hearths warming contest Our Judging Criteria

[***** 138]

We want to be as transparent as possible so we're releasing our Judging Criteria to let you guys know how you'll be graded.

 

View the spreadsheet here

 

All songs submitted will be judged under these categories from 0-10. These scores are averaged out until we have an average per category, then these averages are totalled up to give us the score for each track.

 

If you have any questions or concerns about our scoring system, let us know

[Jonny Music 3,400]

How will we know how the evaluation of the final score for our tracks?

Some of us (if not all) are really curious on what each of the judges scored (even by each category) on our tracks that resulted to the final scores for them.

Because we would be really eager to know how we can improve on our tracks in the future.

Edited December 28, 2016 by Jonny Music

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

I'm sorry I have to say this but...as a musician of 17 years of piano and 7 years of composing...I strongly disagree with the top 3 tracks...I am not saying this because I am upset I only came in 4th, just missing 3rd by .02, I am saying this from my music experience. 

[***** 138]

How will we know how the evaluation of the final score for our tracks?

 

Some of us (if not all) are really curious on what each of the judges scored (even by each category) on our tracks that resulted to the final scores for them.

 

Because we would be really eager to know how we can improve on our tracks in the future.

 

Yep, we're releasing the scores in a few minutes. Keep your eyes on the Pony.fm forums

I'm sorry I have to say this but...as a musician of 17 years of piano and 7 years of composing...I strongly disagree with the top 3 tracks...I am not saying this because I am upset I only came in 4th, just missing 3rd by .02, I am saying this from my music experience. 

 

Sorry you feel that way. Better luck next year