Rank Every Season 1 Episode from Favorite to Least

[Lone Traveler 87]

Episodes to Rank:

Friendship is Magic 
Ticket Master
Applebuck Season
Griffon the Brush-Off
Boast Busters
Dragonshy
Look Before You Sleep
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Winter Wrap Up
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
Stare Master
The Show Stoppers
A Dog And Pony Show
Green Isn't Your Color
Over A Barrel
A Bird In The Hoof
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Owl's Well That Ends Well
Party of One
The Best Night Ever

(Copy and paste this list into this tool: https://czeckd.github.io/preference-revealer/dist/ )

My Ranking:

Amazing:
1: Dragonshy
2: The Cutie Mark Chronicles
3: Sonic Rainboom
4: Over A Barrel
5: Party of One

Great:
6: Suited For Success
7: Green Isn't Your Color
8: Feeling Pinkie Keen (guilty pleasure)
9: A Dog And Pony Show
10: The Best Night Ever
11: Griffon the Brush-Off
12: Swarm of the Century
13: Applebuck Season
14: Friendship is Magic

Good:
15: Fall Weather Friends
16: Bridle Gossip
17: Stare Master
18: Look Before You Sleep

Meh:
19: Call of the Cutie
20: Winter Wrap Up
21: Ticket Master
22: A Bird In The Hoof

Bad:
23: The Show Stoppers
24: Owl's Well That Ends Well
25: Boast Busters

 

 

Edited June 12, 2022 by Lone Traveler

[The Second Opinion 269]

*Chef's Kiss* That was how it's done!
1. The Cutie Mark Chronicles
2. Friendship is Magic
3. Sonic Rainboom
4. Over A Barrell
5. Winter Wrap Up
6. Fall Weather Friends
7. Applebuck Season
8. The Best Night Ever

A-Grade! In fact, was it really necessary to make this a different tier...?
9. Feeling Pinkie Keen (Your "backdoor religious parable" analysis is not interesting)

Sweet, occasionally hilarious A-/B+ life lesson-ing:
10. Look Before You Sleep
11. Griffon the Brush Off
12. A Bird in the Hoof (Because wishy-washy people who can't assert, like so, try to solve the problem instead when no one's looking, that was why )

Flawed but ambitious and good:
13. Party of One
14. Suited For Success
15. Dragonshy
16. Stare Master

Plain old fun, with a useful lesson. (Possibly STILL could've made my top 10, in later seasons):
17. The Ticket Master
18. Bridle Gossip

Decent, perfectly watchable:
19. A Dog and Pony Show
20. The Show Stoppers
21. Swarm of the Century
22. Call of the Cutie
23. Boast Busters

Meh. Redeemed by some heart, here and there:
24. Owl's Well That Ends Well

Doesn't do enough to justify its existence:
25. Green Isn't Your Color