Original idea by SBB64. Thought I'd go ahead and do it as well. Get ready for a lot of positive ratings... I like this show.

Ratings are (in order): Amazing, Great, Good, Average, or Mediocre.

Season 1:

Friendship is Magic, pt 1- Good

Friendship is Magic, pt 2- Good

The Ticket Master- Good

Applebuck Season- Good

Griffon the Brush Off- Great

Boast Busters- Mediocre

Dragonshy- Amazing

Look Before You Sleep- Great

Bridle Gossip- Good

Swarm of the Century- Great

Winter Wrap Up- Amazing

Call of the Cutie- Good

Fall Weather Friends- Good

Suited for Success- Amazing

Feeling Pinkie Keen- Great

Sonic Rainboom- Amazing

Stare Master- Great

The Show Stoppers- Good

A Dog and Pony Show- Great

Green Isn't Your Color- Amazing

Over a Barrel- Good

A Bird in the Hoof- Good

The Cutie Mark Chronicles- Amazing

Owl's Well That Ends Well- Mediocre

Party of One- Amazing

The Best Night Ever- Great

Overall- Great

Recap: The premier could have been better, but it was very good nonetheless. There were some amazing episodes scattered throughout this season, marred by only a few "bad apples" as t'were. Shame it didn't have a two parter finale, but there was a great song so it's all good.

Season 2:

Return of Harmony, pt 1- Great

Return of Harmony, pt 2- Great

Lesson Zero- Good

Luna Eclipsed- Great

Sisterhooves Social- Great

The Cutie Pox- Good

May the Best Pet Win!- Great

The Mysterious Mare Do Well- Mediocre

Sweet and Elite- Great

Secret of My Excess- Average

Hearth's Warming Eve- Amazing

Family Appreciation Day- Great

Baby Cakes- Good

The Last Roundup- Great

The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000- Average

Read It and Weep- Amazing

Hearts and Hooves Day- Great

A Friend in Deed- Good

Putting Your Hoof Down- Amazing

It's About Time- Amazing

Dragon Quest- Great

Hurricane Fluttershy- Great

Ponyville Confidential- Great

MMMystery on the Friendship Express- Amazing

A Canterlot Wedding, pt 1- Amazing

A Canterlot Wedding, pt 2- Amazing

Overall- Amazing

Recap: A solid premier and a flat-out awesome finale brought together one amazing season. MMMystery on the Friendship Express brought the non-stop laughs, It's About Time brought the mind-blowing (and excessively adorkable Twili) stuff, Read It And Weep brought Dashie some character development... All awesome.

Season 3:

The Crystal Empire, pt 1- Amazing

The Crystal Empire, pt 2- Amazing

Too Many Pinkie Pies- Great

One Bad Apple- Great

Magic Duel- Great

Sleepless in Ponyville- Great

Wonderbolt Academy- Amazing

Apple Family Reunion- Great

Spike at Your Service- Great

Keep Calm and Flutter On- Great

Just for Sidekicks- Great

Games Ponies Play- Amazing

Magical Mystery Cure- Amazing

Overall- Amazing

Recap: Season 3 is my favorite. It includes some of my favorite episodes (MMC & WA), and my second favorite almost-tied-for-first two parter The Crystal Empire. (Canterlot Wedding is still my favorite ♫This day is going to be perfect♫). Every episode is solid in this season, which makes it amazing overall.