

It Ain't Easy Being Breezies

Leap of Faith

 

 

MEH:

Friendship is Magic

Bridle Gossip

Feeling Pinkie Keen

Stare Master

The Show Stoppers

Over a Barrel

A Bird in the Hoof

-----

The Cutie Pox

May the Best Pet Win!

The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000

MMMystery on the Friendship Express

-----

Apple Family Reunion

Spike At Your Service

-----

Equestria Girls

-----

Power Ponies

Somepony To Watch Over Me

Trade Ya!

 

 

DISLIKED IT!:

The Ticket Master

Boast Busters

Owl's Well That Ends Well

-----

The Mysterious Mare Do Well

Dragon Quest

-----

One Bad Apple

-----

Rainbow Falls

 

 

Feel free to leave feedback, or ask questions below!