How canon are the G5 comics to G4?

[WickedGames 240]

Would you consider the G5 comics canon?

I know there was debates about the G4 comics being canon but don’t think it’s the same for the G5 comics?

[Otaku-sempai 460]

The G5 comics canonical to G4? Maybe to some extent, but not entirely. I'm pretty sure that the G5 Equestria should be very far away from the ruins of Canterlot or Ponyville, especially now that we can look at Gillian Berrow's G5 show bible.

Quote

Twilight tasked her friends with the sacred responsibility of protecting the crystals and the magic they contained. She asked them to take the crystals to the wilds of unexplored Equestria – farther than anypony had ever traveled; there the ponies would remain, dedicating their lives to protecting the magic in a far away place.

Earth Ponies Pinkie Pie and Applejack took their crystal to the farthest edge of the land, where the mountains met the sea. Unicorns Rarity and Starlight Glimmer took their crystal to the deepest depths of a forbidding forest. And Pegasi Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy flew to the highest peaks with their crystal. As an extra layer of protection, Twilight added a cloaking spell, placing the three lands in an incredibly strong “invisibubble” enchantment so that they would be hidden away from the outside world. This way, Opaline could never find them again.

And the charts in the Set Your Sail miniseries don't make much sense when looking at the G4 maps. 

[WickedGames 240]

1 hour ago, Otaku-sempai said:

The G5 comics canonical to G4? Maybe to some extent, but not entirely. I'm pretty sure that the G5 Equestria should be very far away from the ruins of Canterlot or Ponyville, especially now that we can look at Gillian Berrow's G5 show bible.

And the charts in the Set Your Sail miniseries don't make much sense when looking at the G4 maps. 

Do you think “The Storm of Zephyr Hights” is canon?

[Otaku-sempai 460]

5 hours ago, WickedGames said:

Do you think “The Storm of Zephyr Hights” is canon?

To G4? That's hard to say. We've only seen one issue so far. But I tend to think of all of G5 as an alternate universe at this point. Maybe two alternate universes since some of the comics don't really fit into the show(s) well.