Jump to content
  • entries
    38
  • comments
    155
  • views
    25,121

Science does get it wrong sometimes


Bronium

923 views

You know, a friend asked me "Wouldn't you be devastated if we got all science wrong? They'd have to re-write every physics text book!"

 

Now, I'm not sure if they can re-write velocity and speed. I mean, it's not really theoretical. It's kind of giving a quantitative measure to something qualitative, but I presume their talking about more theoretical stuff like particle physics.

 

And would I be devastated? Well, maybe initially (I even doubt this). But I'd get over it. And you know what? I'd even be a bit excited. I mean, imagine all the new research we could do? All the interesting discoveries that we'd make? I mean, sure we make interesting discoveries now, but still. It's like a whole new world. Well, the same old world, but seeing it with new eyes.

 

But that's not what I wanted to talk about. I mean, from the whole neutrinos faster than the speed of light thing(which was an error in the measuring equipment, I think), people liked the idea of going to their science teachers and saying "Nuh, uh!"

 

What we'd so is pretty much well known (this'll sound like a joke at the end of this).

 

What I'm going to talk about is how science sometimes does get it wrong and what that means to me. Yes, science does get it wrong. Yes, but really, what it comes down to is, what is science?

 

Science is the collection of human knowledge. It's what we know, or at least think we know. And what we know changes, because we realized that what we knew, isn't what we know. Science is about change. It's how we change what we know. Without change, it's not science.

 

And if science changes, the thing that science changed from was wrong.

 

And even then, the science wasn't really science. I mean, by my definition Aristotle's whole element thing was science. And we wouldn't even consider that science anymore.

 

Even so, "science" gets it wrong. And you know what? I'm okay with that. Because that's what makes it great.

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

Indeed. Years ago, it was just assumed that the world follows Newtonian cause-and-effect physics, and now, Quantum Mechanics is becoming more and more accepted, despite the fact that it's essentially destroying most of what Newtonian physics had "proven." Not because Newtonian physicists were completely incorrect in the factual way, but because they were simply looking at it in a way that may not have been entirely correct, and now that this new viewpoint is becoming accepted, we're making all kinds of amazing discoveries. (Which, of course, may still not have the right perspective. Hell, this may be just another stepping stone to something that makes even less sense.)

Link to comment

It's one of my favorite things about science: the fact that if we were wrong, we don't go "ah, goddammit, all that work down the drain! You know what, fuck it, I'm going to deny this ever happened and continue in my false ideas!". We go "Wait, really? That's a bit annoying maybe, but now there's so much new stuff to discover, and we already have a place to start!"

 

So yeah, if some scientists came out next week and produced extremely strong evidence of a ton of stuff I've studied being false, I'd be a bit bummed at first, but I'd be eager to jump straight into the research papers and find out what they found.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Join the herd!

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...