Jump to content
Banner by ~ Kyoshi Frost Wolf
  • entries
    7
  • comments
    32
  • views
    3,828

Distancing Myself From The Brony Fandom


AegisReflector

1,062 views

You guys may have been wondering why I haven't posted at all lately, despite me saying that I would be active come the late Spring after I returned from my first leave. Well, besides the obvious reasons of work and college studies taking up my internet time, there is a reason that goes beyond that.

 

I have become disillusioned with the entire Brony community in general. I have been a fan of the show ever since the end of the first season and during that time, I've met some really nice people from specific IRC chats, Facebook pages, and of course, right here on MLPForums, which I registered for around 2 years ago. Members like Chaotic Discord and Artemis were awesome to me during my time here, and Artemis was even the one to convince me to stay when I decided to leave for a bit the first time. But, just looking at the recent forum community and throughout all the Internet, I think it's safe for me to say this: while the Brony community is certainly not dying, it's becoming more and more of a plague.

 

Everytime I come on here and look at the Show Discussion Boards, I mainly see topics that have so much insignificant drama in them that really isn't needed, such as the "taboo" conversations about Alicorn Twilight and Equestria Girls. I mean, geez guys, I don't think I've even seen these many confrontations in the Trekkie realms when panel nerds scream "KIRK!" "PICARD!" "KIRK!" "PICARD!" And quite frankly, the moderators don't merge any of the topics that deal with these sort of complaints, so naturally, that's pretty much all I see besides the usual speculation topics and storyline guesses, although even that sometimes can transform into a fight between the EG haters and lovers. >.> I get sick of the community tearing itself apart over such retarded arguments. If you don't have faith in EG, then okay, stfu please and leave the lovers alone. Don't make it your crusade to purge all hope for it. Also, it's not just on here I'm talking about, it's pretty much a topic that's still debated on Facebook and /mlp/. I've pretty much unliked all Pony FB pages at this point anyways because all they do is likewhore shitty fan fic and gifs.

 

Oh yeah, and the fan fics too? Screw them to hell, literally. FiMFiction is cancer, and here's why. Most of the stories I read on there are DISGUSTING. Shipping loopholes, violent grimdark stories, raunchy deviant escapades, etc. MLP is a children's show, for starters. Ever since the dumbass creation of Cupcakes came out, psychos came out of the woodwork and started to make even more ridiculous stories about innocent ponies chopping each other up without any sense of set-up or direction. It's literally the norm now to make the most raunchy or gruesome material out of a show that is meant for a wholesome family. It's sickening. It's like trying to glorify a story about Mr. Rogers slicing one of his children's head open while the trolley continuously runs over and mangles their dead body. People just do this shit for attention, and again, most of these stories serve no rhyme or reason. In order for a story to have beauty, one must embrace their writing with the utmost of care, which fan fiction writers rarely do.

 

Also, I also have seen many "e-celeb" Bronies that the community looks up to that are wicked assholes to their fans, like CelticBrony, Yells At Cats, and MandoPony. Hell, Yells At Cats even degraded an autistic fan of his on Skype by offering him a fake record contract to record music. You know, because this community tries to thrive on "friendship" and to "love and tolerate" and yet he just goes and mocks the autistic kid who doesn't know any better, ironic considering that's what dicks from 4chan basically call the community, just a bunch of autistic neckbeards. Well, here's an idea. Maybe our "spokespeople" for our community should stop acting like elitist asses and just enjoy the show for what it is. Tsch, making raps about Applejack while at the same time incorporating drugs and genocide? Yeah, stay classy.

 

I might be ranting on and on, but in the end, I just don't have time to put up with the various things this community has done in the past months or so. I'm just going to stop supporting the whole culture in general. I'm still a big fan of the show, and will await EG and Season 4 with great pleasure, but as far as expressing interest into going to Cons and such, not interested.

 

Before you all say that "every community has their share of problems", I understand that. But to me, this community was very special at first because people were genuinely being nice enough to watch the show and to share their insecurities and to push over the boundaries of gender roles and to spread a social message. Now it's all about backstabbing, image, and popularity. People don't care about the actual show as much as the fan created content or the Cons. I guess you can call me a "Conservative Brony" on that part.

 

Well, whatever. I'm done with this post. If you guys can, give me one good reason why I should stay in the fandom. Because quite frankly, I don't see it happening.

  • Brohoof 1

6 Comments


Recommended Comments

Not sure why people are surprised that YAC is the most despised well known musician in the community. He has continually made wrong move after wrong move. I'm sure he's happy being the bad boy of the community and playing the rebel but most musicians won't have his back now or ever.

 

And this was before Everfree NW con was nearly ruined by the man

 

Yeah the community is being incredibly petty and dumb since the year drought of pony content occurred. Either hang in there and wait for season 4 or move on. But no one needs to beg anyone back or dare anyone to argue for them to stay. It's better to see people leave then to ragequit publically as that's just as useless and attention-seeking. Yes plenty of our fandom sucks right now, plenty does not. But yeah this fandom does not do well w/o fannon powering the ship.

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment

This wasn't for attention seeking. Some members on Skype sent me messages asking if I would return, so I'm giving them my decision .

Link to comment

I've certainly noticed these details about the fandom, but I usually distance myself from them.

 

Twilicorn and EqG? Ignore them. On other sites, it's a matter of scrolling past the thread. Here, there are sections dedicated solely to those controversies; ignoring them is plain and simple. I dislike Twilicorn and EqG like you wouldn't believe, but I hardly ever get involved in those discussions. 

 

Bad fanfics? Even easier. Just don't read them. There may be plenty of grimdark, gore, sexual, or whatever fanfics, but not all fanfics are like that. I've found quite a few fanfics that I've found to be very well written. Even some of the darker ones, if executed the right way, can be great. I've criticized grimdark in the past, but it's easy to avoid. Just don't read or watch them.

 

Asshole celebrities? Even easier. Hell, I haven't even heard of most of those guys you mentioned. I've probably seen their works and listened to their music, but I've never come in contact with them.

 

Personally, I stick around for the better parts of the fandom. I can see how you don't want to be associated with those people, but I don't think it's entirely fair to judge the entire fandom based on these few, easily avoidable issues. 

  • Brohoof 1
Link to comment
*bless this post*

 

Really all of this. Avoid what you don't like, and enjoy what you do.

 

To me, this whole drama is making the time less stale. Besides, it's a cartoon show at the end of the day, so seeing people make such a fuss over this specifically is amusing to no end.

Link to comment

I was just saying that I'm not associated with it anymore. I haven't posted in months as it is and people were worried about me, therefore, I made this post.

 

Simple as that.

Link to comment

"Oh yeah, and the fan fics too? Screw them to hell, literally. FiMFiction is cancer, and here's why......most of these stories serve no rhyme or reason. In order for a story to have beauty, one must embrace their writing with the utmost of care, which fan fiction writers rarely do."

 

Yeah, I can agree on you with that one. There are alot of 'dirty' ones, too, like the "Mature" entitled ones. I don't agree with making things PG-14 or up when it comes to fanfiction-- PG-13 is decent, age-wise, and PG is much near my range. I do really like some fanfiction they have on there, but it seems to get a bit hard to come by. 

 

I've never heard of the people you talked about, the "e-celebs", but they're definitely not worth my time to look up. I don't blame you for avoiding drama or anything like that. I would probably do the same if it really became a "plague" of negativity to me, but so far I've been subconciously avoiding the EG n' Twilight board. Hopefully people will get their senses once S4 comes.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...